Fair enough. I'm theoretically ready to cut Calculatron, I just haven't had enough opportunities to cube with it yet, so I don't want to cut it now.Quote from Salmo »Its really just a meta question IMO: do people you play with like Geist or Mage more? I'd keep the one that's actually wanted.
But in reality, be ready to cut Calcutron, I have not liked it due to how much it can complicate games and be misplayed with whereas all the other options either support the same deck in a better way or are just strong cards. Maybe you're having better results than me, but it's really not wanted and that's not where I want my guild cards to be.
This is basically where I'm at. I think Geist is stronger in a vacuum, and has more than carried its weight. salmo is correct that whatever I cut will probably find its way back into the cube soon enough anyways.Quote from AntiPox »I had to make this exact choice when making room for Calcutron, and I cut Reflector Mage. That card is stellar, but I found it was unneeded. White 3s are already plentiful and strong, so cutting an 3 made sense. And Geist comes out ahead, being more of a unique card. Also I think it's stronger. Verdict is needed for wrath saturation at my size.