But yeah, overall, I find this setup to be more scumsided than not.
Town power always has to take information into account, since from the beginning we have next to none. And maybe it’s entirely our fault this time around - failing to use the lynch properly very much cost us the game since we couldn’t reevaluate.
I agree about flips needing to be revealed if roles are unconventional. There’s no point in giving town a one shot if all the [mostly mafia] roles are gonna have multiple abilities.
Also agree that Slimer as a mafia role should not happen again. It’s like Cantrip wanted to have his Neutral cake and eat it with mafia frosting. That role should’ve been 100% neutral if it was gonna exist at all. Slime all living players and you win, passive non-kill immunity, boom, that’s a nice logical role.
One Ghostbuster being scum is a good idea. But I dislike it in conjunction with scum having Slimer and having full information with all of their roles.
Doctorguard was pretty cool, I see no issues there mostly because Fuwaslot was scummy enough to protect half the game.
I didn’t read the full mafia abilities because I’m still salty, but the Delayer targeting two people, ever, is a no from me.
For all of DV’s usual yikes ranting I agree with a lot of what he’s saying.
tom like, blatantly softclaimed Ghostbuster early D1 tbf. Something about crossing the streams.
I think town would have stood a chance if we hadn’t No Lynched twice AND completely wasted a lynch on DV. Getting the EtR flip early would have helped so much it’s making me sad to think about it.
Yeah, I dunno. I reread what I wanted to and I still think it's EtR/Ruma + 1.
I'll be here for around an hour probably if anyone wants to chat.
Kind of skeeved out by Vaimes' bloodlust in mylo and there's almost certainly at least one wolf voting EtR right now. Unless it's, like, EtR/Kami/Ruma, which seems... unlikely.
Maybe I'm over thinking it though.
I’m yelling at you but more with emotions rather than words.
Town power always has to take information into account, since from the beginning we have next to none. And maybe it’s entirely our fault this time around - failing to use the lynch properly very much cost us the game since we couldn’t reevaluate.
Also agree that Slimer as a mafia role should not happen again. It’s like Cantrip wanted to have his Neutral cake and eat it with mafia frosting. That role should’ve been 100% neutral if it was gonna exist at all. Slime all living players and you win, passive non-kill immunity, boom, that’s a nice logical role.
One Ghostbuster being scum is a good idea. But I dislike it in conjunction with scum having Slimer and having full information with all of their roles.
Doctorguard was pretty cool, I see no issues there mostly because Fuwaslot was scummy enough to protect half the game.
I didn’t read the full mafia abilities because I’m still salty, but the Delayer targeting two people, ever, is a no from me.
For all of DV’s usual yikes ranting I agree with a lot of what he’s saying.
I think town would have stood a chance if we hadn’t No Lynched twice AND completely wasted a lynch on DV. Getting the EtR flip early would have helped so much it’s making me sad to think about it.
except tom
tom so scum
gg
There is no sane world where Riku is scum but EtR isn’t.
I voted Rod as an expression of my townread on Grape and willingness to support his Rod push.
EtR is still scum.
But I really feel like EtR/tom is the answer.
But I also want to kill Riku.
In any case EtR has to die first so it’s a problem for future!us.