I had no idea what to do with my power. I think if I had asked a good question on time it might have made all the difference, but maybe not as I was a light scum read for most of the game. What are good questions for a role like that?
Guys, I'm sorry but I've been sick. I've been keeping up with the thread, just not having any ambition to post.
I think it's probably Jenna and Killjoy. Jenna's obfuscation early game has been replaced by self preservation and scrambling. Killjoy has been more consistent but looking at past votals (ala Tau) and their deflection off of Bear has me suspecting the slot.
Reread Killjoy in light of the flips.
The big one is deflecting off of Bear arguing that it wasn't a likely lynch in the time remaining.
However, at one point in the phase Bear had the most votes. Vote Killjoy
Grapefruit is a credible lynch because Bear was scummy, (the end of day play leading to the Osie hammer, the lack of any real push on anyone), Grapefruits play was better, but still not really pressuring anyone. And it's just not possible to ignore the counter claim. Two town vigs seems extremely unlikely.
Talk me out of it, make a case for something/someone different. The big problem is I think a mislynch is a loss (3 scum, 5 town?), but we're not doing anything productive to change that.
and there's nothing between that and your vote that indicates you've changed that read of Grape. You've answered why you voted for Pizza, but not what your goal with that vote was since the lynch had already happened. And even if Grape flipped town, we hadn't necessarily lost since a successful block of the NK would have left us in LyLo today.
I had no goal. I thought we lost. I was never locked on scumGrape, but was very tunnelled on scumVoxx/Pizza. I was wrong.
@Jenna
Can you speak to any of the things I asked you five days ago? So you think Dot and Grape are town, ok, why?
Who do you think is scum and why? That's the problem, cryptic statements once in awhile aren't going to cut it at this point. If we don't get scum we lose. So if you're not scum, help me understand where you're coming from on your reads.
My big problem is nobody thought Voxx/Pizza was a thing until they had pressure brought on them. I'll be honest, I think it'd be a great feather in my cap to catch Pizza out. The game state is just not reflecting that.
However, nobody said anything about the possibility of Voxx/Pizza. Would scum not take advantage of that opportunity to push dirt on a veteran player? Why is a veteran player like Voxx/Pizza still alive?
what do you think about Jenna, Grape?
I've been expressing suspicion of Pizza and been largely ignored, why when there's pressure on you that Pizza starts to seem scummy?
I think it's probably Jenna and Killjoy. Jenna's obfuscation early game has been replaced by self preservation and scrambling. Killjoy has been more consistent but looking at past votals (ala Tau) and their deflection off of Bear has me suspecting the slot.
The big one is deflecting off of Bear arguing that it wasn't a likely lynch in the time remaining.
However, at one point in the phase Bear had the most votes.
Vote Killjoy
I had no goal. I thought we lost. I was never locked on scumGrape, but was very tunnelled on scumVoxx/Pizza. I was wrong.
I thought Grape might've been town, Pizza was scum and we had just lost. Clearly, I'm very, consistently wrong.
Can you speak to any of the things I asked you five days ago? So you think Dot and Grape are town, ok, why?
Who do you think is scum and why? That's the problem, cryptic statements once in awhile aren't going to cut it at this point. If we don't get scum we lose. So if you're not scum, help me understand where you're coming from on your reads.
My big problem is nobody thought Voxx/Pizza was a thing until they had pressure brought on them. I'll be honest, I think it'd be a great feather in my cap to catch Pizza out. The game state is just not reflecting that.
However, nobody said anything about the possibility of Voxx/Pizza. Would scum not take advantage of that opportunity to push dirt on a veteran player? Why is a veteran player like Voxx/Pizza still alive?
I've been expressing suspicion of Pizza and been largely ignored, why when there's pressure on you that Pizza starts to seem scummy?