2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • posted a message on EMN Mythics Are All In Packs With The Same Art
    Quote from Hagalaz »
    I do not have this experience. In the prizes of my pre-release, for example, got 2 mythics in the half display I won. they were in boosters with different packaging, one in a tamiyo packagin (emrakul) and one with that burning werewolf-like thingy (nahiri's wrath). The boosters all came from the same display.
    According to reddit comments, it seems like this is only true for US product. European and Australian boxes are said to be randomized as normal.

    Source: Comments in here: Reddit
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on Return to Lorwyn?
    I don't know, I just don't see how these things of the original set(s) affect "Returns to"s at all:
    • Draft environment
    • Strong/eternal-playable cards
    • Overall power level
    Draft environment and power level can be vastly different in the new set, there is nothing forcing them to use the same mechanics (see RTR and SOI) or aiming to hit the same power level again. Reprints in "Return sets" don't seem to happen very often either (or have you seen a new Snapcaster/LotV/Cavern of Souls/Craterhoof/Dark Confidant/etc lately?).

    Furthermore, a lot of sets which were popular just happened to have a lot of strong cards and/or a fun draft environment. Like I said, two things that mean absolutely nothing for the return set. On the other hand, sets became unpopular when they had a low power level or are connected to a bad standard experience. Again, nothing the Return set has to repeat.

    I guess what I am trying to say is: Why focus on the executing of the original set when deciding whether a return is a good idea or not? Why not look at things which can/should/must be transferred to the return instead?
    • World "quality" and flavor
    • Design space (for stories, conflicts and of course also cards) within the given world
    • Uniqueness of the world and its inhabitants
    I think these are way better aspects to focus on when thinking about a return. And in these Kamigawa and Lorwyn both look really decent to me. Post-conflux Alara however seems rather unfocused (no clearly differentiated clans/guilds/shards/tribes/whatever), while dragon world of Tarkir feels very one-dimensional and boring to me.

    In the end I really hope that Wizards realizes the above and doesn't fear the negative feedback they will likely receive when announcing a "Return to Kamigawa" or similar. When the set plays good everyone will be happy, when it doesn't people will complain. Doesn't matter if it's Ravinca, Lorwyn or Innistrad.
    Posted in: Speculation
  • posted a message on The Sultai Dilemma
    Quote from Giodante »
    No love for Sidisi, Brood Tyrant combo featuring Mesmeric Orb and Basalt Monolith?

    I guess this answers that:
    Quote from un_diplomatic »
    and I prefer to avoid infinite combos.

    ok, ok. It is not actually infinte. But still...
    Posted in: Commander (EDH)
  • posted a message on Why doesn't wizards make really good equipment cards anymore.
    Just looked at the equipment of the last sets and it seems like there is only a single good one per year or something like that. And I am not talking Modern-playable here. Last ones were Blade of Selves, Sword of the Animist and Godsend.
    Posted in: Magic General
  • posted a message on Ruling Between Mirrorwing Dragon and Dromoka's Command
    a) All other modes of Dromoka's Command target something other than the dragon. Therefore the spell is not copied by Mirrorwing Dragon's effect.
    b) Even if that wasn't the case, for example when you copy Dromoka's Command with Twincast, you can not change the selected modes for the copy, only the targets.
    Posted in: Magic Rulings
  • posted a message on Art Book Spoilers
    Could you please write "SPOILERS" in the title?
    I clicked on this thread thinking it was pure speculation. But already the first sentence of the artbook text is a huge spoiler...

    Aside from that, the artwork and text font looks pretty gorgeous. Maybe I should also start buying artbooks Wink
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on MTGSalvation Eternal Masters Prediction Contest - Winner: Zephyr_Scarlet!
    Will be reprinted:
    51 Grim Lavamancer
    5 Fact or Fiction
    0 Lightning Bolt
    8 Eternal Witness
    16 Faithless Looting

    Wont be reprinted:
    492 Pyroblast
    313 Counterbalance
    223 Red Elemental Blast
    1237 Ponder
    166 Punishing Fire
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.