Quote from calibrettoI'd cut Signet and Proph Bolt before Electrolyze. Which should go first just depends on how much your group values Signets.
And I cut Obstinate Baloth to make room for Polukranos in my Theros update. Baloth is good, but I think a four mana 5/5 with a relevant ability outweighs a four mana 4/4 with a relevant ability.
Quote from CarlHow Does Polukranos compare to the other 4 green drops? I wouldn't cut Thrun, Deadbridge Goliath or Phantom Centaur from my cube. I could easily cut either Chameleon Colossus or Obstinate Baloth. Is there any reason why Polukranos could be a considered a Top 5 4 drop for green?
Quote from N0ohI like Polukranos more than Deadbridge, Colossus, Phantom Centaur or Baloth.
I would rank Vengevine, Master of the wild Hunt and Thrun above, still. And Wickerbough Elder for utility
So, last slot in a "top 5 4 drop", yes.
Quote from ropebreezyCut one (reasoning appreciated!):
Keiga, the Tide Star or Morphling
Diabolic Edict or Chainer's Edict or Doom Blade
Kessig Wolf Run or Ghor-Clan Rampager
Simic Charm or Prime Speaker Zegana
Indrik Stomphowler, Vorapede, Wolfir Silverheart, Thornling and Genesis
Quote from FootzChoose 3 U/B Lands:
Sunken Ruins Drowned Catacomb Underground River Bad River Darkslick Shores River of Tears and 3 U/W Lands: Mystic Gate Flood Plain Seachrome Coast Adarkar Wastes Glacial Fortress
Quote from Megiddo »You're the dude who just lies a lot and makes people hate you and then magically becomes town later, right?
Quote from noshadowkickKor Haven or Entreat the Angels?
Quote from ropebreezyThanks! Gonna sneak one more in:
Rout or Martial Coup
Quote from wtwlf123Entreat can just steal games. It's not particularly fun (the Miracle mechanic as a whole) but it is a really powerful card.
Quote from wtwlf123I get that, it's simply that Miracle has a variance that goes from below average to "whoops, I win" ...fundamentally designed in its mechanic. Topdecks are fun and exciting because it allows an ordinary card to become extraordinary in the perfect situation. Miracle falls short of turning that into a fun and interesting mechanic.
Quote from Salmo »It's just about reasonable expectations.