I'm not even certain why I was scum read this game other than being AFK for IRL reasons.
I was pretty sure that the No kill option Bur would take and I could at least get to night.
Somehow Chad managed to get himself killed and didn't throw which was... Frustrating to say the least.
I'm also like 99% certain I ****ed up in trying to get Bur to town read me since I don't think in the history of mafia together that has ever happened.
Also, I still think the question "Prove you're town" is one of the scummiest things I've ever seen asked. Because the only real answer is "Because my actions are town because I'm town." And otherwise its just dumb.
@osie, @D_V: Tell me why you are town and should not be on the receiving end of the scalpel?
(NOT why the other should be killed)
Cause I'm town?
I refuse to answer this question any more. Its reductive.
Tell me why you are town bur.
Since I'm not actively lurking?
Since I'm trying to interact with people instead of going with the flow?
Since I'm actually interested in game state and trying to make sense of you and osie?
Osie has also REFUSED to engage me in any discussion about actions.
Claiming its all wine. Which is literally bull.
Osie is dodging arguments, scum reading me for literally being the "Only one left". While also scum reading me for posting READS about the game, and not combating the reads at all.
I think Bur is town. I'm willing to shoot first if Bur is willing to holster.
This A gives Bur approval of my shot and B I doubt Bur has come to a town read on me yet so this speeds things up.
Bur give me your top 3? Members to shoot.
Mine at this point are
Osie
Osie
Osie
Easy for you to say.
Cool.
I really like all the one liner bs you keep posting. You keep making posts on the dumbest things. Ignoring larger scale arguments. And have basically said that any analysis this game is wine, and refused to back it up.
I think it's safe to assume that scum would never waste a scalpel deflecting a town kill in this setup, therefore I think we get the most info from flipping Shadow, as the player who's been on both ends of a deflect.
Vezok is conftown at this point since, if he's scum who saved his buddy, then why does Shadow save Kami? If Shadow flips scum then we have guaranteed scum in Kami.
Unless they were looking for town cred.
However game theory suggests that overall you are right.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
I was pretty sure that the No kill option Bur would take and I could at least get to night.
Somehow Chad managed to get himself killed and didn't throw which was... Frustrating to say the least.
I'm also like 99% certain I ****ed up in trying to get Bur to town read me since I don't think in the history of mafia together that has ever happened.
Also, I still think the question "Prove you're town" is one of the scummiest things I've ever seen asked. Because the only real answer is "Because my actions are town because I'm town." And otherwise its just dumb.
I'm literally SITTING ON NO KILL.
Make a decision.
What are you talking about?
Cool
I'm doing all those things too.
So is Osie.
So is everyone else in the thread.
What else you got?
No Kill
Might change my mind. I'm just.
People I'm town reading are reading Osie as town I guess. This isn't live mafia and frankly I think my day one reads are always ******* bad.
Any thoughts other than that?
Its like Bur totally forgot that I offered to shoot if he was going to holster.
On his approval.
Cause I'm town?
I refuse to answer this question any more. Its reductive.
Tell me why you are town bur.
Claiming its all wine. Which is literally bull.
Osie is dodging arguments, scum reading me for literally being the "Only one left". While also scum reading me for posting READS about the game, and not combating the reads at all.
I've been AFK come into the game with Town reads and also post scum reads.
I literally ended up on Osie's scum list because I was AFK and he had "Cleared everyone else as town".
And now hes scum reading me for doing a lesser version of what he did?
Osie are you for real?
I reread the game.
I'd been kind of busy and hadn't had time to post yet and was really only skimming.
Reads changed after I spent some time in depth.
Plus you having your kill at end day is IMO a point in your favor.
Cool.
I really like all the one liner bs you keep posting. You keep making posts on the dumbest things. Ignoring larger scale arguments. And have basically said that any analysis this game is wine, and refused to back it up.
But yeah.
Easy for me to say because why exactly?
Unless they were looking for town cred.
However game theory suggests that overall you are right.