Quote from Marek14 »
Also, nothing prevents you from using the Cauldron in response to a creature dying. You can reanimate a creature immediately after death, before it would be put on the bottom of the library.
Quote from MercurialMemory »
I could, easily, be mistaken, but I'm like 51% sure that Cauldron is a replacement effect, thus never letting Atheros return anything.
As for the card...So is the process of being brought back via Cauldron so horrifying that your guys would rather flee to the endless purgatory of your deck than go to the graveyard to be brought back again? What's going on there?