When six months go by, this conversation will still keep happening about wishes and companions until wishes are actually allowed.
Even after since not everyone is on board with wishboards this debate will IMO never really die out since it's not unanimous.
I can't speak for Perodequeso but to me It also sounded like he did not mean the rule is a non issue but that once they find a ruling that works either allowing or not allowing companions irregardless of the wishboard and that the companion will not have a huge impact on EDH either way.
As otherwise that just means for a Sultai deck for example I could just play Keruga, the Macrosage which would easily get jammed into any u/g/x deck.
While the requirements of some companions are also easy they are requirements unlike Lurtis which is literally the commmander Deckuilding rule. Sure you can play Keruga, the Macrosage as a companion but then you get no Sol Ring, Cyclonic Rift, Swiftfoot Boots, Lightning Greaves, One and Two mana Ramp and more so there is a tradeof for adding him and the others as companion.
But while I don't have a particular stance for or against SB/Wishboards allowing Companions while disallowing SB/Wishboards just Irks me to no end.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
Even after since not everyone is on board with wishboards this debate will IMO never really die out since it's not unanimous.
I can't speak for Perodequeso but to me It also sounded like he did not mean the rule is a non issue but that once they find a ruling that works either allowing or not allowing companions irregardless of the wishboard and that the companion will not have a huge impact on EDH either way.
Yes as unless your playing Relentless Rats like cards and playing U/R having Lutri is always better than not since its a free inclusion.
While the requirements of some companions are also easy they are requirements unlike Lurtis which is literally the commmander Deckuilding rule. Sure you can play Keruga, the Macrosage as a companion but then you get no Sol Ring, Cyclonic Rift, Swiftfoot Boots, Lightning Greaves, One and Two mana Ramp and more so there is a tradeof for adding him and the others as companion.
But while I don't have a particular stance for or against SB/Wishboards allowing Companions while disallowing SB/Wishboards just Irks me to no end.