2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • posted a message on [Mini Game] The Hobbit: AUJ - Game Over: The Return Journey [Town and Hitman Victory]
    I'm obviously not shooting Caex but he's probably scum.

    What the ****?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Mini Game] The Hobbit: AUJ - Game Over: The Return Journey [Town and Hitman Victory]
    Quote from WellOfLostGnomes
    I'm not sure if I have explicitly stated this or not, but:
    Though I think Caex's play has been terrible, I am against lynching him today or calling the vig to hit him tonight.

    Ahhhh.... this is so bad

    The information gained will be worth it, we need it.

    Unvote

    I believe DRey's claim over Caex's, but please don't be ignorant and not listen to the towns request and just shoot who you think it best.

    This is interesting now. Let DRey shoot Caex or lynch him? I don't know if I would trust DRey to even listen to the town and shoot Caex.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Mini Game] The Hobbit: AUJ - Game Over: The Return Journey [Town and Hitman Victory]
    Quote from Caex Kothar
    @Xyre: What is your rationale for wanting me shot tonight?

    I'll spell out why I don't think it's a good idea:
    -The scum have to kill me tonight. But if you call the vig shot, they are free to NK a stronger player and get two kills for the price of one.
    -If they don't kill me, I'll have an investigation result. In that case, I can offer myself up as the D2 lynch to confirm said result.

    I'm not living to D3 no matter how this game plays out. We should use me to put the scum in a position where they're forced to dance to the town's tune.

    If you are alive after the night I'm voting you still. But please make up who you supposedly cop'd because it will be fun figuring out if you say one of your buddies is town or if you try and convict a strong townie.

    That's 2 ghost votes DRey, now claim like a good boy townie.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Basic Game] [#74] MTG Salvation Mafia - Game Over - Mafia Win!
    Quote from Rhand


    A FoS in itself isn't scummy.
    It's when the player flips scum that a FoS points to possible buddies.


    It is when you can vote someone who isn't close to a L-2 and apply pressure, as well as getting involved with a wagon. Scum try to fly under the radar and not voting but saying you *think* someone is scum, is avoiding getting your hands dirty.

    No scum player puts their neck out early game when there are so many possibilities for a day 1 mislynch.
    Quote from Generic
    Che has conveniently been less vocal since his lean on me backfired, but he may just not be on so I will wait to see what he has to say before I go further.

    I post outside of a US timezone so please don't think that because I don't post while you guys are that I'm not being vocal. I post here everyday.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Mini Game] MTGS Mafia Redux 2 - Evil Mirror Universe - Game Over
    Me saying "kpaca could be scum" means that there is a possibility he could be town.... and I don't want to randomly lynch someone because "they are good as a neutral".

    I never said that I cared Nis was neutral hunting (I think that was the cupcake guy), I cared that he would happily lynch someone who is good as a neutral and then also said I only cared about the backpeddle because that's a scummy trait.

    I know kpaca wasn't close to being lynched buy by my standard, only scum would want to randomly lynch someone and I was trying to hunt them down for saying and agreeing with it.

    I'm quite a simple poster, I make generally small posts that are straight to the point, and I think getting incredibly deep off that is just grasping at straws trying to find something wrong with my posts when in reality its should just be accepted at face value.

    XXX
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Basic Game] [#74] MTG Salvation Mafia - Game Over - Mafia Win!
    I didn't vote him in RVS and a FoS is scummy when you can vote to add pressure instead of observing from the outside, keeping yourself intact.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Basic Game] [#74] MTG Salvation Mafia - Game Over - Mafia Win!
    Quote from Polski
    I think you might need a refresher course in psychology. The questions I might have wanted to ask had already been asked, and I was waiting for information from them. What sense does it make to ask the same questions twice?

    You're trying too hard.


    Well if you were a productive townie you would ask something else, how are you helpful to the team if you let others do all the talking and you sit twiddling your thumbs?
    Quote from iRebel
    Why so aggressive, Che? You've been riding people pretty hard right out of the gate.


    Putting someone at L-5 and scum hunting is "riding hard"? That's rich.
    Quote from Mistshadow
    Quote from Che Guevara

    Saying you are waiting for questions and information to happen in front of you is the opposite of scum hunting, asking questions and inquiring. The point that you would have waited for a case to be made by others that you aren't going to be involved in is the sitting.

    Thank you.


    Actually Che... I've just read through your posts and all you've done pretty much is instantly start attacking Polski.

    Is there a reason for this?

    That's how mafia works. When someone does something scummy, press for it. Why would I not want mafia to feel pressure? If town feels pressure they won't crack because they have nothing to hide.

    And I also applied some pressure to Rhand. What have you done this game so far?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Mini Game] MTGS Mafia Redux 2 - Evil Mirror Universe - Game Over
    Excellent! Thanks for claiming scum, we'll deal with you at the earliest opportunity (which is either "now" or "once Forgotten One is dealt with", not yet sure which).

    I mean, come on. I may not know MTGS meta that well yet, but unless a huge change in playstyles has come down the pike in the last year or so I know the Scum meta, and by those standards Che's play is classic newbscum. He had a pass so long as I wasn't aware of his Scum experience. No longer. Observe:

    I am not a noob and this is my first game here (along with 2 other I am currently in) so the whole "mtgs meta" thing will be irrelevant.
    Why does Che feel the need to make this comment after 3 votes in random stage?

    Because some were obviously a joke, and I said "if anyone is serious" ala directed at the whole "kpaca is auto scum" crap.
    You know, Che attacks Nis heavily later for backtracking. Now, is it just me, or is that "I'm not so sure he is town" backtracking? Hypocrisy, anyone?

    the bakctrack was the whole "kpaca play good as scum, lets lynch him" and then denying the attempt at hunting neutrals later. But nice misrep Kekeke
    Let me get this straight. You're saying that because I can't actually vote unless hammering... that until it's time to hammer I should simply sit down, shut up, and not indicate where my vote would be if it actually counted, just because said vote doesn't currently count? Instead of, you know, pseudovoting?

    X

    Sorry, try again.

    I'm saying you don't have to unvote a FoS or HoS. Its not about voting someone. Please read my posts.

    The rest of the stuff was just looking too deep.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Mini Game] MTGS Mafia Redux 2 - Evil Mirror Universe - Game Over
    Go back and read my posts again
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Basic Game] [#74] MTG Salvation Mafia - Game Over - Mafia Win!
    Its really just basic human psychology
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Basic Game] [#74] MTG Salvation Mafia - Game Over - Mafia Win!
    Quote from Polski
    Well well, this will do nicely.

    Quote from Mistshadow
    What do you mean by "too quickly"? Why are you so insistent that it goes at a set pace? Eyebrow


    I mean we don't want the Day to end too quickly. The game doesn't necessarily have to go at a set pace, I just don't want us to get ahead of ourselves.

    Quote from Che Guevara
    How do you think content is generated? Randomly from thin air? Your decision to fence sit and not hunt is scummy as hell


    Not sure how not having any questions to add is fence-sitting. You can tell my motives after two posts? You must be one hell of a mafia player.

    Saying you are waiting for questions and information to happen in front of you is the opposite of scum hunting, asking questions and inquiring. The point that you would have waited for a case to be made by others that you aren't going to be involved in is the sitting.

    Thank you.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Mini Game] MTGS Mafia Redux 2 - Evil Mirror Universe - Game Over
    Quote from Taredas
    X

    Try again, please. Check the first vote count, I've already proven that my vote doesn't count if not hammering.

    Also: Do you have experience over on MafiaScum? This kind of post looks awfully familiar...


    Yes because every time you have given a HoS its been on the hammer Rolleyes

    Yes I do
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Mini Game] MTGS Mafia Redux 2 - Evil Mirror Universe - Game Over
    Quote from Asenion
    If Taredas is telling the truth, it represents 3 votes. That's fairly real.

    Again how does this have anything to do with unvoting a FoS or a HoS?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Basic Game] [#74] MTG Salvation Mafia - Game Over - Mafia Win!
    Quote from Polski
    Quote from Che Guevara
    Why don't you ask some of your own questions Polski?


    I didn't really have anything else to add. We're out of RVS, but there's still hardly any content.


    Unvote, vote Polski

    How do you think content is generated? Randomly from thin air? Your decision to fence sit and not hunt is scummy as hell
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Mini Game] MTGS Mafia Redux 2 - Evil Mirror Universe - Game Over
    Just like the pressure it gives on a scummy player
    Posted in: Mafia
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.