Bur is town because the main argument for him being scum is "he's lurky." But apparently he's been active enough in his Skill chats to rack up 500+ QT posts between him and his chat partners, which would defeat the purpose of lurking. And if having a lot of Skill partners was advantageous to his team in some way mechanically, he's under no obligation to be active there.
Tubba is scum because he was almost killed with a wagon of 95% villagers, he fits on most teams because he doesn't have a lot of fleshed out pushes or interactions, and as far as I can tell the only thing in his favor are his emotional outbursts, which are dubious at best. KJ can correct me on this if he feels a need to, since I think he's the only person arguing Tubba could be town.
And no, everyone is not going to re-explain the reads we've been going over for literal weeks now sub-24 hours to deadline just because you spent the entire game up Wisp's ass. If you read the game, which reads/reasoning do you disagree with specifically for scum!Tubba or town!Bur?
That has got to be the laziest scumread I have ever seen. Over 4000+ posts of content and you come up with "caught him in a lie about a naked vote on Day 1."
Yeah ok, you think I'm lying about something very easily verifiable? How about I misremembered and didn't feel it was important enough to open my own ISO?
I mean, technically, a no-yeet followed the next day by yeeting Azreal anyway did benefit scum. The yeet is towns weapon, failing to yeet is a better outcome for scum then even a missyeet because it leaves the missyeetables in the game for later.
Nobody on MTGS likes No Yeeting. Not villagers, not mafia. Despite that it seems to keep happening once every other game.
Jamie Lannister? What?
I'm just going to point out that you're pushing a read that being with Vaimes being guilty of the same things confirmed!town Cuth was guilty of, meaning Vaimes = scum. Which. Uh.
I agree that Vaimes hasn't pushed anyone in a significant way, which is annoying.
You think Vaimes purposefully didn't vote you D2 because he was playing the long con to get you off toDay? I guess it's not impossible but. Doesn't sound like a Vaimes thing. It sounds like a me thing sort of? And I'm the one arguing to kill you toMorrow.
We have had 3.5 confirmed town players with protective abilities: Tammy, Rhand, Anak, Cantrip+Silver make .5. There are multiple similar rols in this game even outside of the protections.
How are you defining "never too deep" on Wisp re: HR.
Is everyone going to point this out? Yes, I was wrong. Sucks. No need to keep ******* kicking me.
Willingness? I'm advocating for someone else, you loon.
yep.
He's talking about Game of Thrones mafia where I was scum!Jamie Lannister and almost won.
Please explain to me nice and slow how a No Yeet is at all beneficial for the scumteam rather than just killing you.
I can't believe people are still trying to read into that vote mishap. Even if it was planned, it didn't take into account Gentleman Johnny forgetting the one rule of his role.
RE: Vaimes Again, I get that that's your point - but is there anything about Vaimes himself, his play, etc. that makes you think he's town?
I don't know if this is funny or sad. You are literally one of the first people I ever played mafia with, and I am so far outside my scumrange that regardless of your alignment I am going to give you a swift asskicking when the dust clears.
Bur is town because the main argument for him being scum is "he's lurky." But apparently he's been active enough in his Skill chats to rack up 500+ QT posts between him and his chat partners, which would defeat the purpose of lurking. And if having a lot of Skill partners was advantageous to his team in some way mechanically, he's under no obligation to be active there.
Tubba is scum because he was almost killed with a wagon of 95% villagers, he fits on most teams because he doesn't have a lot of fleshed out pushes or interactions, and as far as I can tell the only thing in his favor are his emotional outbursts, which are dubious at best. KJ can correct me on this if he feels a need to, since I think he's the only person arguing Tubba could be town.
I can't believe people are still trying to read into that vote mishap. Even if it was planned, it didn't take into account Gentleman Johnny forgetting the one rule of his role.
I realized as I wrote that post that I'm a hypocrite so like. Ditto lmao.
My vote is going on Tubba. When in doubt, I think it's best to just kill the one most likely to be mafia, even if it isn't mechanically optimal.