2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • posted a message on Unknown Edition Basic Land
    I have a French Swamp from 1996 with no expansion symbols and white borders. It's from Dan Frazier and has one of the Beta arts. I'm left puzzled because 4th edition was in 1995 and the fifth edition in 1997.
    Posted in: Magic General
  • posted a message on From Legacy, flirting with Vintage
    Ancestral Recall is way more powerful than Time Walk. You need more cards way more often than you need an extra land drop and an extra attack phase.
    Posted in: Vintage (Type 1)
  • posted a message on Eternal Prices, Interactions Between Format and Long Term Outcome
    If we look at the history of collectible, the future isn't that bright for MTG. Baseball cards crashed, Beanie Babies crashed, all non MTG TCG crashed, comics crashed, pogs crashed. Stamps, coins, arts and antiquities seems to be the only collectible that crashed but none of them have 2000% increase in price in 5 years and only acquire value after a really long time with a rate of return way smaller than 10%/year.

    Foils tend to increase way faster than everything else but they seem to be the mtg equivalent of triple gold-embossed baseball card with a piece of shirt inside. It's not because something is rare than it's expensive. A lot of people want cards because they're expensive. They might be out for a future someday. I'm sure Alpha Black Lotus will always be expensive but Foil Japanese Brainstorm I'm not sure.

    A collectible is only valuable as long as there is collector and only increase as collectors increase. Wizards is really good right now at balancing the cards price and increasing the player pool but it doesn't mean the player pool will increase forever. How many people do you meet nowadays that are big Backgammon fan or Nine Man's Morris fan?
    Posted in: Market Street Café
  • posted a message on Eternal Prices, Interactions Between Format and Long Term Outcome
    If people buy because it will be higher in the future, there could be a shock if price decreases. The reasons behind the demand might means different price evolution in the future. A card which demand is driven by Standard behaves differently through time than one driven by Legacy or Modern. Let say fetchlands are being traded or sold for Reserved List cards to hedge against their eventual reprint. Once the fetchlands are reprinted it might be possible that the Vintage/Legacy slow-rising staples are traded back for cards with higher increase potential like the fetchlands.

    In the real world, different commodities behave differently. If the economy doesn't go well (upcoming reprints) stocks (fetchlands) will be traded for more stable investments like gold, cash and bonds (Reserved List cards). Once the economy goes better (no more reprints) the stable investments are traded for stocks. Understanding what drives demand helps understand future prices, offer and demand.

    The higher a card is the slower it grows. It's way easier for a $50 card to climb to $200 than for a $300 card to go to $1200. It's for this reason that I think many expensive Reserved List cards will be traded for cheaper cards after the next Modern reprint.
    Posted in: Market Street Café
  • posted a message on Eternal Prices, Interactions Between Format and Long Term Outcome
    A lot of people want to talk about the cost of Type 1 and 1.5 on a broad basis rather than just individual cards. There seems to be an increase around the board with Modern fetchlands and other staples going up. This was them followed by a radical increase in blue-based dual lands price. The Power 9 also seems to be rising with Black Lotus now selling between $2000 and $3000. Even fringe cards like Candelabra of Tawnos seems to have rised a little. Bazaar of Baghdad and Mishra's Workshop also increased in price even if Type 1 is usually considered a fringe format with no impact on card prices. Do you think Commander and Cube is driving Type 1 up?

    Do you think that its really the increase in Modern that rippled to the other formats with people trading their recently increased Modern staples for Legacy staples and Vintage staples. Do you think the raise will affect slightly less premium cards like non-blue duals? Would the price of everything go down when fetchlands will be reprinted?

    Feel free to discuss any topic related to the recent increase in price like its cause, its impact on future prices or any interactions between constructed format prices.
    Posted in: Market Street Café
  • posted a message on [[Official]] Legacy Huge Gainers
    It seems all the power has increased by %50, even more for Black Lotus, in the last year but the greatest increase seems pretty recent.
    Posted in: Market Street Café Archive
  • posted a message on Tips for buying the power 9?
    Near Mint is a strictly better investment because of rarity but you shouldn't play with your investment. Would you use a gold ingot as a door stopper? If you play enough games your cards will get damaged ever so slightly. It doesn't take much for a card not to be Near Mint. Trades are good but you need to know what to look. I don't care if it's easy to spot, if you don't know what to look for you should get them from stores. Many stores sell their power for really high prices because they don't want to trade them away for almost nothing, don't buy there. Stores are most likely to negotiate on expensive cards especially if it's been in the case for a long time. You can be surprised at how good a deal you can have in a store.

    There seems to have been a recent raise in their price but StarCityGames used to have the best prices on MP/signed power especially during their sales. Don't be afraid to ask for scans and ask questions about it. Cards are 3D objects and you can't see all the damage on a scan. Don't settle for non-tournament legal cards, most of the appeal of power is the ability to play vintage and you'll be glad to have it when a sanctioned event comes along. I find it hard to pay a significant chunk of the value for cards that are the same as proxies for all practical purposes. I don't know if it's only SCG but they had big raise in their power price in the last year or so. They used to have Black Lotus at $1000, now it's $1500. The whole game is going up in price and vintage staples seems to be on the raise too after some years of relative stagnation.
    Posted in: Market Street Café
  • posted a message on [[Official]] Legacy Huge Gainers
    Rishadan Port was banned so I doubt it could be reprinted in a Standard set. I don't think they've ever reprinted a banned card in a standard legal set.
    Posted in: Market Street Café Archive
  • posted a message on Power nine, all formats...
    According to the aggregated database http://mtgtop8.com/format?f=VI, each moxen are played more than Sol Ring. Let's look at this year vintage champ. Merfolk and the 2 RUG Delver have no Sol Ring but have moxen and Dredge has none of both. BUG Fish has no Sol Ring and Doomsday only in the sideboard at Bazaar of Moxen Paris, BUG Fish and Landstill have no Sol Ring but moxen at BoM 7. Sol Ring ramp you fast to a 4 drop but 4 drops can be hard to cast and many decks have no 4 drops. It also means you won't do anything on the first turn.
    Posted in: Magic General
  • posted a message on Power nine, all formats...
    Why does people think that Sol Ring is better than the moxen? Sol Ring let you cast a 2 mana colorless spell on the first turn and dies to Mental Misstep. Moxen let you play a 2 mana colored spell on the first turn. Almost no one will skip an in-color mox but Sol Ring is frequently skipped.
    Posted in: Magic General
  • posted a message on Why do you Pimp?
    Quote from Valanarch
    Or, you could spend the money on other formats. Or if you only like Legacy, spend the $30,000 that you would spend on foiling out Stoneblade in Japanese with the oldest printing of every card on actual stuff in real life. As I said before, a deck is just a deck. The shininess of the cards does not make the game any more enjoyable. I cannot believe that there are people who would prefer to spend huge amounts of money on making their deck shiny and a language that they can't read instead of using it in real life.


    What if they have everything else they need in real life. Maybe they want to get more out of their money than just a big inheritance.
    Posted in: Legacy (Type 1.5)
  • posted a message on Vicious but cheap EDH decks?
    If it is Duel Commander, the general can't be tucked unless you let it be.
    Posted in: Commander (EDH)
  • posted a message on Multiplayer Biorhythm/Monument Elves
    It requires a second color (or more), but I'm in love with Burning Wish in Elves to cast either Biorhythm, Hurricane or Blaze but also let you get more niche cards like Seeds of Innocence and Tranquility. You can even go super niche with cards like Leeches or Airborne Aid. I tend to play Ashnod's Altar to produce even more mana but it should be playable without it.

    Winter Orb and Armageddon are also really good but leads to a different style of play.

    Coat of Arms is a classic that I've always loved and cheaper than it used to be way back then.
    Posted in: Multiplayer
  • posted a message on 2013 Multiplayer Power Rankings: Land (Done! Thanks all!)
    I'm genuinely shocked that anyone would rate every colors at the same power level. It's as if no consideration to each colors play value was given.
    Posted in: Multiplayer
  • posted a message on 2013 Multiplayer Power Rankings: Land (Done! Thanks all!)
    Polluted Delta is good but not worth two cards.

    Here we see the difference between cube and multiplayer. While almost every mana producing lands are outclassed by dual/fetch/basic, it isn't the case in singleton format where there's room for the subpars lands.
    Posted in: Multiplayer
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.