Commander Rules Discussion Forum

Your one-stop shop for discussing the rules or ban list
Topic Latest Post Replies Views
[Official] General Discussion of the Official Multiplayer Banlist >>
by viperesque
32,275 1,715,344
[Official] General Discussion of the MTGO Banlist Thread >>
by Jivanmukta
77 8,180
Commander Rulings FAQ >> (1 Viewing)
by cryogen
69 39,683
[Duel Commander] General Discussion of the Official Duel Commander Banlist >>
by Airithne
32 5,326
Read This Commander Rules Discussion Forum Guidelines and SCD/Official Threads - (NO RULES QUESTIONS IN THIS FORUM) >>
by cryogen
0 1,602
Time Warp, Capture of Jingzhou, and Temporal Manipulation >>
by Zygous
2 70
[SCD] Paradox Engine >>
by Carthage
206 15,469
Instantly ban-hammer worthy? >>
by Boros_Blendo
44 5,439
The 100-Card Deck Limitation >>
by arrogantAxolotl
35 1,029
[SCD] Torment of Hailfire >>
by Pokken
32 2,185
If Ancestral Recall and Time Walk were unbanned... >>
by Wizmin
39 1,854
[SCD] Serra Ascendant needs to be banned >>
by Gashnaw
139 6,606
Idea for a modular banlist >>
by Onering
19 1,169
[MTGO] question >>
by ppaallwwaayyss
2 161
Won right to go first, but don't wanna... >>
by ChazA4
4 391
Vehicle rule/flavour discussion >>
by Mono Black
11 435
Edgar Markov Create vs Play vs Cast >>
by Captain_Alpi
6 1,532
If you attack a player with a copy of a commander using helm of the host, would it still count as commander damage? >> 1 2,399
[Casual] What happens with Demonic Pact when it causes an opponent to loose the game? >>
by LaXoZ
2 687
[MCD] Should sideboards be allowed in the official rules? >>
by Dunharrow
35 2,778
Other cards to speculate to get unbanned from edh eventually >>
by Ryperior74
49 5,842
Rashmi, Eternities Crafter: Just a Staple or Too Ubiquitous >>
by JWK
9 2,456
[SCD] Coalition Victory >>
by osieorb18
394 17,873
Non-Sheldon RC AMA >>
by papa_funk
11 789
Brawl / Commander and the Command Zone >>
by Taleran
2 1,305
Brawl, Planeswalkers and Commander >>
by Sadida
25 6,152
Tabernacle Ban? >>
by Wizmin
31 1,740
Bad River in UR Deck? >>
by EmployingBeef2
2 450
Summary Dismissal and suspend >>
by Rooolandd
8 810
Can Silumgar Sorcerer exploit himself? >>
by Mitchlb
9 797
[SCD] Panoptic Mirror >>
by arrogantAxolotl
13 3,743
[Official] The (Multiplayer) Mulligan Rule Discussion Thread >>
by cryogen
305 18,268
Ruling question between me and a friend. >>
by 42Oracle
1 419
Wizards needs to own Commander with some format friendly rulings >>
by kamikaziechameleon
62 4,246
[POLL] Planeswalkers as playable generals >>
by Ph03niX
61 5,873
Wii Banlist >>
by Atlanntis
46 2,862
Likely a dumb question >>
by Dragoon Fighter
6 831
Inala ruling with transform. >>
by LokiSukaido
3 821
Ban Stonehorn Dignitary? >>
by Snappee
32 3,090
Old lands - (eg Tropical Island, Underground Sea, etc) >>
by HalcyonPriory
3 947
[SCD] Painter's Servant >>
by Jivanmukta
101 18,163
Card interaction >>
by Arlochorim
1 603
Stupid question, now that all planeswalkers have been errattad to be legendary can they be commanders now? >>
by borterthecleric
6 18,395
Its time for Wizards of the Coast or the greater commander community to take over the ban list and rules >>
by darrenhabib
154 13,979
Understanding Meren like triggers >>
by morganj02
1 796
Q&A Time Again: September 2017 >>
by Sheldon
12 1,086
What are the odds of Gaea's Cradle getting banned? >>
by Aetherblade
7 2,944
[SCD] Gifts Ungiven >>
by flaming infinity
79 7,168
[Casual] Banishing light on a Commander >>
by Dj_Nimbusus
2 878
The Color Identity rule is the biggest problem with Commander >>
by Pouncing Kavu
51 7,474