cyberium_neo's Profile - Member List

Sep 16, 2019
cyberium_neo posted a message on Adventure and Haakon

Quote from peteroupc »
In general, for the purposes of Haakon's second ability, Muldrotha's second ability, Karador's second ability, and any other ability with an effect that lets a player play a "card" with certain characteristics from a particular zone, what is relevant is what characteristics the card in that zone had before it began to be played due to such an ability, not what characteristics the object it becomes this way has. See also this thread.

In the case of casting an adventure from the graveyard this way, however, it remains to be seen whether creature/adventure cards behave like casting a card face down in the sense that the card has only certain characteristics (namely those of the chosen part), rather than those of the card as a whole, before that card goes on the stack (see also C.R. 707.4).

The link is helpful, though it did bring up another argument I had with Mystic Forge: Apparently you can play a morph creature from top of your library, regardless of its actual color or if it was a land like Zoetic Cavern. If there's a Lantern of Insight in play where everyone reveals the top card of their library, how would I justify playing a morph creature when it's clearly NOT a colorless card?

Yet I could, so perhaps as long as the spell could be cast as a certain type (colorless, knight in grave, etc), it goes on the stack like a fired bullet, much like Eldrazi cast trigger that will happen even if you counter the Eldrazi itself.

Hopefully WotC can address this type of questions all together with the release of Eldraine, I'm dying to know better.
Posted in: Magic Rulings
Sep 16, 2019
cyberium_neo posted a message on Beating a dead horse: Tutors in commander

At this point I'm settled with any kind of tutor as long as the deck isn't aiming for three turn kill. I use tutors for Akido style gameplay, and in most cases I only use Demonic/Vampiric if I don't have green/white removal in my deck, so I could find artifact answers.
Posted in: Commander (EDH)
Sep 16, 2019
cyberium_neo posted a message on [[Official]] Unreleased and New Card Discussion

Quote from joejack8445 »
I really like Kenrith, the Returned King. I can't wait to abuse him with Training Grounds and Biomancer's Familiar.

Goes infinite pretty easily even without, I wonder how notorious he'd be.
Posted in: Commander (EDH)
Sep 15, 2019
cyberium_neo posted a message on [ELD] Jack and the Beanstalk story cards

So the cow was actually a person. That knife on the man's waist is haunting.
Posted in: The Rumor Mill
Sep 15, 2019
cyberium_neo posted a message on Adventure and Haakon

Quote from lucasbpc »
Adventures only exist while on hand, and they have no creature type, so no.

Base on what I've heard, creature CARDS with Adventure are creatures in every zone except on stack (when you chose it to be Adventure), which is why I wonder if Haakon could cast a knight-adventure from graveyard.

Though, base on Bobthefunny's explanation, Adventure spells cannot resolve due to the game realizing the spell isn't a Knight spell, therefore deem it impossible to cast.

Here's a relevant question: If I have both Haakon and Kess, Dissident Mage on battlefield, one lets me cast knight spell the other allows me to cast an instant/sorcery during my turn, would it work?
Posted in: Magic Rulings
Sep 14, 2019
cyberium_neo posted a message on Adventure and Haakon

Haakon, Stromgald Scourge/Murderous Rider

Or any card that allows you to cast creature spells from graveyard, is it possible to cast adventure half of the card while doing so?
Posted in: Magic Rulings
Sep 14, 2019
cyberium_neo posted a message on [ELD] Clockwork Servant— Amazonian preview

I wouldn't mind having one that if cast with three colorless mana you draw two cards.
Posted in: The Rumor Mill
Sep 14, 2019
cyberium_neo posted a message on [ELD] Countryside Villa

Enter tapped isn't an issue, consider Llanowar Reborn does something similar without chance to untap. Like many other cards in the set, they are aiming to bolster mono-color decks, which I approve.
Posted in: The Rumor Mill
Sep 13, 2019
cyberium_neo posted a message on [ELD] Non-Human support— Limited Resources previews

I'm sure the shrooms is what turned Grumgully blue.
Posted in: The Rumor Mill
Sep 13, 2019
cyberium_neo posted a message on Anti-Ramp: Solutions?

Quote from Sleepytyrant »
Played a game the other day against a group hug deck that was running Quicksilver Fountain. Game took hours because nobody was running blue.

Lol, I should look into that.
Posted in: Commander (EDH)
Sep 13, 2019
cyberium_neo posted a message on Is this deck any good?

Living Death seems to be a nice mass reanimation for all your death and sacs.
Posted in: Commander (EDH)
Sep 13, 2019
cyberium_neo posted a message on Best commander for a Eldrazi deck?

Animar, Soul of Elements is a common choice, so is Rakdos, Lord of Riots.
Posted in: Commander (EDH)
Sep 13, 2019
cyberium_neo posted a message on [ELD] Revenge of Ravens

Quote from 5colors »
Yay the Cinderella reference I was hoping for.

The part Disney omitted, of course. (Old fairytales really love eye balls)
Posted in: The Rumor Mill
Sep 13, 2019
cyberium_neo posted a message on [ELD] Irencrag Feat— Matthew Nass preview

That's quite a burst, you can cast this turn 2~3 with some luck.
Posted in: The Rumor Mill
Sep 13, 2019
cyberium_neo posted a message on [ELD] Mirrormade- MTG Goldfish preview

Apparently a theme that emphasizes on enchantment and artifact in this set. Enchantment I understand, consider Theroes is next, what of the artifacts...
Posted in: The Rumor Mill
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.

MTG Salvation