Thanks for the catch. I made the changes needed. As for sub challenge 1, I just changed it to "Your card has no white mana symbols on it." My idea was just that the card isn't white in any way.
Just a clarification on monocoloered. This is only the "casting cost" or the, the color identity can be any combinations. (Colorless, gold and hybrid color cards are not momocolerd)
The commander sets are rather looser with the color pie, and Maro has not missed an opportunity to yell about Chaos Warp or Song of the Dyrads. I'd say we're about Maro strictness on color pie, which is in fact more conservative than actual print.
Which, for example, enables them to freely make cards that intentionally Appeal to only one psychographic.
I do feel the Appeal category captures this poorly. A card that really really appeals to only one psychographic is better than a card that two-three psychographics like but aren't wild about, imo. Maybe we should award two points for "This psychographic just loves this card"?
I agree with this 100% At GDC 2016 Mark Rosewater had a panel Magic: the Gathering: Twenty Years, Twenty Lessons Learned and there he has a section on the psychographic, the jest is that if you try to appeal to all, most of the time you satisfy none.
The talk on the psychographic is at about 44 mins in if anyone wants to watch it.
I was really hoping we could get Necarg's scores as well, but it has been forever now, so lets go with the three judges scores. That makes bravelion83 the winner of the April round!!
Sorry for the long wait, as mentioned in the above posts, I should have just closed it and called it on the scores we had available, my apologizes for that. But now the round is officially closed and we have a winner!
Thanks to all who participated, and a special thanks to all the Judges!!
*Edit
Round 2 is up, we are still waiting for Superbajt, I will add his contestants that passed when he is done.
*Round 1 is up.
We need some judges,
I will create the signup thread tomorrow morning.please sign up here.I agree with this 100% At GDC 2016 Mark Rosewater had a panel Magic: the Gathering: Twenty Years, Twenty Lessons Learned and there he has a section on the psychographic, the jest is that if you try to appeal to all, most of the time you satisfy none.
The talk on the psychographic is at about 44 mins in if anyone wants to watch it.
Sorry for the long wait, as mentioned in the above posts, I should have just closed it and called it on the scores we had available, my apologizes for that. But now the round is officially closed and we have a winner!
I am trying to get this one fixed by maybe swapping some things around.
No worries, I think we might gonna run late on round four anyways.
I will have round four up ASAP when I get the scores.