MTG Salvation

Have you considered Bind? Over the course of a game there's a lot you can point it at, and it cantrips! Also nobody expects the green player to counter a PW ultimate.

Dragonlover

Have you considered Painful Quandary? It's incidental discard which you've said gets less hate in your meta, and 5 life is nothing to sniff at if people go for that option instead.

Dragonlover

I'm gonna echo the people in the thread and recommend Hanna, Ship's Navigator, you're running enough artifacts to make her worthwhile.

Dragonlover

Dumb beaters? How about Moldgraf Monstrosity? Hits for a bunch, gets back two of your other beaters when it dies. Always does solid work for me in Molimo.

Dragonlover

Have you considered Grave Pact effects? If nothing else, every time you Pod you kill some creatures and get back some artifacts which seems pretty good.

Dragonlover

How are you breaking the symmetry on Descent into Madness? Without a constant stream of tokens to help buffer the exile I feel like you probably end up worse off than the rest of the table, but maybe I'm missing something.

Dragonlover

You've got a reasonable amount of self life loss stuff, have you considered Repay in Kind?

Dragonlover

Quote from 3drinks »

I find it impossible to leave feedback and meaningful discussion to this deck. It just...exists.

This made me laugh, so thankyou!

I first came up with the idea for the deck about seven years ago, and built it about five years ago, which is why there's such a preponderance of Kamigawa in there. Since then I've had a slightly erratic involvement in MTG and haven't necessarily picked up new cards every set/managed to get my hands on the new precons for the year.

Many of the card choices you guys have presented do make sense, so I'm not going to answer each one individually, but I am going to question the attitude of 'What does it do? It's going in a million directions? Its slow and unfocused'

It plays guys at every point on the curve (pretty much) and they're all white legends. Yes, there's a bunch of wraths. No, I don't have to windmill slam a wrath as soon as I draw it. How can I have a more defined strategy than that when I can't depend on any given commander being in the command zone? And yes, it does play differently depending who's in the zone. For example, if I got Thalia I'm probably looking to go wide whereas Akroma is aiming for the commander damage kill. People also react to the deck differently depending on who I put down. Nobody is that scared by Cho-Manno, but Elesh Norn is a different matter entirely, even though they know it's the exact same deck in both games.

I wouldn't say any given commander is better than any other, especially now I jettisoned the Myojin, mainly because of the power differential I mentioned. The worse a commander is, the more I can fly under the radar early game seems to be the general way it plays out.

Dragonlover

Anything in my sig is fair game for this thread. There's only two decks at the moment, I'll be adding more in the week.

Dragonlover

Sweet, I've created a tappedout account, turns out you can copy paste a deck across from there into deck tags here and it'll do it fine. Once I get some free time I'll get to sorting my lists out. Cheers guys!

Sadly I can't really comment on the current deck, the combo win isn't really my style. I do enjoy the fact that if the combo win is looking dicey you can just Progenitus someone in the face though, that's much more my style.

Dragonlover

I'd love to get in on this, it seems like a really cool idea. However, I don't have any decklists posted yet. Is there a quick way to put a list together elsewhere or is it gonna be a case of laboriously typing each one up?

Dragonlover