Quote from mechclamsAre you worried about getting two-for-one'd when using enchantments like Overgrowth?
It seems like people running Sylvan Primordial would target enchanted lands first.
Quote from nicol800Maybe Luminarch's Accord should be cut. It is really good, but not very political. People will not want you to get any quest counters on that, and your life might not get high enough. Don't necessarily take it out, but if your playgroup can get kinda irrational about biggish threats that they can try to stop just by attacking, then you might want to omit it.
Quote from SonikPlaying enchantress rigs the exchange in your favor almost every time. If you draw a card off Argothian Enchantress when you first play the enchantment it's a one-for-one, not a two-for-one (this is the reason we play enchantment-based ramp-- I'll take a cantrip Overgrowth over a Kodama's Reach every time... guess which one also buffs up Serra's Sanctum?). And it's probably better they killed that than my Enchantress's Presence. More likely than not the ramp enchants are going to be ignored while the more annoying ones like Rest in Peace or Luminarch Ascension or Mana Reflection are the ones that will be hit with targeted removal.
Quote from mechclamsAh, I see. I had not considered that.
Out of curiosity, why did you select Trostani as the general over, say, Rhys the Redeemed?
Quote from SonikRhys is way too easy. He's the best token general these colors can probably ever hope to have... but in my personal opinion you gotta have have some style points in this format. I get more out of making "meh" Commanders into good and fun decks than just playing with the best ones.
Quote from mechclamsI completely understand.
Is the deck list in the first post up to date?
Quote from ryand83have you guys thought of crystal chimes? seems like it would fit in an enchantress deck even if they wipe the board you can get it all right back
Quote from mechclamsWhat are your thoughts on Compost and Runed Halo?
Quote from mechclamsOh, okay.
Do you have any suggestions for what to cut for Humility and Gossamer Chains?
I'm also interested in running Faith's Reward.
Quote from OCPunisherCouple of generic suggestions for you:
- When I read through your list, I get the feeling that your deck has a lot of expensive spells in it, specifically when it comes to making tokens. I might trim one or two of those and make yourself a little less clunky.
- Another thing I notice is that you are running all of the Wild Growth-type effects to make extra mana. I understand that you're going for the enchantress theme, but if I'm sitting at your table and I have a random Acidic Slime without a really good target, I'm going to think twice about blowing up your enchanted land. Or, if I happen to blow the board with a Pernicious Deed, Austere Command, or something like that, you'll be set a lot farther back than the guy who uses the Rampant Growth-effects. In spite of your overall theme (which is fine), these particular enchantments seem a little too risky for my liking.