To be fair, everyone of those would work and I would pick which one you like the most.
Kruphix is best when you have alot of mana plus stuff like Seedborn Muse, bank all that stuff to keep mana open to protect your beasts
Vorel is cool, but you need the hydra out, it needs to survive and really only need just 1 big fat trampler. But it can double other stuff as well, so its focus can be broadened to stuff like Lux Cannon.
Zegana, good choice but high cmc, draws you cards but again only with a decent sized creature out, else it falls flat on its face. If there is alot of creature control then this would not be great, niether would be smashing in with hydras though.
Tatyova seems like goodstuff to me, you get to draw cards off her ramp spells, ok. Draw and ramp are necessary, seems boring to me. 5 cmc being a bit high because you would be ramping into that! Still good though.
Arimexthese(or however its spelt) is legit, its always going to ramp you from 4 to 6 (7, if you hit land drop) but can get wastelanded, ghost quartered ect. if there are no other threatning lands like coffers/cradle.
All things equal id go with the ramp commander. Draw is not a problem in simic, and better to have a reliable ramp commander and reliable draw spells than anything situational. And lower cmc is great. Works well with Kiora's Follower and such.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
Kruphix is best when you have alot of mana plus stuff like Seedborn Muse, bank all that stuff to keep mana open to protect your beasts
Vorel is cool, but you need the hydra out, it needs to survive and really only need just 1 big fat trampler. But it can double other stuff as well, so its focus can be broadened to stuff like Lux Cannon.
Zegana, good choice but high cmc, draws you cards but again only with a decent sized creature out, else it falls flat on its face. If there is alot of creature control then this would not be great, niether would be smashing in with hydras though.
Tatyova seems like goodstuff to me, you get to draw cards off her ramp spells, ok. Draw and ramp are necessary, seems boring to me. 5 cmc being a bit high because you would be ramping into that! Still good though.
Arimexthese(or however its spelt) is legit, its always going to ramp you from 4 to 6 (7, if you hit land drop) but can get wastelanded, ghost quartered ect. if there are no other threatning lands like coffers/cradle.
All things equal id go with the ramp commander. Draw is not a problem in simic, and better to have a reliable ramp commander and reliable draw spells than anything situational. And lower cmc is great. Works well with Kiora's Follower and such.