Well the Extra kills have been extremely townsided, so yes. It could work.
which extra kills have been townsided aside from ZDS (which was jack's) and WMU?
wisp had pretty much risen to consensus villager by eod1
you can make an argument for sloth i guess? but given that he was our cop i don't think that counts
i don't think the second killer was explicitly townsiding until exactly last night
furthermore, i'm going to point out that we've both been softing since d1 - tom with his gif, me with my intentionally sticking tom at the top of all my readslists "as a joke". for us to be scum, i'm going to point out that we'd have to have:
A. set up this claim on d1
B. elected to STICK with said claim even after the existence of another nighttime KP source was revealed, especially given that said KP source seemed to be scumsiding early on and there was a realistic period of time where i looked like a reasonable SPK (i thought the N1 kill was like 60-40 fonti-me)
and that's ignoring the fact that fakeclaiming masons as mafia is almost always terrible
i don't know what about my play is something you've considered wolfy, but you need to pull your head out of the tunnel and reevaluate
I might as well get this out now: I 100% believe you guys are masons he’ll you haven’t voted for each other at all since your first vote.
I’m trying to see if there are scum willing to jump on my dumb ideas. It’s not working so I’ll stop.
Sorry I shot you.
goo as scum. Lemme get back to you on that. I’ll need to get on the cpu and it’s almost bedtime for me. Can I get back to you tomorrow?
I still think it’s Tom and Amy. Toms reaction to Amy’s vanilla was very confusing because he knew what I had. Amy forgetting that we discussed that my ability can stop the NK is also confusing.
claiming masons solidifies their win because there is no way to prove it and both of them are out of the poe.
Idk, my gut is screaming it’s those two and someone else.
@Rodemy
"I would have stopped the nk if Amy was it?"
......Wait I thought mafia does factional kills in this varient of the genre, how would this help? Unless you mean that she could have been the other carrow in which case... wut.
so fellas
i just confirmed that the mafia team does in fact have to designate a member of their team to carry the nightkill
@Rodemy
"I would have stopped the nk if Amy was it?"
......Wait I thought mafia does factional kills in this varient of the genre, how would this help? Unless you mean that she could have been the other carrow in which case... wut.
so fellas
i just confirmed that the mafia team does in fact have to designate a member of their team to carry the nightkill
to what degree do we buy this as a not-mafia slip
my ability literally stops the Nkz we confirmed this yesterday. If amy performed the nk, I would have stopped it
@Rod our chat closed at day start. Because some dummy vanillized a claimed mason apparently but my first thought was [riddle bullshit]
I dont understand what your plan was if it wasnt to see if scum tom/amy kept pretending to be masons when youd severed the link like
What would that have done if we were scum?
Also a fan of possibly lynching scum.
100% following Tom on this vote.
I might as well get this out now: I 100% believe you guys are masons he’ll you haven’t voted for each other at all since your first vote.
I’m trying to see if there are scum willing to jump on my dumb ideas. It’s not working so I’ll stop.
Sorry I shot you.
goo as scum. Lemme get back to you on that. I’ll need to get on the cpu and it’s almost bedtime for me. Can I get back to you tomorrow?
idk this is a hard one.
vote goo I’m going back to my previous reads. Goo and Ter.
I think we might lose this.
claiming masons solidifies their win because there is no way to prove it and both of them are out of the poe.
Idk, my gut is screaming it’s those two and someone else.
but we aren’t doing that because I’m saying that.
we literally discussed this yesterday.
What.. what are you trying to do, Amy?
my ability literally stops the Nkz we confirmed this yesterday. If amy performed the nk, I would have stopped it
I would have stopped the nk if Amy was it?
it wasn’t that *****ty a plan. ****
hey did you claim your role?