long story short. i am creating a hypothetical commander deck that i want to build someday. however i am very lacking in creatures atm
i have chosen kruphix as my commander as the other options kinda sucked imo.
i also have helix pinnacle in it
also a few trolly cards like: telepathy, consorship, bronze calendar, and permeating mass.
my deck also contains:
1,00 Terra Stomper
7,95 Champion's Helm
0,30 Censorship
2,00 Cast Through Time
0,50 Cackling Counterpart
0,20 Bronze Calendar
0,20 Blinding Powder
0,25 Blighted Woodland
0,75 Blighted Agent
0,20 Blight Sickle
0,75 Blatant Thievery
0,35 Biomass Mutation
0,50 Beastmaster Ascension
1,50 Skullclamp
8,50 As Foretold
0,75 Argentum Armor
1,00 Arcane Lighthouse
2,00 Sol Ring
3,00 Awakening
0,70 Animist's Awakening
0,45 Altered Ego
3,00 Allosaurus Rider
1,20 Alchemist's Refuge
0,35 Anthroplasm
0,20 Plasma Elemental
0,30 Ætherplasm
0,75 Cryptoplasm
0,50 Plasm Capture
0,75 Aetherflux Reservoir
6,00 Kruphix, God of Horizons
0,50 Permeating Mass
6,00 Temporal Mastery
2,00 Temporal Trespass
0,50 Temporal Adept
4,50 Helix Pinnacle
0,15 Telepathy
59,55 Total:
i will also throw my: Nissa, steward of elements in it, polymorpher's jest, rhonas's monument, elvish mystic, forced adaption and primal druid.
i would like to hear your opinions ofcourse. and tell wich cards should be thrown out and/or added.
this is just a casual deck also. i just grabbed the cards i saw in mtg card search
also xmage is being: you want account and test deck? nope!
and i want to keep it under 100.
the cost u see above is ofcourse the cost a local magic store selling place thing.
Is your playgroup fine with you playing un-cards like Censorship? If not, or if you don't know, you should remove all silverbordered cards.
Do you even have a game plan? Right now, it looks like you just jumbled together a bunch of cards and called it a deck. Really, it's all over the place. Playing a 100 card singleton deck is no excuse for lazy deckbuilding. If anythng it demands more attention to detail. Each deck should have a focus and a (meaning one) primary plan to win. Like with regular constructed decks, incorporating secondary strategies that have little to no synergy with the rest of the deck, will only weaken it. For example, why are you playing Telepathy? You have no way to actually abuse the information you get (I'm talking cards like Isperia the Inscrutable), and on its own the card is too weak to be played. Helix Pinnacle is another card that simply doesn't belong, unless you can get way more mana production into the deck, or ways to manipulate counters. And of course, tutors for it, so that you can get it early. But only if the card is to be your primary focus. If it's not, cut it, because then it only weakens the deck.
So before we can even start suggesting cards, you have to tell us, how you want to deck to achieve victory, and how you want it to get there in a typical game, your primary plan, no in-case-of. Because I really can't tell from your list.
(I apologize, if this comes about a bit harsh, I did not intend to be offensive.)
Card advantage is not the same thing as card draw. Something for 2B cannot be strictly worse than something for BBB or 3BB. If you're taking out Swords to Plowshares for Plummet, you're a fool. Stop doing these things!
first of all. thanks for the advice and all.
i think probably i will make a new thread that is better thought out and stuff
as well... first thread and all.
also, the reason it is a random bunch of cards grabbed together is because i am a quite *****ty deckbuilder.
now the thing i was going for is a massive manaramp, thuss god of horizons as commander. (and indestructible commander c'mon what is not to love about it)
and the second thing was to have a good amount of strong green creatures like terrastomper while having a few counterspells from blue
as in my opinion green creatures are often very cost efficient compared to blue.
counterspells i do also really need. as my group of totally more then 3 including me... they both use the premade saskia the unwielding deck. and one has many strong cards in them. including god of victory. because menace and basicly indestructible while attacking for all creatures is not op noooooo.
When you said trolly cards in those colours I directly thought of Simic Guildmage to move auras around.
Creatures with X like hydras is a good idea with Kruphix.
You can get quite far with ramp and card draw to start with as edh decks is not something you put together on the first try
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
EDH BGU Sidisi, Brood Tyrant - Lurking Zombies. GBG Sapling of Colfenor - Forest Growth and Destruction. RWU Zedruu the Greathearted - Blinking and trading. GWB Teneb the Harvester - Enchantments, you lose life I gain life. RRR Neheb the Eternal - Ping people for mana burn.
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
i have chosen kruphix as my commander as the other options kinda sucked imo.
i also have helix pinnacle in it
also a few trolly cards like: telepathy, consorship, bronze calendar, and permeating mass.
my deck also contains:
1,00 Terra Stomper
7,95 Champion's Helm
0,30 Censorship
2,00 Cast Through Time
0,50 Cackling Counterpart
0,20 Bronze Calendar
0,20 Blinding Powder
0,25 Blighted Woodland
0,75 Blighted Agent
0,20 Blight Sickle
0,75 Blatant Thievery
0,35 Biomass Mutation
0,50 Beastmaster Ascension
1,50 Skullclamp
8,50 As Foretold
0,75 Argentum Armor
1,00 Arcane Lighthouse
2,00 Sol Ring
3,00 Awakening
0,70 Animist's Awakening
0,45 Altered Ego
3,00 Allosaurus Rider
1,20 Alchemist's Refuge
0,35 Anthroplasm
0,20 Plasma Elemental
0,30 Ætherplasm
0,75 Cryptoplasm
0,50 Plasm Capture
0,75 Aetherflux Reservoir
6,00 Kruphix, God of Horizons
0,50 Permeating Mass
6,00 Temporal Mastery
2,00 Temporal Trespass
0,50 Temporal Adept
4,50 Helix Pinnacle
0,15 Telepathy
59,55 Total:
i will also throw my: Nissa, steward of elements in it, polymorpher's jest, rhonas's monument, elvish mystic, forced adaption and primal druid.
i would like to hear your opinions ofcourse. and tell wich cards should be thrown out and/or added.
this is just a casual deck also. i just grabbed the cards i saw in mtg card search
also xmage is being: you want account and test deck? nope!
and i want to keep it under 100.
the cost u see above is ofcourse the cost a local magic store selling place thing.
You should also tag your list and any cards you want to talk about, so that they can be looked up easily. Learn how to use card tags here:
http://www.mtgsalvation.com/forums/magic-fundamentals/magic-rulings/251940-cardtag-explanation-aka-you-must-use-cardtags-in
Is your playgroup fine with you playing un-cards like Censorship? If not, or if you don't know, you should remove all silverbordered cards.
Do you even have a game plan? Right now, it looks like you just jumbled together a bunch of cards and called it a deck. Really, it's all over the place. Playing a 100 card singleton deck is no excuse for lazy deckbuilding. If anythng it demands more attention to detail. Each deck should have a focus and a (meaning one) primary plan to win. Like with regular constructed decks, incorporating secondary strategies that have little to no synergy with the rest of the deck, will only weaken it. For example, why are you playing Telepathy? You have no way to actually abuse the information you get (I'm talking cards like Isperia the Inscrutable), and on its own the card is too weak to be played. Helix Pinnacle is another card that simply doesn't belong, unless you can get way more mana production into the deck, or ways to manipulate counters. And of course, tutors for it, so that you can get it early. But only if the card is to be your primary focus. If it's not, cut it, because then it only weakens the deck.
So before we can even start suggesting cards, you have to tell us, how you want to deck to achieve victory, and how you want it to get there in a typical game, your primary plan, no in-case-of. Because I really can't tell from your list.
(I apologize, if this comes about a bit harsh, I did not intend to be offensive.)
Former Rules Advisor
"Everything's better with pirates." - Lodge
(The Gamers: Dorkness Rising)
"Any sufficiently analyzed magic is indistinguishable from science."
(Girl Genius - Fairy Tale Theater Break - Cinderella, end of volume 8)
Now that we've got those out of the way, I'm a fan of Trygon Predator and Mystic Snake.
On phasing:
i think probably i will make a new thread that is better thought out and stuff
as well... first thread and all.
also, the reason it is a random bunch of cards grabbed together is because i am a quite *****ty deckbuilder.
now the thing i was going for is a massive manaramp, thuss god of horizons as commander. (and indestructible commander c'mon what is not to love about it)
and the second thing was to have a good amount of strong green creatures like terrastomper while having a few counterspells from blue
as in my opinion green creatures are often very cost efficient compared to blue.
counterspells i do also really need. as my group of totally more then 3 including me... they both use the premade saskia the unwielding deck. and one has many strong cards in them. including god of victory. because menace and basicly indestructible while attacking for all creatures is not op noooooo.
Creatures with X like hydras is a good idea with Kruphix.
You can get quite far with ramp and card draw to start with as edh decks is not something you put together on the first try
BGU Sidisi, Brood Tyrant - Lurking Zombies.
GBG Sapling of Colfenor - Forest Growth and Destruction.
RWU Zedruu the Greathearted - Blinking and trading.
GWB Teneb the Harvester - Enchantments, you lose life I gain life.
RRR Neheb the Eternal - Ping people for mana burn.