2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • posted a message on Kudzu Q
    Thanks. After carefully reading it that's the conclusion I reached. I only ask because "back in the day" we always played it as a "must" ability for some reason. It feels that without it being a "must" ability to be an extremely lackluster card, whereas it being a "must" ability makes it a fun card, especially in multiplayer.
    Posted in: Magic Rulings
  • posted a message on Kudzu Q
    I play Kudzu on my opponent's land. They tap that land and it gets destroyed. Does my opponent have to put Kudzu on another land or can they just let Kudzu go to the grave? The wording on Kudzu leads me to believe latter.
    Posted in: Magic Rulings
  • posted a message on Nomenclature and the Comp Rules
    Thank you! So “status” is now the word to look for.

    I’m beginning to think “status” was always the term and that I’m just misremembering.
    Posted in: Magic Rulings
  • posted a message on Nomenclature and the Comp Rules
    Whether a card is tapped/untapped, face up/face down, flipped/unflipped, phased in/phased out used to be referred to as a card’s “state”.
    Is there a new way of referring to this, and where in the comp. rules do I find this topic?
    Whenever I try and search this up all I get are articles about game states or the state of the game, LOL.

    If this is the wrong place to ask sorry in advance.
    Posted in: Magic Rulings
  • posted a message on Vesuvan Doppelganger Q:
    Peteroupc and Zappa from Cairo, thanks for the responses.

    We did play it out correctly but were just a little unsure about it.
    Posted in: Magic Rulings
  • posted a message on Vesuvan Doppelganger Q:
    I have out a Vesuvan Doppelganger with three +1/+1 counters. During my upkeep I target my opponent's Triskelion with the Doppelganger's shapeshifting ability. His Triskelion has one +1/+1 counter. In response to me targeting the Triskelion with the Doppelganger's ability, my opponent removes the counter from Triskelion to kill the Triskelion.
    Our question, since the target is no longer on the battlefield does the ability of the Doppelganger "fizzle"? And if so, does it just remain the creature it was at the start of the turn?
    Posted in: Magic Rulings
  • posted a message on Reflecting Pool and Interplanar Beacon and The World Tree
    If I’m not mistaken, YES to both.
    Posted in: Magic Rulings
  • posted a message on Dragon with more than one artwork
    Quote from FunkyDragon »
    Quote from Perodequeso »
    @FunkyDragon, thanks very helpful.
    I too am trying for all the art variants. What’s killing me are the judge promos hovering around $50 each. That and the fact I’ll never be able to own the employee promos from Heroes of the Realm.
    Yeah, the Treva promo is like $30+ and the Bolas one is over $70. But neither of those hold a candle to Zodiac Dragon, the $285 card that would be less than 50 cents if it ever got reprinted.


    Luckily I have the Zodiac Dragon. But a half dozen or so $30+ cards adds up.
    Posted in: Magic General
  • posted a message on Dragon with more than one artwork
    @TheOnlyOne652089


    Thanks, very helpful!
    Posted in: Magic General
  • posted a message on 31 new digital-only cards for upcoming Jumpstart : Historic Horizon
    Quote from Draymore2019 »
    I Hate this new set. Here have random way to get cards to hand. What? You get OG duals sort of...dumb.

    I feel like because of Covid Wizards is like at all the money we got. If we cut out LGS of the picture we get to keep all that money. Let's start moving to full digital. Screw you LGS.


    Oh for goodness sake! They're not going to go full digital, at least not anytime soon. The paper game is a cash cow. The fact that some digital card can randomly give you an OG dual for a game isn't what's killing LGSs. People seem to forget that on MGTO you can play with all the Reserved List cards you want. Now they port over a little of that to Arena and all the sudden it's doomsday for paper Magic. There are so many players with physical cards that would never give up the game for a digital platform. WOTC could go under tomorrow and most players I know have enough cards or access to cards to never need new product for the rest of their lives. Old School 93/94 and Pre-Modern are proof that the game can and will have life beyond WOTC.

    I do however concur that WOTC could be a better ally to the LGS.

    Isn't Shandalar one of the worlds we'll be visiting in the near-ish future? These "random" cards seem to be a nod to the old Micropose game. I can imagine that as a designer, digital space opens up design ideas that the paper game just couldn't support logistically. It's interesting to see that in action. I think they're being a bit conservative from what I've seen so far.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on Dragon with more than one artwork
    @FunkyDragon, thanks very helpful.
    I too am trying for all the art variants. What’s killing me are the judge promos hovering around $50 each. That and the fact I’ll never be able to own the employee promos from Heroes of the Realm.
    Posted in: Magic General
  • posted a message on Dragon with more than one artwork
    I've been looking into dragon cards with more than one version of the art. I don't need info on cards from 2020 and 2021.
    I figured I'd list the ones I've found so far, but finding them all is tricky. I figured there'd be people who'd know about ones I hadn't found.

    I know about From the Vault: Dragons
    The Iconic Masters reprints and Secret Lair.
    And all the Ugin/Nicol Bolas planeswalker variants.

    So far:
    Dragon Whelp
    Shivan Dragon
    Treva, the Renewer
    Oros, the Avenger
    Dragon Broodmother
    Hypersonic Dragon
    Forgestoker Dragon
    Siege Dragon
    Thunderbreak Regent
    Eternal Dragon
    Dromoka, the Eternal
    Volcanic Dragon
    Rorix Bladewing
    Steel Hellkite
    Spawn of Thraxes
    Harbinger of the Hunt
    Pristine Skywise
    Deathbringer Regent
    Skyship Stalker
    Ryusei, the Falling Star(foil promo)
    Glorybringer
    Niv-Mizzet, the Firemind

    If anyone can think of any I overlooked, or are mistaken on I'd appreciate it.
    Thanks.

    Edited after I found a few more.
    Posted in: Magic General
  • posted a message on 31 new digital-only cards for upcoming Jumpstart : Historic Horizon
    Quote from Mataleon »
    In my opinion when MaRo says “ The digital only cards only work on digital. They aren’t cards we can make in paper”, it probably means that they literally can’t work in paper magic, pretty much like the astral cards (for reference https://magic.wizards.com/en/articles/archive/feature/astral-cards-2009-02-12).


    This is exactly what will most likely be done. Effects that are just too wonky, random, or cumbersome to do in paper Magic. As a person who plays a ton of Shandalar, the idea of digital only cards that don't really work IRL doesn't bother me in the least. Besides these would be the kinds of cards that people hate on IRL because they bring "too much variance to the game". And lord forbid that the digital and paper games have features that differentiate them from one another than just the physical attributes.

    One commenter made a statement about the difficulty of transitioning from digital to paper and vice versa if there are differences between them. If that's a problem for you then maybe gaming is above your paygrade, just how pathetic do you think people are(rhetorical, please do not reply)?

    It's not the end of all things people. If I had a dollar for every time someone said "X is killing the game" I'd be a rich man today.
    It really doesn't matter. In the end it'll have little impact on how people play. And when the next thing that will supposedly kill the game comes along everyone will forget about this as their outrage will have a new target. Take The Walking Dead Secret Lair, no one says anything about that anymore, and all the people who claimed that they'd never play against an opponent that plays those cards has most likely played, or will play an opponent using them or other like products in the future.

    Bad design, over powered crap and unbalanced metas will be far more detrimental to the health of the game than any side product.
    Posted in: The Rumor Mill
  • posted a message on Hunted Troll and Zedruu?
    Quote from Gaiden.17 »
    Any idea why they changed these rules? The hunted series and a handful of other cards (e.g. forbidden orchard, varchild's warrider) had a niche use for exploiting the fact that the originator of the tokens owned them (e.g. Gruul Charm) and with Commander Legends would have had beautiful synergy with Blim, Comedic Genius and Zedruu the Greathearted. I similarly find this change unnecessary (and more than a little obnoxious).

    People were abusing these cards with Warp World.
    Posted in: Magic Rulings
  • posted a message on Dragon’s Approach Q:
    Quote from Rezzahan »
    The exiling of four copies of Dragon's Approach from the graveyard is part of the spell's effect. To get a dragon from any resolving DA, copy or original, you have to exile it and four cards named DA from your yard for it when it resolves. Since the copy is created above the original, you may exile cards named DA for the copy first to get a dragon, cause it resolves first. And later you may exile four cards named DA and the original when that original resolves to get another dragon.

    I wasn’t asking about the stacking order, I realize I worded my inquiry poorly. What I’m wanted clarification on is this, the only way to get a dragon out out with DA, copy or not is the exiling of DA and four other copies in the grave. You did answer that part, so thanks.
    Posted in: Magic Rulings
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.