That's the vote ability I thought CP had, but I don't think he keeps them when people unvote. Back when Fade wanted to test him, I voted him and he promptly demonstrated 2 votes. Then I unvoted and he went back to 1 for the rest of the day.
My position on Dagger is more or less this:
Quote from Puzzle »
Dagger's role could be mafia or town but unlikely SK and as Axelrod mentioned, he isn't the cake-sender, nor the mafia killer of last night. He's worth leaving alone for now and I hope he'll think of what I said in my PM to the group.
Alx, is there any reason to hold your results? If you die today, we don't get them. If you die later, we don't get them. If you don't die later, you can keep giving us the results. What's the problem? And giving us evidence that clears you of being the SK seems like something you'd want to do, not sit on.
I like the case on Dagger, though I'll give him a chance to defend himself before voting.
For role-players we've got DYH and RafK now as people that've been forced to, yes? Maybe it's an every other night thing? Also, I'm convinced it's a mechanic / ability. There's no reason DYH would have role-played otherwise. Theoretically RafK could just be lying, but DYH was town. He told us he had to role-play and had no reason to lie.
HE: Were you forced to role-play?
AG being caked means very little in regards to his alignment. I don't want to swim in that lake of wine.
For starters, RafK's new restriction is the most hilarious thing I've ever seen in a mafia game. Good times.
On a related note, can anyone who's been hit by the 'role-playing bug' let us know if it was a bad thing? I want to know whether or not we should be looking for the source.
Grak: What was the case on Dagger yesterday beyond the fact that he hasn't done much?
I'd be interested to know if RafK is, in fact, vanilla considering Puzzle's wore off just after Fade's death.
Quote from ZDS »
Speaking about this, CP, today is the day we test the validity of your votes. Right ?
I know fade figured out (or at least thought he had) how CP's vote worked on day 1, and I'm pretty sure I've got it, too. I want to see him try and multi-vote before I spill anything, though. Also on CP,
Quote from ZDS »
Quote from puzzle »
@ CP : You paid attention to the type of smiley he used every day before knowing he was a "Mafia Emoter" ? Impressive. Remind me to lynch you some day.
QFT
QFT
Axel's list of possible day-killers (+ himself) should be useful. Whether or not his intentions are good, I think the logic makes sense. It's at least a starting point of where to go today. Oh, and Cyan's role as he's claimed is fine if Axel is the SK. A pseudo-unkillable SK that can still be lynched is ok.
I will certainly not answer this. Just the fact that I know it would harm should be enough to you.
I have none. I know it isn't great but I base it on my feelings ; I believed he was a good lynch yesterday, and I do not matter how weak or strong my argumentation was : I still feel it this way.
I wonder... On the previous days, votes were accumulating a lot more quicker. (even though players were dropping them after the claims). I know that people will say that they don't find Hawkeye or Loran suspicious, and that is why they do not vote him, but on day 1, there were scum voting and "helping us" to lynch ; today, they are not (or so I think), from which I conclude that Loran (and probably Hawkeye) are both scum. We just need to focus on one or the other.
If this is all you have to say, then don't bother to ask us to get back on the hawkeye wagon again. Just because a wagon "is not moving very fast" does not mean that Hawkeye is scum. That's just craplogic to the max, imo.
My position on Dagger is more or less this:
I like the case on Dagger, though I'll give him a chance to defend himself before voting.
For role-players we've got DYH and RafK now as people that've been forced to, yes? Maybe it's an every other night thing? Also, I'm convinced it's a mechanic / ability. There's no reason DYH would have role-played otherwise. Theoretically RafK could just be lying, but DYH was town. He told us he had to role-play and had no reason to lie.
HE: Were you forced to role-play?
AG being caked means very little in regards to his alignment. I don't want to swim in that lake of wine.
CP, can you multivote for us?
For starters, RafK's new restriction is the most hilarious thing I've ever seen in a mafia game. Good times.
On a related note, can anyone who's been hit by the 'role-playing bug' let us know if it was a bad thing? I want to know whether or not we should be looking for the source.
Grak: What was the case on Dagger yesterday beyond the fact that he hasn't done much?
I'd be interested to know if RafK is, in fact, vanilla considering Puzzle's wore off just after Fade's death.
I know fade figured out (or at least thought he had) how CP's vote worked on day 1, and I'm pretty sure I've got it, too. I want to see him try and multi-vote before I spill anything, though. Also on CP,
QFT
Axel's list of possible day-killers (+ himself) should be useful. Whether or not his intentions are good, I think the logic makes sense. It's at least a starting point of where to go today. Oh, and Cyan's role as he's claimed is fine if Axel is the SK. A pseudo-unkillable SK that can still be lynched is ok.
That's all for now.
Sidenote: sorry I've been less active these past few days; school just started for me.
I meant why can't we just vote atlseal. My vote's in the right place.
1. His initial play on day 1 is very sketchy. This is well agreed upon seeing as it led to his claim.
2. The -2 to lynch part of his claim is kluncky, inelegant, and otherwise suspicious. I hate it.
I'm not entirely convinced of his scuminess based on these two points alone, but I can't see anyone better.
So I'm less convinced than I was earlier, but I still think he'd be a good lynch. Consider this a vote atlseal.
...Seriously? These answers are crap.
Also keeping my eye firmly on atl as well.
If this is all you have to say, then don't bother to ask us to get back on the hawkeye wagon again. Just because a wagon "is not moving very fast" does not mean that Hawkeye is scum. That's just craplogic to the max, imo.
FOS: Jeffe4.