2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • posted a message on [Mini Game] Pleasantville Mafia: Town Victorious!
    You're missing the point. Wheat, hans and Iso all expressed doubts about the veracity of rezombied's claimed, and want to lynch him because he's potential scum. You, on the other hand, immediately assumed he was town and decided to lynch him anyway, purely for the ability unlock. Tell me Tan, in what world is a mislynch more protown than an extra JoaT ability or two for scum?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Mini Game] Pleasantville Mafia: Town Victorious!
    Quote from Tanarin

    Umm... the fact it is stating a likely fact that scum will likely shoot him tonight. I mean I am not the only one to express this opinion. Wheat, Iso, hans, and even Rezombied himself all said pretty similar things as well. Why not go after one of them? We all can't be scum, now can we.

    Have they, now?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Mini Game] Pleasantville Mafia: Town Victorious!
    Quote from Tanarin
    Sorry on the gender thing, didn't know.

    Anyway, Still seems pointless to even use it to gauge reactions from him. I mean isn't there a better way to go about it other than that way?

    /shrug

    I mean, I didn't think of one in the couple of minutes between me reading rezombied's claim and that post. My main reason for the question involved the town's win condition (you'll notice that Rezombied's restriction of the role to just the mafia matches the town win con, and a backtrack to include third parties would have been pretty indicative of scum).

    Are you going to answer my question?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Mini Game] Pleasantville Mafia: Town Victorious!
    Quote from Tanarin
    We know Rezombied is the lynch for today (Can't risk scum gaining an ability unlock.)

    Hmm, Tan, do you see the problem with this statement?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Mini Game] Pleasantville Mafia: Town Victorious!
    Quote from Tanarin
    Quote from fulcrum
    Quote from Iso
    I could ask you the same about EtR. Didn't he claim that if he died in any way, the town got a random shot of their abilities?

    No, he claimed that if he was lynched, scum would get a random shot and if he was shot in the night, town would get a random shot.

    Rezombied: Is it just mafia who would get an extra shot, or does it also apply to third parties?


    OK, since when was a third party on the table? I mean AFAIK there is no third in this game. Why even speculate and ask about one?

    It hasn't been. I just wanted to see rezombied's reaction. (And I'm a she.)
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Mini Game] Pleasantville Mafia: Town Victorious!
    Quote from Iso
    I could ask you the same about EtR. Didn't he claim that if he died in any way, the town got a random shot of their abilities?

    No, he claimed that if he was lynched, scum would get a random shot and if he was shot in the night, town would get a random shot.

    Rezombied: Is it just mafia who would get an extra shot, or does it also apply to third parties?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Mini Game] Pleasantville Mafia: Town Victorious!
    Quote from Iso
    "Missed" meant I incorrectly guessed who was going to be the Nightkill.

    Quote from fulcrum
    Quote from Iso
    I targeted you, Tan. I figured if I didn't die, you or Rhand would.I opted for you and I missed, but wanted to use the unknown of my target as leverage to get dkings lynched since I'm 100% sure he's scum. And then hans ruined it. No I guess I should've figured I was prime Tracker material, especially on Night 1.

    Iso: How does the bolded work with your claim to have not known about Rhand's roleclaim?


    What does my interpretation of how well Rhand plays the game have to do with his role?

    Ah. Ok.

    I'm relly not sure what to think of Iso. I do like Wheat's reaction to Tanarin and the way he revealed the neighborizing ability, so I'll trust his greater experience for the moment.

    Unvote

    Quote from Kosakosa
    Oh, and people are actually letting Iso go away with 1) not using his watch on the claimed doctor and 2) lying about having targeted (and found a guilty on) DKL?

    rollout

    I guess I'll just PTAP every few days and keep chatting with my BFF in the mason chat.

    Rolleyes
    You could attack him instead of putting the onus on everyone else.

    I'll delve back into the game on Friday or Saturday and see what comes up.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Basic Game] [#82] Hayate the Combat Butler Mafia SCUM WIN
    Wheat: Why did you hammer there?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Basic Game] [#82] Hayate the Combat Butler Mafia SCUM WIN
    Yeah, if Titus is scum Shockwave is pretty likely to be town in my eyes for the gimmick argument.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Basic Game] [#82] Hayate the Combat Butler Mafia SCUM WIN
    What is it with you people and hammering?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Basic Game] [#82] Hayate the Combat Butler Mafia SCUM WIN
    Quote from 7hawk77
    II can list other mafia games and explain how I handled a power role situation or link you scum chats of what night kills were chosen and why.

    That would be appreciated.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Basic Game] [#82] Hayate the Combat Butler Mafia SCUM WIN
    Quote from 7hawk77
    I strongly believe that if Rhand, Wheat or myself was on the scum team, the night kill would have landed on you instead of kosa.

    Sigh.

    Yes, you've said that. You have not explained why you believe that.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Basic Game] [#82] Hayate the Combat Butler Mafia SCUM WIN
    Why does me being alive make you, Rhand and Wheat town?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Basic Game] [#82] Hayate the Combat Butler Mafia SCUM WIN
    Quote from 7hawk77
    This also fits because if Rhand, Myself or wheat was scum, fulcrum would have died.

    ?

    If you're trying to convince me to vote for you over Scarlet, then you're doing very well.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Basic Game] [#82] Hayate the Combat Butler Mafia SCUM WIN
    Vote: Scarlet Rage

    Quote from 7hawk77
    @Rhand,

    Fulcrum told the person that EtR replaced to "Ask someone a question"

    This is why I thought it was an ordered pair.

    Facepalm

    How many times are you going to do this?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.