I might have somewhat of a idea of what might become legal in eternal
likely:
dice rolling and coin flips is the most obvious
Augment and host
Contraptions assemble and reassemble
cards worded like regular magic cards (examples killerbots infinity elemental, crow storm
Cards that have black border versions (example: the cheese stands alone to barren glory)
Most of the legendaries
The alt win condition cards B-I-N-G-O Blast from the Past B.O.B. (Bevy of Beebles)
Chicken and clam folk creatures
depends:
Artist/art related (these are easy to understand but mark might not allow it.)
Last strike and triple strike (if they allow it)
Squirrellink and Knightlifelink Baron von count (it’s hard to activate but might have a similar problem like leovold/black braids.)
Cards involving words or numbers (Now I Know My ABC's dodges this bullet) By Gnome Means (first ability is black it just depends if the counter part is possibly)
The cards with same art with different abilities Flock of rabid sheep (the type of token is the only problem it’s just coin flips for X tokens)
Cards involving age Grusilda, Monster Masher we're okay with this one mark may not
not happening:
Everything else but we will give most obvious
Gotcha cards
Wacky stunts
Player cards (acception is Timmy, Power Gamer that card is literally a creature Quicksilver Amulet no tap required)
Any thing involving booster packs
Body part/clothe related The Countdown Is at One
The 1/2 power creatures/donkeys
Players outside the game
Throwing cards in the air Flavor Judge Rules Lawyer Gleemax (impossible to loose with that out)
Not sure but the mini game cards are probably out (example Head to Head) Keeper of the sacred word (there’s no way in hell they will let this easy infinite +3/+3 creature)
Reminder/flavor text (they change in reprints)
Involving sets (symbols) or watermarks (reprints the symbol changes)
You really didn't put much thought into this, did you. You are basically missing out on one fundamental rule: (Outside acorn-rules) Every printing of a card has to be functionally the same. This means anything that can change on a reprint (illustration, flavor text, set symbol) should be automatically in the red section.
those 3 were in maybe but now you just made this easy for me to put those catergories in red
I might have somewhat of a idea of what might become legal in eternal
likely:
dice rolling and coin flips is the most obvious
Augment and host
Contraptions assemble and reassemble
cards worded like regular magic cards (examples killerbots infinity elemental, crow storm
Cards that have black border versions (example: the cheese stands alone to barren glory)
Most of the legendaries
The alt win condition cards B-I-N-G-O Blast from the Past B.O.B. (Bevy of Beebles)
Chicken and clam folk creatures
depends:
Artist/art related (these are easy to understand but mark might not allow it.)
Last strike and triple strike (if they allow it)
Squirrellink and Knightlifelink Baron von count (it’s hard to activate but might have a similar problem like leovold/black braids.)
Cards involving words or numbers (Now I Know My ABC's dodges this bullet) By Gnome Means (first ability is black it just depends if the counter part is possibly)
The cards with same art with different abilities Flock of rabid sheep (the type of token is the only problem it’s just coin flips for X tokens)
Cards involving age Grusilda, Monster Masher we're okay with this one mark may not
Reminder/flavor text
Involving sets (symbols) or watermarks
not happening:
Everything else but we will give most obvious
Gotcha cards
Wacky stunts
Player cards (acception is Timmy, Power Gamer that card is literally a creature Quicksilver Amulet no tap required)
Any thing involving booster packs
Body part/clothe related The Countdown Is at One
The 1/2 power creatures/donkeys
Players outside the game
Throwing cards in the air Flavor Judge Rules Lawyer Gleemax (impossible to loose with that out)
Not sure but the mini game cards are probably out (example Head to Head) Keeper of the sacred word (there’s no way in hell they will let this easy infinite +3/+3 creature)
So all the weirdest and fun cards are unlikely hehe. I'm worried by making them black border that most of the cards are going to be way too "safe". I'd like to see them go full on crazy with these un-sets. I'm worried it'll get too watered down and the "comedic" element is just too tame.
I’m trying to think like mark of the cards he would let in to the format
we wouldn't mind the comedy stuff but it’s what mark would let in is problem
I might have somewhat of a idea of what might become legal in eternal
likely:
dice rolling and coin flips is the most obvious
Augment and host (mutate is black border and that mechanic is eons more complicated than this.)
Contraptions assemble and reassemble
cards worded like regular magic cards (examples killerbots infinity elemental, crow storm
Cards that have black border versions (example: the cheese stands alone to barren glory)
Most of the legendaries
The alt win condition cards B-I-N-G-O Blast from the Past B.O.B. (Bevy of Beebles) Surgeon General Commander (even if augment misses they let it through because of the aura/mutate part)
Chicken and clam folk creatures
depends:
Artist/art related (these are easy to understand but mark might not allow it.)
Last strike and triple strike (if they allow it)
Squirrellink and Knightlifelink Baron von count (it’s hard to activate but might have a similar problem like leovold/black braids.)
Cards involving words or numbers (Now I Know My ABC's dodges this bullet) By Gnome Means (first ability is black it just depends if the counter part is possibly)
The cards with same art with different abilities Flock of rabid sheep (the type of token is the only problem it’s just coin flips for X tokens)
Cards involving age Grusilda, Monster Masher we're okay with this one mark may not
not happening:
Everything else but we will give most obvious
Gotcha cards
Wacky stunts
Player cards (acception is Timmy, Power Gamer that card is literally a creature Quicksilver Amulet no tap required)
Any thing involving booster packs
Body part/clothe related The Countdown Is at One
The 1/2 power creatures/donkeys
Players outside the game
Throwing cards in the air Flavor Judge Rules Lawyer Gleemax (impossible to loose with that out)
Not sure but the mini game cards are probably out (example Head to Head) Keeper of the sacred word (there’s no way in hell they will let this easy infinite +3/+3 creature)
Involving sets (symbols) or watermarks (reprints it changes it)
Reminder/flavor text (same as sets/watermarks)
Seems like the black border thing will make the set more marketable and maybe we'll get some legacy goodies in there?
I always hated that I'd play an UN release then never play the cards again. At least now some can have a second life in commander decks and dumb legacy brews.
A reminder of reprints so cards from mostly unstable and unsanctioned could become commander legal
from the other two sets logical guess's could be a thing most obvious is chicken egg
Those basics are gonna cost a kdiney by how pretty they are
and The shock lands are just jaw dropping and godless shrine art……I……I’m speechless
And I can't believe it I always knew one day this would happen they at long last cracked it on how to get silver border cards legal in commander the same security holo stamp thing like with UB triangle this time it’s a acorn
why do I fell i can safely wager a unmasters set (reprints but with the acorn or no acorn/oval security stamp thing.) or they redo all the un-sets but with this security stamp treatment
It might have leaked it’s sticker related
those would be good
how about “Pioneer Horizons” cards not legal in standard but legal in pioneer and the other eternal formats.
those 3 were in maybe but now you just made this easy for me to put those catergories in red
the Tricky part I was think was art because you know dang well Acornelia, Fashionable Filcher and Selfie Preservation is just fine to us it’s thinking like mark is what I’m doing
(Oh if I’m not understanding what your saying it’s my bad)
by the way the sets one I need to remind you of city in a bottle and Apocalypse Chime
I’m trying to think like mark of the cards he would let in to the format
we wouldn't mind the comedy stuff but it’s what mark would let in is problem
a d those are “guest” and “Robot”
there is a few cards that can get that typing
With robot could that be The end of “Construct” type like with “hound” to “dog”
https://scryfall.com/search?as=grid&order=name&page=2&q=type:construct&unique=cards
because almost all of them are robot like
likely:
dice rolling and coin flips is the most obvious
Augment and host (mutate is black border and that mechanic is eons more complicated than this.)
Contraptions assemble and reassemble
cards worded like regular magic cards (examples killerbots infinity elemental, crow storm
Cards that have black border versions (example: the cheese stands alone to barren glory)
Most of the legendaries
The alt win condition cards
B-I-N-G-O
Blast from the Past
B.O.B. (Bevy of Beebles)
Surgeon General Commander (even if augment misses they let it through because of the aura/mutate part)
Chicken and clam folk creatures
depends:
Artist/art related (these are easy to understand but mark might not allow it.)
Last strike and triple strike (if they allow it)
Squirrellink and Knightlifelink
Baron von count (it’s hard to activate but might have a similar problem like leovold/black braids.)
Cards involving words or numbers (Now I Know My ABC's dodges this bullet)
By Gnome Means (first ability is black it just depends if the counter part is possibly)
The cards with same art with different abilities
Flock of rabid sheep (the type of token is the only problem it’s just coin flips for X tokens)
Cards involving age
Grusilda, Monster Masher we're okay with this one mark may not
not happening:
Everything else but we will give most obvious
Gotcha cards
Wacky stunts
Player cards (acception is Timmy, Power Gamer that card is literally a creature Quicksilver Amulet no tap required)
Any thing involving booster packs
Body part/clothe related
The Countdown Is at One
The 1/2 power creatures/donkeys
Players outside the game
Throwing cards in the air
Flavor Judge
Rules Lawyer
Gleemax (impossible to loose with that out)
Not sure but the mini game cards are probably out (example Head to Head)
Keeper of the sacred word (there’s no way in hell they will let this easy infinite +3/+3 creature)
Involving sets (symbols) or watermarks (reprints it changes it)
Reminder/flavor text (same as sets/watermarks)
A reminder of reprints so cards from mostly unstable and unsanctioned could become commander legal
from the other two sets logical guess's could be a thing most obvious is chicken egg
but still this opens the door for other cards from unstable and few others from un-sets to become eternal legal
If they have the acorn symbol it’s silver border
If it’s missing the acorn symbol or has the classic oval holo stamp it’s eternal legal
and The shock lands are just jaw dropping and godless shrine art……I……I’m speechless
And I can't believe it I always knew one day this would happen they at long last cracked it on how to get silver border cards legal in commander the same security holo stamp thing like with UB triangle this time it’s a acorn
why do I fell i can safely wager a unmasters set (reprints but with the acorn or no acorn/oval security stamp thing.) or they redo all the un-sets but with this security stamp treatment