-
- AnImAr_
- Registered User
-
Member for 11 years and 9 months
Last active Tue, Jul, 6 2021 11:38:48
- 0 Followers
- 1,755 Total Posts
- 747 Thanks
-
Sep 11, 2019
4
schindar posted a message on [ELD] Righteousness reprintI think I traded a dual land for one of these back in 94.Posted in: The Rumor Mill -
Sep 11, 20193
lookingupanddown posted a message on Mothership 9/11 - cards from rapunzel and morePosted in: The Rumor Mill
Right, so apparently the dwarves aren't the only thing in this art in sevens. Time to start looking? Here's some music for inspiration.
-
Sep 11, 20197
bobthefunny posted a message on Ayara, First of LocthwainEnough. This is not the place.Posted in: The Rumor Mill
Personal attacks will not be tolerated. Sexist, Misogynistic, or other comments that insult or degrade a group of people will not be tolerated.
From our Rules:
Quote from Rules»Flaming is a hostile verbal attack directed at another person or group of people. Trolling is the act of deliberately provoking a hostile reaction from other users. These actions will not be tolerated. Additionally, harassing and flaming someone via PMs may trigger more severe offenses, up to and including a suspension. -
Sep 10, 2019
2
Crispen_Smith posted a message on {ELD] Robber of the Rich (@JEDepraz spoiler)Posted in: The Rumor MillQuote from Neuroticneurok »Quote from MercurialMemory »Could be an oppressive card. Also, you absolutely get access to all exiled cards whenever any rogue attacks.
Conditions to be met for ability to be triggered:
1. Robber needs to attack.
2. Your opponent must have more cards in hand that you.
3. If conditions 1 and 2 are met, Robber exiles the top card of their library.
4. During any turn you attacked with a Rogue (Robber or other), you may cast THAT card. (Does not specify other cards exiled in this way that were not cast, only the most recent one exiled after the first three steps)
5. If you cast that card, you may spend mana as if it were any color to cast it, blah blah.
Reading it a line at a time, it's quite clear. Nowhere on the card does it explicitly specify that any card BEYOND THE ONE YOU HAVE CURRENTLY EXILED is playable, and thus, the Rules Committee will need to make a ruling on what this card ACTUALLY does.
If it DOES end up allowing you to cast exiled cards from past turns, then this is a pretty good card. If it's only the most recently exiled card, it's not quite as amazing but still has applications, most likely in midrange and control decks.
it definately reads to me like each card gets exiled in it's own little bubble that gets unlocked every time you attack with 1 or more rogues. I don't find the language at all ambiguous. An argument could be made that 'each card...." may be clearer except that now the bubble belongs to Robin, not to the exiled card. Really there's no other way to word this for the function they intended - that cards exiled by Robin gain extra text while in exile.
No, the biggest question is why "of the rich" was required... they're the best people to rob from anyway.
-
Sep 10, 20192
Neuroticneurok posted a message on {ELD] Robber of the Rich (@JEDepraz spoiler)Posted in: The Rumor MillQuote from HighHolder »Flavour win, card fail.
It's missing the 'cast without paying mana' clause, and like other cards like this it will fail.,
I'd hardly say it qualifies as a failure. Even if you don't cast the cards you're stripping them out of your opponent's library and making them useless. With just that alone, it's a human with Reach, Haste, and Ingest. -
Aug 7, 20194
Buffsam89 posted a message on [C19] jumbo commander preview- song of the worldsoulPosted in: The Rumor Millor how broken this is
Is this really necessary on every card you create a thread for? -
Aug 7, 20192
SyrixLoremaster posted a message on [C19] Tahngarth, First mate (new and improve Tahngarth)Posted in: The Rumor MillQuote from AnImAr_ »This card is nuts for EDH. Make other people kill with your commander with commander damage.
Just for clarification, your opponent gains control of Tahngarth but the effect doesn't untap him so you do get to determine combat, you just dont get to have them "Xantcha" Tahngarth.
Edit: So... uh apparently I can't read. This is why I shouldn't post 5 mins after I wake up.
That said, he seems less exciting now. What I THOUGHT I read was some variation of Portal Mage. My mistake. Carry on. Nothing to see here. -
Aug 7, 20191
AylaTheCat posted a message on [C19] Marisi, Breaker of the CoilI was hoping for Zaliki, but Marisi is dead so this is really the only place to card him. I can finally build Naya Cats after a decade of waiting for a legend though!Posted in: The Rumor Mill -
Aug 7, 20191
cyberium_neo posted a message on [C19] Marisi, Breaker of the Coil"A legendary Nacatl, who rebelled against the Empire of the Clouds, and broke the Coil."Posted in: The Rumor Mill
He's from Alara and incited a rebellion for his people. Nice lore call back, and I just LOVE more combat! -
Aug 7, 20191
Raptorchan posted a message on [C19] Marisi, Breaker of the CoilI like it. You basically have to hit all of your opponents once with anything and everything else is not your business anymore.Posted in: The Rumor Mill - To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
1
1
If this art wasn’t a land you could make a case. Injecting your hurt feelings makes no sense in this context.
1
1
Lazy design. Make this 3BB and to give -2/-2 to YOUR OPPONENT’S creatures if you’re going to do this.
2/5.
1
1
Phew
1
Oh in commander you're not playing this wrath. I'd rather play Fumigate.
4
1
Anyway, this is a pretty damn good card for devotion and for making a vigilant, indestructible creature every turn. Time for Mono W Aggro.
1