Commander Rules Discussion Forum

Your one-stop shop for discussing the rules or ban list

Read This Commander Forum Rules - (NO DECKLISTS IN MAIN FORUM!) by ISBPathfinder Apr 6, 2012

Topic	Latest Post	Replies	Views
[Official] General Discussion of the Official Multiplayer Banlist >> by viperesque Oct 17, 2010 1 2 3 4 5 1281 →	by Taleran May 26, 2018	32,053	1,693,841
[Official] General Discussion of the MTGO Banlist Thread >> by Jivanmukta May 3, 2017 1 2 3 4	by Onering May 12, 2018	76	7,449
Commander Rulings FAQ >> by cryogen Mar 19, 2011 1 2 3	by ChazA4 Nov 7, 2017	69	35,471
[Duel Commander] General Discussion of the Official Duel Commander Banlist >> by Airithne May 24, 2016 1 2	by FearDReaper Dec 17, 2016	32	4,974
Read This Commander Rules Discussion Forum Guidelines and SCD/Official Threads - (NO RULES QUESTIONS IN THIS FORUM) >> by cryogen May 24, 2016	by cryogen May 24, 2016	0	1,489
Edgar Markov Create vs Play vs Cast >> by Captain_Alpi May 12, 2018	by Impossible May 13, 2018	6	339
[SCD] Serra Ascendant needs to be banned >> by Gashnaw May 1, 2018 1 2 3 4	by Shadowkass May 13, 2018	75	2,180
If you attack a player with a copy of a commander using helm of the host, would it still count as commander damage? >> by Masumaro, first to crush all May 5, 2018	by MRHblue May 5, 2018	1	236
[Casual] What happens with Demonic Pact when it causes an opponent to loose the game? >> by LaXoZ May 4, 2018	by MRHblue May 4, 2018	2	169
[MCD] Should sideboards be allowed in the official rules? >> by Dunharrow Feb 23, 2018 1 2	by Zemarr May 3, 2018	35	1,845
Other cards to speculate to get unbanned from edh eventually >> by Ryperior74 Apr 25, 2017 1 2	by MatthewB May 1, 2018	49	5,003
Rashmi, Eternities Crafter: Just a Staple or Too Ubiquitous >> by JWK Feb 2, 2018	by Ertai Planeswalker Apr 23, 2018	9	1,516
[SCD] Coalition Victory >> by osieorb18 Sep 4, 2016 1 2 3 4 5 16 →	by Buffsam89 Apr 17, 2018	394	15,588
Non-Sheldon RC AMA >> by papa_funk Mar 26, 2018	by Buffsam89 Apr 17, 2018	11	617
Brawl / Commander and the Command Zone >> by Taleran Apr 10, 2018	by Forgotten One Apr 10, 2018	2	593
Brawl, Planeswalkers and Commander >> (1 Viewing) by Sadida Mar 23, 2018 1 2	by illakunsaa Mar 30, 2018	25	4,322
Tabernacle Ban? >> by Wizmin Mar 22, 2018 1 2	by MRHblue Mar 24, 2018	31	1,204
If Ancestral Recall and Time Walk were unbanned... >> by Wizmin Mar 22, 2018 1 2	by Hawk7915 Mar 23, 2018	37	1,023
Bad River in UR Deck? >> by EmployingBeef2 Mar 17, 2018	by Airithne Mar 18, 2018	2	359
Summary Dismissal and suspend >> by Rooolandd Mar 10, 2018	by Airithne Mar 14, 2018	8	499
Can Silumgar Sorcerer exploit himself? >> by Mitchlb Mar 6, 2018	by Lithl Mar 8, 2018	9	514
[SCD] Panoptic Mirror >> by arrogantAxolotl Sep 22, 2016	by Onering Mar 1, 2018	13	2,837
[Official] The (Multiplayer) Mulligan Rule Discussion Thread >> by cryogen Sep 29, 2015 1 2 3 4 5 13 →	by BloodyWednesday Feb 15, 2018	305	17,342
Idea for a modular banlist >> by Onering Dec 26, 2017	by Hermes_ Jan 11, 2018	15	817
Ruling question between me and a friend. >> by 42Oracle Jan 4, 2018	by WizardMN Jan 4, 2018	1	335
Wizards needs to own Commander with some format friendly rulings >> by kamikaziechameleon Nov 7, 2017 1 2 3	by DementedKirby Jan 1, 2018	62	3,791
[POLL] Planeswalkers as playable generals >> by Ph03niX Jul 6, 2017 1 2 3	by methup Dec 20, 2017	61	5,201
Wii Banlist >> by Atlanntis Dec 9, 2017 1 2	by Atlanntis Dec 16, 2017	46	2,517
Likely a dumb question >> by Dragoon Fighter Nov 5, 2017	by Dragoon Fighter Nov 8, 2017	6	720
Inala ruling with transform. >> by LokiSukaido Nov 4, 2017	by ISBPathfinder Nov 6, 2017	3	629
Ban Stonehorn Dignitary? >> by Snappee Oct 6, 2017 1 2	by Onering Nov 2, 2017	32	2,756
Old lands - (eg Tropical Island, Underground Sea, etc) >> by HalcyonPriory Oct 25, 2017	by ISBPathfinder Oct 25, 2017	3	723
[SCD] Painter's Servant >> by Jivanmukta May 31, 2016 1 2 3 4 5	by MuzzleMuffin Oct 9, 2017	101	14,519
Card interaction >> by Arlochorim Oct 8, 2017	by Vrenel Oct 8, 2017	1	519
Stupid question, now that all planeswalkers have been errattad to be legendary can they be commanders now? >> by borterthecleric Sep 27, 2017	by ISBPathfinder Oct 2, 2017	6	9,664
Its time for Wizards of the Coast or the greater commander community to take over the ban list and rules >> by darrenhabib Dec 15, 2016 1 2 3 4 5 7 →	by LouCypher Sep 20, 2017	154	13,052
Understanding Meren like triggers >> by morganj02 Sep 9, 2017	by Taleran Sep 9, 2017	1	633
Q&A Time Again: September 2017 >> by Sheldon Sep 7, 2017	by Sheldon Sep 8, 2017	12	975
[SCD] Paradox Engine >> by Carthage Feb 21, 2017 1 2 3 4 5 6	by BloodyWednesday Sep 6, 2017	147	12,093
Instantly ban-hammer worthy? >> by Boros_Blendo Jun 29, 2017 1 2	by plushpenguin Sep 3, 2017	32	3,963
What are the odds of Gaea's Cradle getting banned? >> by Aetherblade Aug 10, 2017	by Pokken Sep 1, 2017	7	2,349
[SCD] Gifts Ungiven >> by flaming infinity May 30, 2016 1 2 3 4	by Carthage Aug 29, 2017	79	6,686
[Casual] Banishing light on a Commander >> by Dj_Nimbusus Aug 25, 2017	by Claytonjaimes1 Aug 25, 2017	2	759
The Color Identity rule is the biggest problem with Commander >> by Pouncing Kavu Jul 12, 2017 1 2 3	by Schreckstoff Aug 4, 2017	51	6,183
[SCD] Craterhoof Behemoth >> by ISBPathfinder May 1, 2017 1 2 3 4 5 9 →	by Onering Aug 1, 2017	224	11,568
[MCD] Moxen >> by osieorb18 Jun 22, 2017 1 2	by Muspellsheimr Jul 22, 2017	45	3,044
Razaketh VS Griselbrand >> by outout123 Jul 15, 2017	by Kahno Jul 18, 2017	9	2,779
[Official] The Official Color Identity Discussion Thread >> by cryogen Jan 30, 2015 1 2 3 4 5 31 →	by osieorb18 Jul 15, 2017	752	33,626
[SCD] Cyclonic Rift >> by Prossch Jun 24, 2016 1 2 3	by WizardMN Jul 6, 2017	69	9,870
Divine Intervention >> by Onering Jun 1, 2017	by Lithl Jul 3, 2017	8	1,764

Forum Jump: