I have the name "Observer", and I rock targeted Rhand.
I got no results, only that I burned my initial upgrade level and upgraded. But no actual results. Assuming Rhand chose paper, or I am wrong about what my role does.
Spoiler: I didn’t.
@ZDS: I was in a weird space where I had developed scumreads on both of you, but was also convinced you weren’t scum together.
That post did push me to the vote I ended up with.
I think I want to oust GJ now.
I don’t think HR is mafia and I don’t think ZDS and Grape are mafia together, so that leaves ZDS / GJ and Grape / GJ.
I’m gonna try to figure out Grape / ZDS this phase.
I was going to ask why you did nothing to defend him, but you missed the complete wagon buildup so meh :/
Would you have lynched GJ over ZDS?
Would have preferred ZDS but gone GJ because of the votes to tie the wagons. If I'd been around I would have been pushing ZDS still.
And yeah, I had cold feet on Pokechu when I left over the random town read on me, but the explanation was believable and in the end it didn't feel like a pocket attempt so I figured town on mindmeld ground.
Can you point me to where he explained his town read on you?
It's early morning and I just woke up so I'm not going to make a long post or comment on anything, but I agree we should massclaim and I was already planning on claiming in my first post no matter what happened (I'm obviously the #1 kick candidate after yesterDay).
I am the Doorman, I Scissored Whispy (hoping to do something helpful for him, he was my top town after re-reading) and I received no Night result.
That's it for now, I'll post more in ~13 hours.
What helpful thing did you figure your role could do?
Clarification, does that mean Kick or Lose? Like, if we don't get a mafia today, we're done?
If so, that confirms we have two mafia. I think it would be in our best interests to not vote for a bit lest the mafia pounce on the opportunity.
I believe we should massclaim, including who we targeted, what we threw, and what results we got, last night.
I would like ZDS to go first, seeing as I believe he's the most suspicious person, and also because I targeted him last night with my ability and I would like to hear what he has to say to give him as little room to fake claim as possible.
And yeah, we have to hit or we lose here. So we need to take this slowly. In favor of a mass claim.
Proposing an order of ZDS>GJ>me>Rhand>HR.
I’m fine with this order. HR is my only strong townread so I don’t mind going before him.
I haven’t reread yet, I’ll get to that the coming days.
@GJ you’re up next
@Grape what would you have done with your vote if you would have been around at EOD?
(Situation was Pokechu at 3 votes, GJ at 2, ZDS at 1)
Most Entertaining Player Slothful, especially in spectator chats
Most Improved Player Lastwhisper
Mod Awards:
Best Design
3 games come to mind: Seasons, Voldemort and Prison Block II.
Seasons had that mafia calendar that ended up having a negative impact on town’s fun in the game.
Voldemort had a false mason, which should never exist.
So my pick is Prison Block II
I was talking about from the perspective of a wolf?
weird flex though
Oh right. Went back to look for a post for no reason at all :/
Where did Grape go? I want to see his thoughts before this Day ends.
And wasn’t GJ going to make a bigger post too? I liked him early on but he hasn’t posted anything of value lately.
@Poke you asked who my avatar was. Just a random “Trophy Boy” Andrew Christian underwear model.
but like since GJ is there? it's hard to say, if he is bussing it's not gunna save him from me. You win micro's by looking townie, not by voting off your partners.
If that is what you believe, then why don’t you care about how you look?
I don't really think anyone needs to worry about me atm lol. I'm just existing, not radiating towniness nor wolfiness. I'm good right where I am
If u want some thoughts you can ask me, in between my regular posts, which I'll probably spend some time talking about your new scum lean @ZDS, and Pokechu's posts in detail
Another thing, me and GJ have both seen both alignments from ZDS, both consist of more walls than real time, so that early post should have done nothing for him. Ohh look he made a wall, it's so townie, yet somehow highroller can't pull out. Reason to hate it. Ok boomers
Also it shouldn't take you so much time to explain why Whispy is lower in your reads list than Rhand and Grape, you had to order your list that way for a reason.
I make posts not only to answer others' questions but also to further my own understandings. Wisp sits right at null for me because a lot of his posts are simply reacting or open thinking. Like, two-line posts. Not necessarily scummy but there's some "noise" you have to look past to find his conclusions (many of which didn't ping me strongly). Actually, I don't remember any conclusions. I think the slot is unreadable tbh.
This is one post of his that piqued my interest in my catch up:
Lastly, I think ZDS has given the best read of me so far, "He isn't playing like his wolf or town game",
I was going to ask why he took knowledge of this, but did not make a further comment. Why is he deliberately playing unlike he would usually do? But I could form my own answer (for fun, want to try something new, maybe because it's a mini/7 person game). If Wisp could answer this that'd be cool since I wasn't sure what tell this could be. Hence why I put him as null.
Highroller talks in to many absolutes for my liking, literally feels like he is creating a narrative everytime he talks. He has the whole game figured out, so why are we even playing lol?
I will comment more once I reread to make sure I don't end up talking out my ass
I do agree with this post of his but I wasn't sure town or scum, which perspective it's likelier to come from. I haven't seen a scum!Wisp yet but this is a real observation Wisp makes here (one I feel as well, I stated HR made it feel like the answer is on a silver platter). I imagine a scum player could say this but it would be better said as a real push against HR but instead Wisp is focusing on GJ. Maybe scum!Wisp said it because his partner is pushing against HR?
ok i guess that is a fair point lol, didn't think about that wording
If Wisp didn't think about that wording, why did he choose it? Like, very wishy-washy. It's not the town Wisp I played with in our one game together but I know that scum!Wisp would be doing better. Or at least, I hope he would.
Good luck with that, and I am staying out of the slap fight because I don't necessarily think HR is a wolf, and am not going to bother trying to change his mind on you
At this point I am just trying to figure if you are in fact town or just mafia
maybe give me some cases on why someone is town, rather than always trying to find reasons why someone new is mafia
Another post that seems like LHF (low hanging fruit). "I don't think HR is scum but I'm not going to try to change his mind. Also make some cases for me" This reads pretty lazy. Like, Wisp isn't involving himself in anything.
because I do what I want, and sometimes I need someone else talking about something to motivate me to talk about it as well, as for the Rhand quote I pulled out, I don't particularly have a reason for picking it out, I was just curious since Rhand plays with a lot of wine based on his own mafia play
IF ZDS is town, I am locking my vote on Highroller for funsies day 2
another lazy post.
I know Wisp is a strong player but what he's given us so far is wimpy. But based on what I've seen from his town game I doubt that this is his scumgame. Want to see the slot be more involved but at the moment I'm more suspicious of ZDS/GJ/HR - though I wouldn't be against a Wisp lynch.
You have 3/6 players you’re more suspicious of but you wouldn’t mind a Wisp lynch?
So the only ones you wouldn’t lynch are me and Grape? What has Grape even done to deserve that “honor”?
[quote from="Lastwhisper »" url="/forums/community-forums/mafia/819846-shoushiling-mafia-day-1?comment=172"]
@Pokechu what community (or communities) do you usually play in?
Smashboards. I've also played twice on Mafia Universe. The only one in this game I've played with before is Wispy Woods.
What communities/community do you play in? I think you played in this year's Championships on MU, right? I did 2019. I won - barely! LOL But you might've played with someone named Kary? They're from my place! Smashboards!!! I love Kary :^) (but don't tell them that)
</blockquote>
I did play the championship yes, Kary was our last Nightkill in the qualifier.
I play mainly here and a bit on Mafia Colosseum and Civilisation Fanatics and a game here and there elsewhere.
I remember that Kary wasn’t a fan of having to explain herself.
Anyways, I don’t know the culture of your site apart from seeing Kary in action. I mainly wanted to know if brushing off a post with laughter is normal behavior there.
LOL no
It's just me. I laugh at everything. Everywhere. I don't care the context I'm gonna laugh. I never think people would be surprised at it. But people are. Maybe I'm weird
</blockquote>
Nothing wrong with having fun, but the way you dismissed ZDS’s post with didn’t read but lol rubs me wrong.
But so does ZDS’s persistent HR read that then disappears in a cloud of “too many mafia for the game”.
And there’s no way you’re mafia together.
Spoiler: I didn’t.
@ZDS: I was in a weird space where I had developed scumreads on both of you, but was also convinced you weren’t scum together.
That post did push me to the vote I ended up with.
I think I want to oust GJ now.
I don’t think HR is mafia and I don’t think ZDS and Grape are mafia together, so that leaves ZDS / GJ and Grape / GJ.
I’m gonna try to figure out Grape / ZDS this phase.
Can you point me to where he explained his town read on you?
I was going to ask why you did nothing to defend him, but you missed the complete wagon buildup so meh :/
Would you have lynched GJ over ZDS?
What helpful thing did you figure your role could do?
I’m fine with this order. HR is my only strong townread so I don’t mind going before him.
I haven’t reread yet, I’ll get to that the coming days.
@GJ you’re up next
@Grape what would you have done with your vote if you would have been around at EOD?
(Situation was Pokechu at 3 votes, GJ at 2, ZDS at 1)
Best Town Performance (Individual)
Best Mafia Performance (Individual)
Best 3rd Party Performance (Individual)
Best Town Performance (Group)
Best Mafia Performance (Group)
Best Town Player
Best Mafia Player
Best Overall Player
Best Newcomer
Most Entertaining Player
Slothful, especially in spectator chats
Most Improved Player
Lastwhisper
Mod Awards:
Best Design
3 games come to mind: Seasons, Voldemort and Prison Block II.
Seasons had that mafia calendar that ended up having a negative impact on town’s fun in the game.
Voldemort had a false mason, which should never exist.
So my pick is Prison Block II
Best Flavor
Best Role
Tom Riddle from Voldemort’s Throne Room
Best Read
Game of the Year
Are you mafia Pokechu?
Also, come play with us again!
Oh right. Went back to look for a post for no reason at all :/
Where did Grape go? I want to see his thoughts before this Day ends.
And wasn’t GJ going to make a bigger post too? I liked him early on but he hasn’t posted anything of value lately.
@Poke you asked who my avatar was. Just a random “Trophy Boy” Andrew Christian underwear model.
If that is what you believe, then why don’t you care about how you look?
Do you not like Wisp or do you have conflicting feelings? You say both in one post with no reasoning for anything whatsoever.
Then why aren’t you voting GJ? Or what is it that you like?
I do not understand what you’re saying here
You have 3/6 players you’re more suspicious of but you wouldn’t mind a Wisp lynch?
So the only ones you wouldn’t lynch are me and Grape? What has Grape even done to deserve that “honor”?
vote Pokechu
Nothing wrong with having fun, but the way you dismissed ZDS’s post with didn’t read but lol rubs me wrong.
But so does ZDS’s persistent HR read that then disappears in a cloud of “too many mafia for the game”.
And there’s no way you’re mafia together.