I don't mind going early if you all think I'm scum.
I just want my biggest not yet claimed lead (Karn) to go before I do.
It's he who chooses the next claim.
TOWN
7hawk77: I never had a strong scumread on Che, and Hawk gives me no reasons to change that. Che was agressive, but his motives seemed correct. Hawk's play is also very much different from the scum play in [redacted]
LEANING TOWN
Tom: He reacted well to my pushes on him (albeit a bit omgus-ish) and still is in control. I stay wary of him though: I'm not used to him taking this much control of a game and I haven't seen him as scum yet.
50/50
Generic: I don't like his overreactions to the pushes against him. But because there's no meta to compare with, I can't tell if there's a scum motivation behind that. His frustration might well come from a town mindset.
MRHBlue: I don't have much of a read on him. He's been pushed around a lot and has been the center of conversations. I need to see more bodies drop to assess him properly.
SharkFinnigan: I can't read Shark. he's been moving up and down my T/S list all game.
LEANING SCUM
Petard: Mainly for being the only one not on the Mist wagon. Scum hardly ever piles on 1 wagon with the load of them. More POE than anything else.
Sir Karn: I had a town read on Len, but Karn's pushes on Tom aren't all that good.
SCUM
iRebel: for reasons already stated and because of his claim (I will explain when we did / rejected the massclaim)
I omitted Polski because I don't want to talk about him until we massclaimed.
Tcm: day 1 you didn't hunt me while you kept saying I was scum.
That was enough reason for me to cop you.
You can't call my day 2 tunelling: I knew you weren't town.
Stormblind: a vig wasting an item on you is not the best solution for your situation if you're town.
A brief case on Asenion:
He's an active lurker (which isn't a scumtell). Not much content in many of his posts; he's talking about mechanics more than about behaviour.
I really, really dislike this post:
I haven't played the set yet and don't know how rare 2-drops will be, so I'll go with your judgement.
I think I would pick Battering Krasis if I was drafting alone
@Tom: I took that step back and no longer have you in my scumspects. I don't want to talk about Polski until after the massclaim for obvious reasons.
If you don't mind, I would also like to wait with expanding on Karn until after that.
I do mind. I don't want your t/s list to consist of "because his claim was like this instead of this." I want actual content from you, actual thoughts on players unrelated to any claims.
I also can't see your "torn on Karn" thing having anything to do with the claims, so do that now please.
Karn's case against you has parts where he pulls things out of context to paint a scummy picture of you. I know that I have a tendencie to do that as well when I think I found scum, so I know that you don't have to be scum to do this. That's why I'm torn. And that's why I want him to claim first.
This has the potential to go very wrong.
Tcm might attract multiple item passes, which means those items don't get passed to town tonight.
Time for me to claim my night action.
I copped tcm tonight. The result was not town. I used a bloodhound to do this.
I'm going to do a reread this weekend. Some of the pushes on Mist seem off, but I want to put them into perspective before I comment on them.
Mist: I still want you to answer more detailed on Fairy's case on you.
This occured during D1. IRL happened during this phase and after it. When you caught up, you made no mention of this. How come?
My reread gave me completely different insights and I was no longer focused on this when I finished it. But good point. I'll take a new look at the Mist wagon.
@Tom: I took that step back and no longer have you in my scumspects. I don't want to talk about Polski until after the massclaim for obvious reasons.
If you don't mind, I would also like to wait with expanding on Karn until after that.
I just want my biggest not yet claimed lead (Karn) to go before I do.
It's he who chooses the next claim.
If he's telling the truth and is SK, then my suspicion of you diminishes.
This is my T/S:
TOWN
7hawk77: I never had a strong scumread on Che, and Hawk gives me no reasons to change that. Che was agressive, but his motives seemed correct. Hawk's play is also very much different from the scum play in [redacted]
LEANING TOWN
Tom: He reacted well to my pushes on him (albeit a bit omgus-ish) and still is in control. I stay wary of him though: I'm not used to him taking this much control of a game and I haven't seen him as scum yet.
50/50
Generic: I don't like his overreactions to the pushes against him. But because there's no meta to compare with, I can't tell if there's a scum motivation behind that. His frustration might well come from a town mindset.
MRHBlue: I don't have much of a read on him. He's been pushed around a lot and has been the center of conversations. I need to see more bodies drop to assess him properly.
SharkFinnigan: I can't read Shark. he's been moving up and down my T/S list all game.
LEANING SCUM
Petard: Mainly for being the only one not on the Mist wagon. Scum hardly ever piles on 1 wagon with the load of them. More POE than anything else.
Sir Karn: I had a town read on Len, but Karn's pushes on Tom aren't all that good.
SCUM
iRebel: for reasons already stated and because of his claim (I will explain when we did / rejected the massclaim)
I omitted Polski because I don't want to talk about him until we massclaimed.
That was enough reason for me to cop you.
You can't call my day 2 tunelling: I knew you weren't town.
Stormblind: a vig wasting an item on you is not the best solution for your situation if you're town.
Good, then you won't NK me tonight
Stardust: do you think it possible that both wagons are scum? I find that very improbable for a D1 end and I feel worse about Asenion than about TMCT.
He's an active lurker (which isn't a scumtell). Not much content in many of his posts; he's talking about mechanics more than about behaviour.
I really, really dislike this post:
He seems to be afraid of Macius getting lynched.
An even briefer case on TMCT:
He did a lot of Swishh attacking. He seems to know Void is town and seems responsible for the blocked vote.
This game is a mess. I don't feel comfortable with blindly following Seppel in this.
Kosa: voting Void won't help us at this point.
Ehm no, I don't feel like defending him
It's just that I can't imagine both wagons at the end of the day being on scum.
I'm gonna try and case both today because that always helps to get perspective (I hope I manage within the time I have ).
I haven't played the set yet and don't know how rare 2-drops will be, so I'll go with your judgement.
I think I would pick Battering Krasis if I was drafting alone
Karn's case against you has parts where he pulls things out of context to paint a scummy picture of you. I know that I have a tendencie to do that as well when I think I found scum, so I know that you don't have to be scum to do this. That's why I'm torn. And that's why I want him to claim first.
No reason to end the day early now. We need to discuss the hammer.
Tcm might attract multiple item passes, which means those items don't get passed to town tonight.
Time for me to claim my night action.
I copped tcm tonight. The result was not town. I used a bloodhound to do this.
My reread gave me completely different insights and I was no longer focused on this when I finished it. But good point. I'll take a new look at the Mist wagon.
@Tom: I took that step back and no longer have you in my scumspects. I don't want to talk about Polski until after the massclaim for obvious reasons.
If you don't mind, I would also like to wait with expanding on Karn until after that.
@tom: I'm observing what is happening, and am torn on karn's sincerity.
Irebel is the lynch for today anyhow.
I propose a mass name and flavor claim popcorn-style before I share why.