I'll explain one last time. I merely proposed a hypothetical counter to your claim of random lynching D1 to be terrible policy to show a way to make random D1 lynching less bad. As I've already stated a few times, this was not a serious proposal. I am fine if you want to take KCC's side that my hypothetical is still a terrible idea; that I can understand even if I don't agree with it. Continuing to paint me as neutral hunting, however, is deliberately ignoring everything I said so things fit with a worldview you're trying to artificially construct.
Do I worry about a neutral kpaca? Certainly, but do I have any evidence that kpaca is a neutral or am I playing as though he is? Absolutely not.
Again, I couldn't care less if you were neutral hunting, I care that you are backpedaling and giving flimsy reasoning. You Asenion and desCoures are my current early game scum team read.
You said kpaca plays well as a neutral and that is why he should be random lynched if we have no option today. Again, explain to me how this isn't neutral hunting?
This is you expressing worry for the success of a neutral through the skills of kpaca.
Nis, I don't think you are scum, but continuing to argue this probably won't convince your detractors. I feel like we need some town leadership to step up, because so far the game is barely movin and the town seems kind of scattered.
Why are you so intent on painting me as neutral hunting?
I think you are lying and created some flimsy reasoning to lynch a good player that could be town. Its not about the neutral hunting its that you are backpedaling hard.
I've only taken a quick look at the last bit, and will have to read more before I comment on the rest.
First thought that comes to mind is that I've seen similar behaviour to what he claimed from a cop.
It wasn't meant to be a serious proposal. I don't know how experienced you are so I was offering a counterpoint to your claim of "TERRIBLE POLICY" with a hypothetical that takes into account a particular player's skill.
I'm not trying to hunt a neutral. It's like you people can't recognize hypotheticals. I guess it's my fault for not being explicit that it was merely a counter to Che's claim that random lynching D1 is automatically "TERRIBLE POLICY." I was trying to show that it might not be terrible depending on context. Jeez. I'm not seriously advocating a kpaca lynch "just because" nor have I ever advocated such a move. I have a suspicion you're trying to chum up the waters.
Experienced enough to know that random lynching due to previous games is a horrible idea. And you even said that the reason is that he play well as neutral... thats hunting neutrals
Again, I couldn't care less if you were neutral hunting, I care that you are backpedaling and giving flimsy reasoning. You Asenion and desCoures are my current early game scum team read.
This is you expressing worry for the success of a neutral through the skills of kpaca.
Its a toss up, I'll read up all the DRey posts again this afternoon
Why don't you step up instead of asking for it?
I think you are lying and created some flimsy reasoning to lynch a good player that could be town. Its not about the neutral hunting its that you are backpedaling hard.
I came here for spoilers and mafia, why does everyone think I'm someone else? Is this site so bad that nobody new registers or something?
I salute her for the guts she had though, how she dealt realistically with people.
I know who I'm questioning when Caex flips scum
There is a possibility that anyone can be town, why random lynch and risk killing town?
Experienced enough to know that random lynching due to previous games is a horrible idea. And you even said that the reason is that he play well as neutral... thats hunting neutrals