As for eggs, they're cetainly powerful in builds that want to recur them, for example with Second Sunrise, because they are cheap and draw cards. They're commonly used in Sydri decks, among others.
Thank you for your support, I really appreciate this
Thanks for the suggestions, I will add them asap (except for sad robot, just because he's already there :)).
As for commentary, I think being a good or bad mana rock might vary with every deck. Of course some manarocks are much, much better than the other (see Sol Ring or Mana Crypt) and should be played in every deck if possible, but there are some that are gems only for certain decks, like aforementioned Cathodion and Su-Chi or Chronatog Totem in Jalira. I might make a "Top X" manarocks in certain categories, but definitely not now.
I've always struggled with finding right mana rocks for my decks - searching magiccards.info is a really good, but also time consuming way to search for them. While the accelerants are a core parts of any EDH deck, not everyone have enough time to seach for the most optimal ones for their decks. So, to save time and make searching easier, here's the list of all mana-accelerating or mana-making artifacts (I've included things like Wayfarer's Bauble (technically not a rock) and Chromatic Star (eggs may not accelerate you but still are invaluable in certain decks)). If I ommited something worth mentioning - please do tell, I'll update the list!
MTGO: UberMower
MTGO: UberMower
As for eggs, they're cetainly powerful in builds that want to recur them, for example with Second Sunrise, because they are cheap and draw cards. They're commonly used in Sydri decks, among others.
MTGO: UberMower
MTGO: UberMower
MTGO: UberMower
Added:
I omitted Locket of Yesterdays, as I don't see any application in singleton format (if there's any, please let me know!).
MTGO: UberMower
Thanks for the suggestions, I will add them asap (except for sad robot, just because he's already there :)).
As for commentary, I think being a good or bad mana rock might vary with every deck. Of course some manarocks are much, much better than the other (see Sol Ring or Mana Crypt) and should be played in every deck if possible, but there are some that are gems only for certain decks, like aforementioned Cathodion and Su-Chi or Chronatog Totem in Jalira. I might make a "Top X" manarocks in certain categories, but definitely not now.
MTGO: UberMower
V0.98 24.03.2016 - thread created, all rocks up to Shadows over Innistrad.
V0.981 26.03.2016 - Added cost reducing artifacts
V1.1 10.07.2016 - Added Eldritch Moon.
V1.2 20.09.2016 - Added Kaladesh cards plus colorless non-artifact manadorks.
V1.4 14.01.2017 - Added Aether Revolt.
V1.5 20.04.2017 - Added Amonkhet.
V1.51 25.04.2017 - Added Chrome Mox and Mox Diamond to the Duel Commander banned list.
V1.6 10.08.2017 - Added Hour of Devastation, added section with rocks on MTGO 1v1 Commander banlist.
V1.7 10.08.2017 - Added Commander 2017.
V1.8 29.09.2017 - Added Ixalan.
V1.9 28.03.2018 - Added Rivals of Ixalan.
V1.10 11.05.2018 - Added Dominaria, plus updated MTGO banlist.
V1.11 17.07.2018 - Added Battlebond and Core Set 2019.
V1.12 27.07.2018 - Added Commander 2018.
V1.13 01.07.2019 - Added Guilds of Ravnica, Ravnica Allegiance, War of the Spark, Modern Horizons and Core Set 2020.
V1.14 12.02.2020 - Added Commander 2019, Throne of Edraine and Theros Beyond Death. Removed the MTGO and Duel Commander banlists.
V1.15 11.04.2020 - Added Ikoria and Commander 2020, plus some cards I missed from Eldraine.
V1.16 27.11.2020 - Added Core Set 2021, Zendikar Rising and Commander Legends. Removed Paradox Engine.
MTGO: UberMower
I've always struggled with finding right mana rocks for my decks - searching magiccards.info is a really good, but also time consuming way to search for them. While the accelerants are a core parts of any EDH deck, not everyone have enough time to seach for the most optimal ones for their decks. So, to save time and make searching easier, here's the list of all mana-accelerating or mana-making artifacts (I've included things like Wayfarer's Bauble (technically not a rock) and Chromatic Star (eggs may not accelerate you but still are invaluable in certain decks)). If I ommited something worth mentioning - please do tell, I'll update the list!
Last update - Commander 2020 / Ikoria
MTGO: UberMower