Because of the way Sreeching Scorchbeast's ability is worded, if all players mill at the same time (which is what happens if an effect says "each player mills [number] cards", it indeed sees one trigger event and it looks at all players to determine the number of tokens.Quote from cyberium_neo »Screeching Scorchbeast
If an effect causes each player to mill cards, does Scorchbeast create zombies base on the total number of nonland cards milled, or does it only look at one player?
- cyberium_neo
- Registered User
-
Member for 10 years, 2 months, and 12 days
Last active Wed, Apr, 3 2024 05:26:42
- 2 Followers
- 4,993 Total Posts
- 1017 Thanks
-
1
MadMageQc posted a message on Screeching Scorchbeast and "Each player mill"Posted in: Magic Rulings -
1
user_938036 posted a message on Hofri and Leyline of the VoidNo, Hofri requires a nontoken creature to die. Meaning go from the battlefield to the graveyard. This doesn't happen with Leyline of the Void in play. The leyline is a replacement effect while Hofri is a trigger.Posted in: Magic Rulings -
1
MadMageQc posted a message on Undead Alchemist and Zombie MillsBarring things like first strike or double strike, all of the combat damage is dealt at the same time and replaced at the same time by the Alchemist, even if it's from mutliple sources, so it'll be only one Mothman trigger.Posted in: Magic Rulings -
1
MadMageQc posted a message on Multiple Lara CroftProvided you have a way to get around the fact that Lara Croft is legendary of course, well, each Lara's attack trigger resolves separately, and each gives you a separate permission to play an exiled card with a discovery counter on it this turn. Those permissions are cumulative, if you had 3 Lara attack triggers resolve, you can play 3 of those cards.Posted in: Magic Rulings -
2
Rezzahan posted a message on Gandalf of Secret Fire and BuybackBoth buyback and Gandalf's trigger are trying to replace the same event (the spell being put into the graveyard when it is finished resolving). As the controller of the affected object you get to decide which replacement effect to apply first. The other will then no longer be applicable, and your choice of replacement will be carried out.Posted in: Magic Rulings -
1
MadMageQc posted a message on Davros and MissyYou're correct in both cases, yes. The abilities don't check those variables until they resolve. Davros doesn't have what's called an 'intervening if' clause that would prevent his ability from triggering, it always triggers and the conditions are checked on resolution. And as for Missy's ability, the artifact creatures that deal damage are those that you control as her ability resolves.Posted in: Magic Rulings -
1
Horseshoe_Hermit posted a message on Anikthea and Battle for BretagardIf Battle for Bretagard is creature, and a token, at the time the last chapterr ability triggers, then it is a legal target (provided you target only one object named "Battle for Bretagard"). The setup you describe does provide those conditions.Posted in: Magic Rulings
The ability fully resolves and makes the token, before you sacrifice the Saga (CR 704.5s). -
1
Horseshoe_Hermit posted a message on Elenda and Azor and EoT triggersThat's correct. The instruction in Elenda and Azor's ability will count up the number of cards you have drawn this turn (equivalently, number of times you've drawn a card this turn), just as the effect is being applied.Posted in: Magic Rulings -
2
genini2 posted a message on Xyris/Nadir Kraken/Gaea's CradleSo you attack with Xyris and deal three damage to an opp causing him to trigger and you both draw 3 cards. Because the draws happen simultaneously all the triggers happen at the same time and can be put on the stack in any order you (as the controller) choose so you can have Nadir Kraken's resolve last. If you do then Xyris will create 3 tokens first then you will have more tokens available for Gaea's Cradle when the kraken triggers go to resolve.Posted in: Magic Rulings -
1
Rezzahan posted a message on Sheoldred + Regna + MonarchNo. In order to trigger, the trigger condition has to be true at the time the trigger would go off. Here, that is the moment the end step begins, and only that moment. At that time, your team has not gained life (yet), so no trigger. It doesn't matter, that you will gain life soon after, the check for the trigger condition has already happened, and failed.Posted in: Magic Rulings - To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
1
1
1
Chapters of nothingness, but this one really hits me. The struggle and suffering is palpable.
1
1
The story about how Orochi losing limbs is rather... unconvincing. I can see the appearance change as an artistic decision so Orochi could fit in with snake tribes on other planes (not to mention less headache for artists), but they could've thought of a better reason than "Thanks to kami, miracles happened," and kami demanding "a simpler form" as a sacrifice is way too convenient for this aesthetic change. Nevertheless, I'm always happy to see more kirins.
1
Grandpa Markov and Olivia, it seems. Years past I was hoping for a card depicting the Fourth Sister (Liesa) and a demonic lover, but I suppose two vampires will do.
1
1
1
No, the mystery is, "Who is the father?"
1