2019 Holiday Exchange!
 
A New and Exciting Beginning
 
The End of an Era
  • posted a message on [Basic Game] [#82] Hayate the Combat Butler Mafia SCUM WIN
    My lack of care for this game is really really high. I might just ask for replacement, sorry.

    I will attempt to send out some stuff before I go. First off, haven't voted because I just straight up forgot. I would vote now, but I feel like it wouldn't be fair for my replacement.

    I don't know who to vote for, though. It's been, what, several extra pages and fulcrum has redeemed themselves fairly well, actively scum hunting with her "ask someone a question" which I think shows that fulcrum actively wants to get reads on people instead of being aggressively painting everyone scum. It's the phrasing, I guess, and even though the jump from Deathjoey to swishh back to no-one is still kind of suspect in my eyes, I really can't deny right now that fulcrum is showing her attempts to scum hunt. When you go "ask someone a question", that means that they're searching for reads and trying toget people more active - and it's something I can sympathize with. Scum just wouldn't do that, they don't actively search out reads.

    Um, swishh's vote on me is a thing and not complete OMGUS, but I'm not sure what else has changed since my last vote on him. I see nothing that forgives his earlier behaviour in regards to making up reasoning for his vote on Deathjoey. I'm kind of biased but I don't see the exact reasoning of swishh's case, but that's irrelevant because I can't read, apparently. I'm non-committal because of the lack of vote that I forgot. Got it. Am I missing something here?

    Also, troubled by the fact that a lot of what made swishh scum in my eyes was his interactions with fulcrum, who looks fairly town about now.

    It's been enough time that I'm OK making a list of people in the game:

    Rhand/Bigtraine: I still do not understand Bigtraine's case, but Rhand's reads are off to me. Whether that's because I disagree with them or because some of them are irrelevant - see my own, zeman, Azuriae - but that first post just reeked of off to me.

    Also, all that text and Im not exactly sure what his second highest scum read is. I personally don't like that.

    Condoms: has swag. I just like these people who come in, drop intent to vote and leave. It's just a thing. Yes, this is null.

    Kosa: no content. Coupled with my early scum read, I don't like this. Would go for #1 scum.

    storyteller: has he posted past Deathjoey saga? I do remember town posts from him, though. Would like a statement right about now.

    7hawk77: Any other time, I would call scum on hawk because of his simple commentary but I'm getting town reads out of his fingers. Questions is important, etc etc. He's been consistently town so far because... as a feeling, I can't explain, but it might be due to the in-depth questions he asks. He questions people's tactics, I guess. Through a town perspective.

    Zeman: posted more recently, I'm not sure if he's simply wordily barning swishh but I find it slightly suspect. He shows participation, so Null at best, though.

    Raptor: Quiet, don't like it. I had Azuriae as town, but RR is running 7hawk's commentary but at a lower level that seems fairly scummy. Needs more post for a solid read, but leaning scum.

    Deathjoey: ehhhhh. He seems like the type of guy that I can't read fairly well, but I haven't seen anything super scummy from him. Lean town.

    AG: town, case on fulcrum is still a good thing. I said he was light and fluffy before, but ever since the case of fulcrum I like him a lot more.

    Current scum era are:

    Kosa
    swishh
    Rhand/RR, depending on further posts

    Would vote Kosa for extra prod.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Basic Game] [#82] Hayate the Combat Butler Mafia SCUM WIN
    So I took a three day break from mafia because I went insane with something from another game, and now I'm done.

    Quote from fulcrum

    Quote from explosiveforce
    Fulcrum because he unvoted swishh for the silliest reason and that's all I can remember.

    Really? How was my reasoning silly?

    Since you have so many scum suspects, why don't you put a vote down?

    Quote from explosiveforce
    Yes, I thought that whole weak unvote vote from fulcrum off swishh indicates weak bussing to take suspicion away from swishh.

    Er, what?


    Your reasoning is silly because (the reasoning) was because of a really, really slow explanation that came after lots of scumminess (which I believe you even noted) from swishh. Unvoting him because he finally answered your question without even noting his precluding scumminess was something very unexpected and scummy to me. It felt like you were just finding access to argue your case against swishh.

    The easiest explanation, for me, was that you were weakly bussing swishh. Is the term distancing? I think it's called distancing. Does that make more sense? I'm bad at mafia language apparently

    ---

    In regards to current people:

    Did a quick ISO on bigtraine - nothing incredibly scummy stands out to me at first glance. /shrug How much did bigtraine push the newbie card in WWII? I might go check myself. That's pretty much the only obvious thing that I can see.

    Condoms' intent to vote is whatever. I like this guy. He's reckless.

    AtheistGod's case seems good enough, I don't see anything untowards. Loaded questions and whatnot can be made by overzealous/tunneling town and are not necessarily indicative of scumminess.

    Kosa/storyteller/zeman/RR need to post more.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Basic Game] [#82] Hayate the Combat Butler Mafia SCUM WIN
    Quote from Deathjoey

    Do you think it's possible for fulcrum and swishh to be scum together?
    Which is more likely to be scum in your opinion?

    And since you were indignant when I didn't ask you about your experience, what's your previous level of experience?

    Yes, I thought that whole weak unvote vote from fulcrum off swishh indicates weak bussing to take suspicion away from swishh.

    If I was going to choose who was more scum, it would probably be swishh. At an outside chance swishh is just fairly dense town (but Occam's Razor) while fulcrum's unvote on swishh to the next vote on, Bigtraine for weaker reasons than swishh, could be seen as throwing suspicion on every person he can so that he can net a mislynch on everyone later. But they're probably both scum anyways.


    This (second thread) is an example of a town game, while this is an example of a scum game. yeah handle is ownedbyasmartbomb. Similar to the former Azuriae's meta, it's 48 hour day phases, 24 hour night phases, fluff on the first day, etc etc.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Basic Game] [#82] Hayate the Combat Butler Mafia SCUM WIN
    I've been reading because that's all I can do right now. I'm kind of sick with a terrible throat infection and it's messing me up.

    Um scum candidates are swishh, fulcrum, and someone else who I haven't decided on yet, because Im haven't been properly reading. Swishh because it took him a long time just to justify his point, which reads "Oh I was oppurtunistic scum I've been caught, let's make some excuse and then concentrate on Bigtraine for a silly reason - I do distinctly remember in past games that everyone unvotes because RVS is over. . Fulcrum because he unvoted swishh for the silliest reason and that's all I can remember. I did see AG's post and I'm aware I might be kind of barning him.

    Oh yeah, and Kosa, though that's changing . Kosa because I don't trust his response to 7hawk77. But his nex few posts were OK, so I'm not 100% sure on I need to reread eventually.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Basic Game] [#82] Hayate the Combat Butler Mafia SCUM WIN
    Quote from swishh
    Quote from fulcrum
    Unvote
    Vote swishh


    Explain "words, words, words" for me.


    there were lots of words in his RVS posts


    you don't say

    Please explain how this makes him scum and don't say "because there were words in it" because I will vote you because you've posted words
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Basic Game] [#82] Hayate the Combat Butler Mafia SCUM WIN
    ^I don't understand the relevance as it pertains to mafia?

    Activity will be spotty for the rest of this week. Swishh noted as also not paying attention to the game atm. AG noted for being cute and fluffy.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Basic Game] [#82] Hayate the Combat Butler Mafia SCUM WIN
    Quote from zemanjaski
    Quote from explosiveforce
    Vote: zemanjaski

    I disagree with his idea of a good username. Explosive force is one of the most unoriginal names ever.


    OMGUS and unaustralian booooo.

    You're town though right?


    Yeah, I'm town. Town>>>>Mafia

    Quote from swishh
    I'm a day cop.


    You're silly.

    Quote from Deathjoey
    Quote from fulcrum
    Quote from Deathjoey
    Sorry fulcrum, bad memories from last game.

    Swishh - did you by any chance happen to read WWII Mafia?

    Oh, you were calling me scum with swishh. Please. I'm better at bussing than that.

    Yes, I'm fully aware that you're much better than that...

    Quote from fulcrum

    I was actually questioning this bit:
    Quote from Deathjoey
    Wow swishh you caught me.
    Unvote vote deathjoey
    Omg I'm at 3 votes look at the speed of this wagon. Time to unvote and do some wagon analysis.

    unvote

    Storyteller, swishh, and deathjoey. There is guaranteed at least one scum on this wagon.

    Was I perhaps missing sarcasm tags?
    I just drew a parallel here to what generic did d1.

    Swishh, you should read through early d1 of WWII.
    You'll get it then.


    Reads like a natural defense made scummy by the fact that Deathjoey used sarcasm and an obscure reference. Sarcasm is generally scummy outside of RVS, obscure reference requires overexplanation. Also the joke fell flat on everyone, but it was clearly meant to be a joke.

    I don't like how he didn't ask the other >10 post newbie about his experience level when he was around. Part of that is egotism, part of that feels like the post about Azuriae was deflection/distraction.

    ^kosakosa's post: this interests me. Can you or someone else walk through why you don't being asked if you're scum or not?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on [Basic Game] [#82] Hayate the Combat Butler Mafia SCUM WIN
    Vote: zemanjaski

    I disagree with his idea of a good username. Explosive force is one of the most unoriginal names ever.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Basic 82? 'Hayate The Combat Butler' Mafia Sign-Ups CLOSED
    ...this is an /in post.
    Posted in: Old Sign-ups
  • posted a message on [[DGM]] Emmara Tandris
    People say this card is bad.

    People say this card is dumb and terrible design.

    I think it's the smartest card in Dragon's Maze. It fits in one particular niche and is theoretically the absolute greatest in said niche. The fact that no-one has realised what R & D has done by printing this card is indicative of how sneaky this card is.

    Simply put, I believe this card, where by coincidence or on purpose, was printed to make people use the seven-drop spot on Momir Basic instead of being scared of Phage the Untouchable.
    Posted in: New Card Discussion
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.