Quote from rantipole »
4. Need to establish how to rank "best." I think last time we did it by measuring how likely you are to win if the card resolves.
Quote from wtwlf123 »I would vote for classifying everything where it's intrinsically best. Including Hierarch in Bant and phyrexian mana in its respective color.
Quote from wtwlf123 »That always baffles me. Just because the card would still be in the cube if it only tapped for G doesn't mean that its Bant identity doesn't influence the value of the card. There are absolutely decks that I play Hierarch in that would not play a Llanowar Elves.
Quote from BlackWaltz3 »Would you then consider Avacyn's Pilgrim or Elves of Deep Shadow to be a guild card?
Quote from wtwlf123 »Timeframes look good to me. 10-card guilds and 2-card shards/wedges is probably fine.
Still split on classifications and ranking criteria, though I've voiced my opinion on both.
Quote from Marl Karx »You want to classify according to color identity (or even stricter than that, since even Commander fudges on extort)