MTG Salvation

Deth receives .5 experience for defeating a lower level opponent in the Arena.

Bat is dead.

I'm thinking because of how many turns have passed and how you two had agreed on trying to resolve it that the bats should be dead, a lesson learned for your character. Don't worry mistakes are how everyone learns.

Bats are dead, a weapon can always be used to defend against an attack as long as there are spells per turn to pay for the action. Everything looks smooth including current life totals.

You each begin the match with 15 life. Roll a 20 sided die to determine who plays first.