I've yet to see anyone maintain a consistent opinion when it comes to multiplayer banned and restricted lists so it's unsurprising that people get confused. Unless the cards are banned in your playgroup then you're fine. It didn't magically become illegal just because another group banned its use in theirs.
I agree with what you are saying, there are a ton of different house rules out there but I don't think the other poster is saying his groups way is the only way to play. I think he is saying that 4 windfall is akin to playing 4 sol ring or 4 demonic tutor. After all, you yourself talk about how busted waste not into windfall or smothering tithe into windfall all the time. You also frequently state that you yourself are not a fan of house rules b/c of the slippery slope it creates when it comes to peoples magic cards.
Ultimately, every group should play the way they want and adjust their decks according to the power level of the group. If someone was going to play 4 windfall against me, I would assume the deck is optimized to abuse the card and I would break out my illegal decks as well. I mean at that point, no list is being followed so whatever.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
I agree with what you are saying, there are a ton of different house rules out there but I don't think the other poster is saying his groups way is the only way to play. I think he is saying that 4 windfall is akin to playing 4 sol ring or 4 demonic tutor. After all, you yourself talk about how busted waste not into windfall or smothering tithe into windfall all the time. You also frequently state that you yourself are not a fan of house rules b/c of the slippery slope it creates when it comes to peoples magic cards.
Ultimately, every group should play the way they want and adjust their decks according to the power level of the group. If someone was going to play 4 windfall against me, I would assume the deck is optimized to abuse the card and I would break out my illegal decks as well. I mean at that point, no list is being followed so whatever.