I believe there's also another normal starting up soon. I think it was delayed due to many games starting at the same time as well as the other normal having difficulty filling up.
More to the point, saying "he's obv scum let's vig him" is lazy. It's one thing to be pro-vigging, and another to be trying to slip it through as a consensus thing without talking it out.
I seem to recall him being atop many peoples' scum lists, but the point is irrelevant. He is being vigged tonight. If you want to change that fact, discuss it with the vig.
(Side note: Rereading today, Dagger, ced, Ged, Cyan and I seem to be in favor of killing Wrath_of_Dog based on outright statements or scumlists, while only desCoures and you have said anything against the vigging.)
In any event, that was a reply to andelijah not you. You apparently have the ability tomake good on your suspicion for better or for worse. It is also in character. It is much iffier for ande to be trying to get around the information of a lynch wagon (not to mention the increased certainty of the target actually dying)
I was trying to lynch him: I voted him. Then Cyan and Ged come along telling people not to bother because they were going to finish him tonight. I have no preference as to how he dies, so long as it happens.
Cyan would be. Pushing kills on two potentially townies the town would not think highly of him.
And why is this a bad thing if you think he's scum?
Its just to easy for scum to jump on and get that kind of wagon going.
So your defense is basically "trust me, I'm town"? Yes, it would be easy for scum to jump on you, if you were town who is acting scummy. Or you could simply be a scum who is acting scummy - you haven't explained how we should differentiate the two, nor why we should come to the former conclusion instead of the latter.
To push for a lynch for lack of post early on is not that helpful. Having a large margin of the town going after someone thats lagging behind in posts is taking away from weeding out scum.
You do not have a lack of posts: you're in the top half. You have a lack of content - in all those posts you've made you've contributed nothing.
@Cyan, how do you know about Ged?
I don't target at night only during the day.
A doc that kills I don't see it. Put in all that time protecting just to kill? Alot of time to put in for things to go right.
Cyan has just found his way on my scum list.
If I'm lynched, look to him.
Suspicion entirely based on role analysis?
The game was built so that everyone started out as town (or neutral). I do not see anyone false claiming. Which means that I'm frowning at Cyan too for claiming, but eh, he's already claimed.
Very convenient Cyan. Maybe some work for a cop. You better hope WOD does not come up town like I will because it will be an easy lynch for the town then.
This makes no sense at all. Who will be an easy lynch? And why is this a good or bad thing?
Why do you doubt that? There were 4 SK's plus a vig in Battle Royale. With 24 players you don't think there'd be day protection?
Battle Royale was far from a standard game. In most games, there is a mafia group, a vigilante, and a serial killer.
Quote from Archmage Eternal »
I find it hard to see where I am scum. Especially seeing how people are claiming that I haven't produced much of anything in this game but the votes are pilling up.
I'm not sure why there is a problem with you not contributing anything and votes landing on you for it. You'll have to explain that one.
But your scumminess can be summarized as follows:
1) You have produced no content thus far.
2) When you do post, you ignore large parts of the accusations against you.
Unvote, Vote desCoures. I was suspicious of CC yesterday, and that slip only makes me more suspicious of you.
You caught him.
He was definitely scum in those games.
Secondly: Is it REALLY necessary to vote for me given my disability? Can't you please, as I asked right at the start, express suspicion of me in a non game-relevant way? FOS or IGMEOY, or even "FOS with intent to lynch", at least until it there is a consensus that it is time to lynch me?
Since I don't plan on unvoting today, nor tomorrow should you survive, I'm not sure what the problem is.
Until you get to lynch -4 or something, your ability is hardly relevant.
Funny how everyone made quite a big deal on Day 1 about someone voting WoD, and now it is done without hesitation.
The difference is that I have reason to vote. Night Archer caught flak for voting essentially because Wrath_of_Dog asked people not to, and only Ged asked Jobie about his vote, and the point was dropped shortly thereafter.
Wrath_of_Dog's role only poses a problem in the event he gets wagoned and then people want to back off.
@Andelijah: There's no real point making an effort towards, WoD. I am as convinced as ever of his scumminess; and will take this matter into my own hands tonight.
I am glad, but even if I wanted to, its not like I could unvote.
well, you say the GF is scum, which rather fundamentally alters the read on everyone else
I feel like, as clan leader, I should set up one of these... But I'm not really sure what kind of extracts to use...
Take some scenario that people actually have to use to get a read of people - such as a counterclaim, case, or just something you saw to lead you to a correct read, and see if other people see it as well.
As for the game: Warhammer 40K
Godfather = Sobek = Town
Allen = andelijah = Survivor
Steve = StormBlind = Town
Colin = Cyan = Scum
Isaac = iLord = Town
James = JodoYodo = Survivor
Rachel = RafaelK = Town
Thomas = TravelingLaundromat (= Niv) = Scum
Charles = carrion pigeons = Anti-town Neutral
Arnold = armlx = Anti-town Neutral
Vivian = velict = Town
I think Ecophagy went over the top with the non-town guesses. If I had to pick, I'd say Skander is the closest, as although he missed the Godfather's alignment, he got that the two mafia wagoners were anti-town.
(Side note: Rereading today, Dagger, ced, Ged, Cyan and I seem to be in favor of killing Wrath_of_Dog based on outright statements or scumlists, while only desCoures and you have said anything against the vigging.)
I was trying to lynch him: I voted him. Then Cyan and Ged come along telling people not to bother because they were going to finish him tonight. I have no preference as to how he dies, so long as it happens.
So your defense is basically "trust me, I'm town"? Yes, it would be easy for scum to jump on you, if you were town who is acting scummy. Or you could simply be a scum who is acting scummy - you haven't explained how we should differentiate the two, nor why we should come to the former conclusion instead of the latter.
You do not have a lack of posts: you're in the top half. You have a lack of content - in all those posts you've made you've contributed nothing.
Vote: Alx2
Welcome back.
The game was built so that everyone started out as town (or neutral). I do not see anyone false claiming. Which means that I'm frowning at Cyan too for claiming, but eh, he's already claimed.
This makes no sense at all. Who will be an easy lynch? And why is this a good or bad thing?
Battle Royale was far from a standard game. In most games, there is a mafia group, a vigilante, and a serial killer.
I'm not sure why there is a problem with you not contributing anything and votes landing on you for it. You'll have to explain that one.
But your scumminess can be summarized as follows:
1) You have produced no content thus far.
2) When you do post, you ignore large parts of the accusations against you.
He was definitely scum in those games.
Since I don't plan on unvoting today, nor tomorrow should you survive, I'm not sure what the problem is.
Until you get to lynch -4 or something, your ability is hardly relevant.
Colin = Cyan = Scum.
Even with 4 neutrals?
Wrath_of_Dog's role only poses a problem in the event he gets wagoned and then people want to back off.
As for the game:
Warhammer 40K
Godfather = Sobek = Town
Allen = andelijah = Survivor
Steve = StormBlind = Town
Colin = Cyan = Scum
Isaac = iLord = Town
James = JodoYodo = Survivor
Rachel = RafaelK = Town
Thomas = TravelingLaundromat (= Niv) = Scum
Charles = carrion pigeons = Anti-town Neutral
Arnold = armlx = Anti-town Neutral
Vivian = velict = Town
I think Ecophagy went over the top with the non-town guesses. If I had to pick, I'd say Skander is the closest, as although he missed the Godfather's alignment, he got that the two mafia wagoners were anti-town.