FWIW dead shadows reads were pretty bad. He maybe could have gotten there today, but yeah, I was in rhand’s pocket
I did a pretty good turnaround on you though KJ, you kept at it in a very townie way.
To the thread at large: I have no actual solid footing this game at all, and the feelings I do have are just going to be dust in the wind when we have everyone’s claims to analyze tomorrow. But rest assured, I will actually be ready for tomorrow, and I’ll stop this sort of half way meandering that I feel like I’m doing.
Are you considering his progression from you to Anak? Can we just all agree that Osie is town and force scum to kill him if so?
Also, I kinda think you’re town. The “I’m dying tonight” and subsequent reaction to that is still really bad and I’m not going to just ignore it, but if I was lynching today I’d no longer be solidly lynching you.
69 - It seems easier for him to scumread me here, the read has some subtlety, the "doesn't do improv" seems reasonable for Killjoy who doesn't really know my scumgame. A little concern because he townreads me so readily, but I'm not super opposed.
I don't think that going against the no lynch was alignment indicative; too much wine.
115 doesn't feel like a scum mislynch push. A little too genuine in feeling.
The only posts that give me huge pause so far are 127+131; it feels like a potential scum disconnect followed by an attempt to save it.
The flip onto Shadow is a little overwrought, though Killjoy does tend to be a bit that way as either alignment.
Actually, I really don't like 152. His approach to these questions is slimy and disingenuous.
Mechanics confusion and talk about specifically Rhand shooting him is tricky. It could be legit.
Huh. Shoot. I think I'm scumreading him in place of Cantrip now. Cantrip's 172 and Killjoy's response in 174 are a much better look for Cantrip and a much worse look for Killjoy.
Makes me feel significantly better about LnGrrrR too.
Hmm...
Shadow townie
Cantrip townie?
LnGrrrR townie?
Rhand townie?
Anak still not great for a lot of reasons, and 183 is another strike against him for me.
Killjoy scum.
Vote Killjoy (though still down for a no lynch otherwise.)
184 for reference.
Why do you guys keep making me talk about Osie? I don’t think the above post is high quality, but it’s not like...bad. I’m gonna go read it in context and get back to you.
How’s do you figure? Do you think it’s impossible for you to make several mistakes as scum? How are these things even connected, and why should they indicate your mindset at all? I don’t buy that any of what I’ve cited conglomerates together as indicative of anything, except careless mistakes that more often come from scum because of the content.
I do kind of buy that your insistence that this is somehow indicative is genuine, which does actually more often come from town. But again, it’s not impossible that scum you really is trying here. And I really don’t buy your scum read of me, being as I’ve engaged with you more than anyone else except maybe Cantrip, and you somehow think my scum read of you has been the least justified.
You’re missing the point. If you’re scum, you made a mistake. There’s no about of theorizing I can do that can come up with your thought process, because it would be anything sensible, it would be an “oh crap” moment.
Look at scum loves their king that just ended. One of the big things I caught DV on was the slip about scum having “pregame chat”. Nothing was going through his head, he slipped information that he shouldn’t have.
You wanna know a secret KJ? The fact that you’re actually pumping out some effort and really insistant on this is a good look. It’s why I’m still down for a no lynch and want to see where things sit tomorrow.
I did a pretty good turnaround on you though KJ, you kept at it in a very townie way.
Also, I kinda think you’re town. The “I’m dying tonight” and subsequent reaction to that is still really bad and I’m not going to just ignore it, but if I was lynching today I’d no longer be solidly lynching you.
Vote No Lynch
Why do you guys keep making me talk about Osie? I don’t think the above post is high quality, but it’s not like...bad. I’m gonna go read it in context and get back to you.
Yeah, that’s why I don’t remember his posts, cause there’s nothing there. He’d be my pick for despy shot honestly.
I do kind of buy that your insistence that this is somehow indicative is genuine, which does actually more often come from town. But again, it’s not impossible that scum you really is trying here. And I really don’t buy your scum read of me, being as I’ve engaged with you more than anyone else except maybe Cantrip, and you somehow think my scum read of you has been the least justified.
Look at scum loves their king that just ended. One of the big things I caught DV on was the slip about scum having “pregame chat”. Nothing was going through his head, he slipped information that he shouldn’t have.