Quote from DaemionWould it be possible to name us the reasons for each banned card (in the "As well as the following cards" list)?
Quote from AcardusI'm curious about certain stores in my area are still using the EDH.net site as their source for banned cards. Is it ok for some people to post 1v1 deck despite that other people [i.e. like me] are still using SDT, Sol Ring and etc?
Quote from love_blanketThe problem with defining [EDH] by what is "fun" is that everyone seems to define fun as what they don't lose to. If you keep losing to easily answered cards, that means you should improve your deck. If you don't want to improve your deck, then you should come to peace with the idea that you are going to lose because you chose to not interact with better strategies.
Quote from Tapped.outDoes 21 general damage still kill a player in 1v1 edh?
Quote from Surging Chaos- All other normal EDH rules regarding deck construction, generals, mulligans, paths of victory, etc. are unchanged.
Quote from outoutnew oficial bans 2010.06.20 - bye bye Arcum
Quote from Sheldon »Paradox Engine is a more defensive card.
Quote from KabukiHum...
I don't have a great experience of competitive EDH, but my opinion is that Braid, Rofellos, Erayo and Clique deserve a ban.
When you see a general who come fast, and win the game if opponent don't have a removal he can use in the turn, I think it's better to ban this General, for exemple. Rofellos means "You lose your lands turn 3"... Braid means "Now, you'll lose your board"... Erayo means "I'll counter all your spells"... Clique is a little different cause it only means bounce, bounce, counter, bounce, counter, counter, bounce... In fact, they are not funny.
But I have a strange vision of EDH. For me, it's a funny format wich normaly means that you'll play originals decks and Generals, and not just two cause they're broken and win all.
Quote from KabukiOh, I don't play Standart cause chosing between 1/2/3 decks when I see the possibilities of Magic seem... lame. For me.
If 1vs1 EDH become "You play Rofellos or Clique ?", it's a shame. And not fun at all, finaly. Then, I encourage the ban of broken Generals and cards, with the hope that will diversify the format. Even in competitive mode.
After, I don't make the banlists...
(And no offense taken, don't worry.)