Quote from AsianInvasionIf tordeck develops a history of being problematic in games of Mafia, he can be modkilled, excluded from future games by their hosts, put on probation, and/or blacklisted. However, none of these are your call to make. If you have a problem with what he's doing, contact Zionite or the Mafia Council and have them deal with him. If you're going vote him for this then you're no better than he is.
Quote from Ecophagy@HC: Sure, OMT could be Sylar, but looking for a SK - especially this early in the game - isn't all that fruitful an endeavour. I am content to assume he is town for now and look back at him in a day or two.
Quote from tordeckScum are always a threat to town, isn't that what this game is about?
Quote from EcophagyI meant more that if sylar takes peter's ability, he can use it to gain other abilities without killing, meaning we don't know what he has gained.
Quote from Ecophagy1) OMT is incredibly town. For everyone on his wagon, I invite you to go look at:
#117, wherein he votes joboman well before the wagon took off. coupled with 254 & 256, I see no way that OMT can be mafia. Newb scum don't bus like that. His attempt at analysis in 396 is also indicative of townie scumhunting.
Quote from OneMoreTimeout of curiosity was he active at all before the end of the jobo lynch? cause if he wasn't then the pattern of wanting other players lynched but then holding off when the one lynched is going to be scum is a pretty big tell.
Quote from EcophagyIn a way, I'd actually much prefer Sylar not to get his hands on Peter's ability. At least with each kill we know what Sylar has gained.
Quote from tordeckAnd sorry bucko but no matter how much you don't like my playstyle I am town through and through. Lynching me will just set us farther in the hole.
Quote from tordeckAnd I am just stating a hard cold fact. The last thing we need now is another dead townie.
Quote from AsianInvasionThis post stood out during a quick reread.
The comments regarding Hunted Charlie are obsolete, but the discussion of Cyan's suspicions of Ace and red_0mega is worth pursuing.
Twilight posts immediately preceding the lynch scene:
It sure looks like Ace wanted Cyan dead to end what certainly would have been an awkward conversation.
Quote from TACKY@HC: What flavor/information do you have about you becoming scum had you picked it?
Quote from AsianInvasionExactly. Given how much scrutiny he was under Day One I'm sure Hunted Charlie thought a cop investigation was imminent and so wanted to make sure he had a chance of winning. (It sounds like if he were to die before choosing a side, he couldn't win with either town or mafia.)
Quote from red_0megaAs has been said, the rules would seem to be a decent reason to assume so. The is no reason to assume that he can use multiple abilities.
Quote from red_0megaYes, obviously it was not a great idea. I am really not sure what else you want me to say.
Quote from OneMoreTimeWOD is actively lurking and making no effort to hide it.
Quote from OneMoreTimeCyan hasn't really been around much but what he says feels like an active contribution, not lurking.
Quote from tordeckIt happened at the end of the season, I'm not saying he oonly used ther first half i m saying that he more than likly wouldn't use something from the last 5% of the season to build a character/power.
Quote from Nom_AnorI don't believe this for a second.
You threw away your chance at not having to choose town or scum until night 3--when you would have a substantially better idea of who was winning--in exchange for. . .coming up as town on the off chance you were cop investigated on Night 2(when you had a 50/50 chance of showing up as town anyway) but the cop decided not to investigate you on Night 1.
Quote from AsianInvasionChoosing town is certainly a mistake if you suddenly think that scum have a better shot at winning. The math is about the same since town:scum is generally 3:1 anyway, but HC's playstyle suggests a relatively low level of guile so him saying this is par for the course.
Quote from tordeck@ai you made my point for me ty. It wasn't until the end of season that nikki figured out how to use her power and to game the mod a little, I can't see zion useing. Fluff from only the end to give a power so if he was in fact nikki he would not be able to use his power until later in the game or not at all.
Quote from Nom_AnorYou're missing my point. He says he chose town because he didn't want to get cop-investigated and have it accidentally show scum.
However, this doesn't make sense, as by choosing town, he prevent the thing he was using the ability to stop: he could just save the ability for later, when the game had played out more.
Quote from SyrenzIf you've fulfilled your wincon, now what?
Quote from Nom_AnorAlso note how different his tone is now than later. He comes out as being very willing to claim. Later, when it's looking like he's going to get out of it, he clams up. Together with his "and I screwed up too" comment, it feels like he was going to claim a power role to try and avoid the lynch, but when things started looking up for him, he decided he didn't need to.
Quote from Zionite »This ability may also be dangerous, as certain supernatural abilities may change alignment
Quote from TACKYYou're last response is terribad. And your prod on me was well expected. That's why.
Quote from TACKYUnvote
ReVote Hunted Charlie
Never should have gone against my D1 thoughts. That's what I get for harboring a WIFOM gnome from the cold with the empty space in my noggin. He pays good rent though...
Quote from SyrenzEarly mudflinging. Says OMT's post are a distraction from something. He's been asked what this distraction is repeatedly and I believe he has still not answered that. It's just an attack on OMT for no reason.
Quote from Syrenz"Jobo was the best possible case at that time." yep it certainly was a great case at that time: "he's barning and staying quiet, maybe he's busy, wagon I suppose?"
Quote from SyrenzLooking at the tone of the original post, it's a very wishy washy noncommital post. I cannot see the place that would have been meant for the vote he supposedly forgot. Look:
It just does not feel right at all and he did not intend to have a vote in that post like he implied.
Quote from SyrenzHunted Charlie is now pursuing the RO wagon with terrible logic to say that RO is Sylar and get a lynch that is not himself. Like seriously:
This is so terrible it hurts. Was there a reason you completely ignored Ecophagy's explanation a couple posts above?
Quote from Syrenznvm, you responded to that. With even worse of an argument.
Quote from red_0megaWrong. No matter how many abilities he takes, he can still only use one per Night and he is still alone. The mafia have multiple actions and are able to coordinate them. Therefore as long as there is likely to be several of them left out there I would definitely rather concentrate on them.
Quote from red_0megaIf I get lynched it will have been all of you who has removed a town player.
Quote from red_0megaYes, I agreed with TACKY and voted. If people agree with this PBPA and vote for me would you call them scummy?
The fact that your counter-arguments were weak (I am not the only one who said so) IS content to support my vote. As was TACKY's PBPA.
Quote from red_0mega"Aggression" is not a scum tell.
Quote from red_0megaAgain, why should I bother to listen to the second scummiest person in the game?
Quote from red_0megaYou forgot my hammer vote, you know, your entire case. Nice.
A decent PBPA and a poor response. What more would you like?
Quote from red_0megaWarned not to by someone I was convinced was scum.
Quote from red_0megaTL;DR: I doubt that I am going to be able to get through to these tunnel-visioned, one-point-wonders, so go ahead and put me into claim range and hopefully that will do it. N
ot that I want to claim, but if it will get these people off of my back...
Quote from vezokpirakaEpic slip. How can you know what Sylar can do with his abilities?
Please lynch this guy.
Also you're entire not look for sylar is wrong. You see if we lynch Sylar there is one less kill. If we try to lynch the mafia then we need at least 3-5 days.
Quote from EcophagyHey Vezo! Look!