I'm sorry I've been absent. Unfortunately I'm going to miss the deadline as it's 12am here and unless I get up at 3am I'm going to miss all the action.
I don't think either of KJ or Highroller are scum.
I think Chris and Tom are both town.
I think Rod is very very townie.
If there was more time I'd push for a CFD onto RE. She's been super absent and EtR was only dubiously townie. But it's too late for that.
Vez is just most likely to be scum but his role saves him for today.
KA is in a similar boat just a lot less likely to be scum.
Tubba/Vaimes have reasons I think each is town but nothing mechanical to say they are. But there just isn't enough. I don't want to condemn either but they are the best bets in the to have performed the kill as Rod is just telling the truth and I trust Chris.
LnGrrrR is more interesting to me than the above two on content alone but if we believe Chris then he didn't perform the kill last night which lowers his scum % by 2-5%. I think it makes me prefer one of Tubba/Vaimes even though I like them more behaviorally.
*shrug*
Vote: Tubba
I don't have a good feeling about it and my gut says he's town but the game state makes it hard for him not to be scum.
Vote: LnG
There was a reason not to vote him but I don't remember what it was. And having 2 people I'm not at all confident are town follow me is not great.
Will vot Tubba if this doesn't happen fast.
Going to be spotty for a bit. Family landed today. Do I'm maxo distracto.
For the record I did not realize Benito was a character in the ninja turtles world it was just the first Italian name that wasn't a ninja turtle I thought of. How I didn't land on Tony they world may never know.
Anyway my claim was very obviously not serious but the larger point was.
Vote: Vaimes
I don't have a strong read on which person in the PoE to vote. I guess Tubba's post was fine. If this makes Vaines post I'd be happy. Town!Vaimes is the best.
Also on the information front given how many people claimed trying to explain the kill situation I strongly believe anyone who had knowledge pertaining to that has claimed. If there are non protection roles there is value to keeping them hidden.
You don't get to preach about the intricacies of slight edges for mass claiming while spewing away similar small edges because you got burnt in your last game.
Well I mean you do because you can do whatever you want but it's a not a great look and makes people less likely to listen to you.
And by not doing something productive with your vote when it's obvious that town doesn't want to pursue that angle you are giving mafia more control over the game.
Also mass claiming does give mafia information. Not always valuable information but definitely information.
Too bad you're in an obvious minority. Yes you got burned in GB. That's because no one thought critically about what it meant to leave him alive and what the benefits and or costs would be.
It's like we're playing two different games... I went deep on Kami being an SK like a week ago and came to the conclusion that even if he is keeping him alive at least 1 more phase is correct. If he is an SK his targetting has to be pro town or he dies. If he's a vig then sweet.
Anyway I'm mildly surprised at the lack of Tubba momentum. I thought my tone read was the main thing keeping him alive. I guess it wasn't.
I'm happy to act on the Vez has to be dealt with by scum plan but it sure doesn't change my opinion that he's scum. More Tubba pressure please. I want this because I've been wrong about everything and I went hard on Tubba being town.
I believe Rods claim as I think he's town and KA not killing LnG suggests it's true.
If I believe all those things it seems to make LnG's chances smaller.
Anyway it's now 1:15 and I need to sleep. Cya
I don't think either of KJ or Highroller are scum.
I think Chris and Tom are both town.
I think Rod is very very townie.
If there was more time I'd push for a CFD onto RE. She's been super absent and EtR was only dubiously townie. But it's too late for that.
Vez is just most likely to be scum but his role saves him for today.
KA is in a similar boat just a lot less likely to be scum.
Tubba/Vaimes have reasons I think each is town but nothing mechanical to say they are. But there just isn't enough. I don't want to condemn either but they are the best bets in the to have performed the kill as Rod is just telling the truth and I trust Chris.
LnGrrrR is more interesting to me than the above two on content alone but if we believe Chris then he didn't perform the kill last night which lowers his scum % by 2-5%. I think it makes me prefer one of Tubba/Vaimes even though I like them more behaviorally.
*shrug*
Vote: Tubba
I don't have a good feeling about it and my gut says he's town but the game state makes it hard for him not to be scum.
There was a reason not to vote him but I don't remember what it was. And having 2 people I'm not at all confident are town follow me is not great.
Will vot Tubba if this doesn't happen fast.
Going to be spotty for a bit. Family landed today. Do I'm maxo distracto.
Anyway my claim was very obviously not serious but the larger point was.
Vote: Vaimes
I don't have a strong read on which person in the PoE to vote. I guess Tubba's post was fine. If this makes Vaines post I'd be happy. Town!Vaimes is the best.
How does my claiming Benito the watcher who hasn't seen anyone target Tom help you solve anything?
Well I mean you do because you can do whatever you want but it's a not a great look and makes people less likely to listen to you.
Also mass claiming does give mafia information. Not always valuable information but definitely information.
What can KA do if not town here?
Anyway I'm mildly surprised at the lack of Tubba momentum. I thought my tone read was the main thing keeping him alive. I guess it wasn't.
I'm happy to act on the Vez has to be dealt with by scum plan but it sure doesn't change my opinion that he's scum. More Tubba pressure please. I want this because I've been wrong about everything and I went hard on Tubba being town.