Magic Market Index for Nov 2nd, 2018
 
Magic Market Index for October 26th, 2018
 
Magic Market Index for October 12th, 2018
  • posted a message on Banned Mafia - Game over, Town LANDSLIDE VICTORY!
    This was a good game to come back for
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Banned Mafia - Game over, Town LANDSLIDE VICTORY!
    So no fakeclaim?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Banned Mafia - Game over, Town LANDSLIDE VICTORY!
    I imagine it wasn't so fun for the scum team.

    you misspelled grapefruit
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Banned Mafia - Game over, Town LANDSLIDE VICTORY!
    was that your first vote this game? Grin
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Banned Mafia - Game over, Town LANDSLIDE VICTORY!
    I can only do one thing a night, not both
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Banned Mafia - Game over, Town LANDSLIDE VICTORY!
    I guess i'll go.
    Im deathrite shaman
    Im the doc and i can self-protect.
    If i get rid of a town corpse i can protect someone else.
    If i get rid of a mafia or neutral corpse i can self protect.
    If one of my targets becomes invalid my ability fails.
    Last night i tried to get rid of the goblin corpse to protect highroller, but failed because the corpse was already devoured.

    I think i like my vote on dan. Also az's play today seems really odd.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Banned Mafia - Game over, Town LANDSLIDE VICTORY!
    I want the rest of it
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Banned Mafia - Game over, Town LANDSLIDE VICTORY!
    bulletproof
    GGT is a green card, not G/B
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Banned Mafia - Game over, Town LANDSLIDE VICTORY!
    vote ganderin_dan
    dan half claimed in 753, but i want the rest and im willing to put him at L-2
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Banned Mafia - Game over, Town LANDSLIDE VICTORY!
    Quote from ganderin_dan »
    I was hoping to get some clarity on both the claim order and how much we were claiming, given that both of those things are unagreed upon.

    I'm Golgari Grave-Troll, town BP. Green (and black?!) Creature - Skeleton Troll.

    At night, I target and devour a corpse. For each [redacted] corpse(s) I eat, I become one-shot BP.


    why didnt you finish your post?
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Banned Mafia - Game over, Town LANDSLIDE VICTORY!
    Also
    unvote

    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Banned Mafia - Game over, Town LANDSLIDE VICTORY!
    @dan i dont have meta reads, but i will reread those posts in a bit and see what i think.

    Im not a land
    Not opposed to claims either.

    @terry calm down, lol. Ive been sick.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Banned Mafia - Game over, Town LANDSLIDE VICTORY!
    your only actual "read" was cantrip and that was weak and you didn't actually push it even though you said you were.
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Banned Mafia - Game over, Town LANDSLIDE VICTORY!
    Quote from Grapefruit21 »
    I don't have a feel at all for Axel this game. I remember vaguely thinking townie but I don't have anything in my notes.

    Lynching Terry, Rez, Bur, KA, and Dan probably nets at least 2 scum. Vig should always fire in there. Rez deserves a ton of skepticism for the late wagon hop. KA looks okay-ish but again we didn't have the numbers when he moved off. Dan doing somehow less than Bur is a giant red flag. Terry needs a lynch.

    i dont think grape gives up both of his buddies in this post. kinda wine, but thats just my thought on it.
    -----
    Quote from vezokpiraka »
    Quote from Grapefruit21 »
    Anyway RB's are a common scum role. They are also commonly town in Role Madness games. Both sides usually need some form of blocking. The fact that I haven't been CC'd is a great look for me to be quite honest.
    This feels scummy.

    @vezok: Can you give something better than "not feeling"? More detailed, at least?


    Maybe.

    Grape doesn't feel like scum. He is fighting his lynch and claimed a role that would mostly be -EV as a scum claim. His wagon also doesn't look like scum trying to save a body.

    Terry is just doing nothing, but fighting his lynch and I just came out of a game with Albertino where he did the exact same thing and I was convinced he was scum. (he was town)

    I'm just unconvinced on both of them. I'd rather lynch someone else, but I will vote one of them before the deadline. Probably the one with more votes on him.

    vezok would rather lynch someone else, but only voted for myself, grape, cantrip, and terry (and bur in rvs) yesterday so lets get into that:

    115: votes cantrip:
    -KA voted cantrip 5 posts prior (where KA votes cantrip because of meta)
    -puts me at 60% town, calls cantrips vote on me in 31 opportunistic
    -calls cantrips play shallow and non-commital and full of nothing.
    (a reread of cantrups posts up to this point shows:
    51: looks good, questions at dan moos and grape are solid
    91: responds reasonably to grape and moo, the stuff between he and highroller makes my eyes glaze over though
    105: pushes grape along with some meta and highroller stuff.
    this part of vezos post does not read as genuine.)

    -points out cantrip was scum in his last 5 games

    posts re: cantrip are mostly based on meta.

    245: "I kinda want to move my vote to grape, but Cantrip keeps doing these things that just more and more scummy."

    295-298: he and iso associate ka with grape

    331: votes rez:
    -"I think this is a reasonable lynch although I'm not convinced he is scum."
    -currently there are 3 votes on me:
    -KA (318: basically naked)
    -Grapefruit (149: "I just don't get his focus this game")
    -Bur (26 "#25, which felt really awkward")

    336: town meta read on grape, "middle of the road" "I could go for lynching him if it comes to that, but I'd rather try rezombied first" "I'm bad at reading grape so I just kinda assume he is town and work from there"

    438: votes grapefruit: not feeling terry. grapes claim is dubious, but "not really that bad" " I'd still rather lynch cantrip or rezomb."

    450: defends grape against cantrips questions

    453: "I'm still gathering support to lynch [cantrip], not sure why you think I should stop when I don't really consider any of the big wagons even close to as scummy as you. I won't try to push a case I don't believe in."
    -emphasis mine

    457: more meta about cantrip "I'm voting grape at the moment and trying to push my real read. You damn well now that a wagon can form hours before the deadline so I'm still giving my best to push the game in the direction I want to."

    484: votes terry:
    -"I'd prefer gan too, but I'm not feeling either terry or grape."

    509: unvotes
    -"I'm not feeling this wagon either."
    -tries to get terry to name someone to vote besides grape.

    521: defends grape, defends terry, unconvinced on both. "I'd rather lynch someone else, but I will vote one of them before the deadline. Probably the one with more votes on him."

    532: votes terry, justified by just wanting to lynch someone

    624: votes grape:
    -"I just want a lynch right now and I will figure things out later. I have some suspicions avout the scum team, but I gotta see a flip before I decide on things. Terry is not happening even though I think that is the superior lynch."

    So, clears grape based on meta, "pushes cantrip" based on meta, shows no real reads based on interaction in game. talks about wanting to push cantrrip, but doesnt, and wagon hops back and forth until the end of the day.

    Vote: vezokpiraka
    Posted in: Mafia
  • posted a message on Banned Mafia - Game over, Town LANDSLIDE VICTORY!
    @Rezom: Vezo said:

    "And even if I actually thought that my post would influence anyone, I'd still do it as any alignment"

    You said:

    "I don't care. "I do this every game" isn't really a valid argument to me right now."

    It's really straight forward, which why I responded to you in the way I did, multiple times.

    This completely misrepresents that exchange because the full quote is: (emphasis mine) "And even if I actually thought that my post would influence anyone, I'd still do it as any alignment as I have a strong history of suggesting different types of mass-claims early game even though almost the entire MTGS playerbase considers it a bad idea."
    Posted in: Mafia
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.