OK I guess it looks like everyone opted for the alternative challenge. If whoever the winner was doesn't judge or indicate that he doesn't want to, I'll judge this some time tomorrow morning.
I mean everyone still has the option of doing the winner's IIW. If everyone goes with my alternative challenge and the winner doesn't want to judge it, I guess I'll have to.
Han Solo, Renegade SmugglerBB
Legendary Creature - Human Rebel (M)
Haste, menace
Whenever Han Solo, Renegade Smuggler deals combat damage to a player, reveal the top card of your library and put that card into your hand. You lose life equal to that card's converted mana cost.
2/1
iphanx- mehrph yeah it's green land removal I suppose
AS- Though I'm sure this is ridiculously busted in certain formats, I think MtG needs to move away from destruction-as-transformation. I mean then you can just reanimate your dead thing that's supposed to have turned into something else. Exile it or put it on the bottom of its owner's library.
Winterspring- Often when I play I'm frustrated that my deathtouch creatures don't have any extra impact on planeswalkers. Then again they don't have an extra impact on players, so why would they?
Tilwin- Modes are only useful when they do very different things, not roundabout ways of achieving the same effect.
Chemtrails- eek 6 is a big number
SBF- I'd imagine clause two would rarely happen, but this first looks really swing.
AS- What is the one thing green doesn't do? Destroy creatures (except for flying). It's like the number 2 rule for green. And you're not allowed to force opponents to sacrifice a targeted creature.
NFB- What's annoying about this is that it requires exactly five targets, some of which may have to be your own lands. Even still it's far too powerful and swingy.
PPN- Why doesn't this fight?
MC- Did you not get the memo that intimidate is out?
Winner- ArchSinccubus
Next- Un-cards
ugh. judge veto of challenge: black (B) protagonists
iphanx- mehrph yeah it's green land removal I suppose
AS- Though I'm sure this is ridiculously busted in certain formats, I think MtG needs to move away from destruction-as-transformation. I mean then you can just reanimate your dead thing that's supposed to have turned into something else. Exile it or put it on the bottom of its owner's library.
Winterspring- Often when I play I'm frustrated that my deathtouch creatures don't have any extra impact on planeswalkers. Then again they don't have an extra impact on players, so why would they?
Tilwin- Modes are only useful when they do very different things, not roundabout ways of achieving the same effect.
Chemtrails- eek 6 is a big number
SBF- I'd imagine clause two would rarely happen, but this first looks really swing.
AS- What is the one thing green doesn't do? Destroy creatures (except for flying). It's like the number 2 rule for green. And you're not allowed to force opponents to sacrifice a targeted creature.
NFB- What's annoying about this is that it requires exactly five targets, some of which may have to be your own lands. Even still it's far too powerful and swingy.
PPN- Why doesn't this fight?
MC- Did you not get the memo that intimidate is out?
Winner- ArchSinccubus
Next- Un-cards
ugh. judge veto of challenge: black (B) protagonists
Heroes Unforgotten2GW
Instant (R)
Search your library for up to four legendary creature cards with different names and reveal them. An opponent chooses two of those cards. Put the chosen cards into your graveyard and the rest into your hand. Then shuffle your library.
IIW: tutors (proceed with caution)
Alternative entry
Reddit
Legendary Land (C)
When Reddit enters the battlefield, sacrifice it if it's your turn. t: Add one mana of any color to your mana pool.
Ashiok, Architect of Dread2UB
Planeswalker - Ashiok (M)
+1: Put a loyalty counter on Ashiok, Architect of Dread for each creature card in target opponent's graveyard.
-X: Target opponent reveals cards from the top of his or her library until X land cards are revealed. That player puts all cards revealed this way into his or her graveyard.
-13: Put a 9/9 black Horror creature token onto the battlefield. It has trample and "When this creature leaves the battlefield, put two tokens that are copies of it onto the battlefield at the beginning of the next end step."
(4)
Next: Weird ways of card advantage // lost in the wilderness
/judge
Legendary Creature - Human Rebel (M)
Haste, menace
Whenever Han Solo, Renegade Smuggler deals combat damage to a player, reveal the top card of your library and put that card into your hand. You lose life equal to that card's converted mana cost.
2/1
IIW: smuggle
AS- Though I'm sure this is ridiculously busted in certain formats, I think MtG needs to move away from destruction-as-transformation. I mean then you can just reanimate your dead thing that's supposed to have turned into something else. Exile it or put it on the bottom of its owner's library.
Winterspring- Often when I play I'm frustrated that my deathtouch creatures don't have any extra impact on planeswalkers. Then again they don't have an extra impact on players, so why would they?
Tilwin- Modes are only useful when they do very different things, not roundabout ways of achieving the same effect.
Chemtrails- eek 6 is a big number
SBF- I'd imagine clause two would rarely happen, but this first looks really swing.
AS- What is the one thing green doesn't do? Destroy creatures (except for flying). It's like the number 2 rule for green. And you're not allowed to force opponents to sacrifice a targeted creature.
NFB- What's annoying about this is that it requires exactly five targets, some of which may have to be your own lands. Even still it's far too powerful and swingy.
PPN- Why doesn't this fight?
MC- Did you not get the memo that intimidate is out?
Winner- ArchSinccubus
Next- Un-cards
ugh. judge veto of challenge: black (B) protagonists
AS- Though I'm sure this is ridiculously busted in certain formats, I think MtG needs to move away from destruction-as-transformation. I mean then you can just reanimate your dead thing that's supposed to have turned into something else. Exile it or put it on the bottom of its owner's library.
Winterspring- Often when I play I'm frustrated that my deathtouch creatures don't have any extra impact on planeswalkers. Then again they don't have an extra impact on players, so why would they?
Tilwin- Modes are only useful when they do very different things, not roundabout ways of achieving the same effect.
Chemtrails- eek 6 is a big number
SBF- I'd imagine clause two would rarely happen, but this first looks really swing.
AS- What is the one thing green doesn't do? Destroy creatures (except for flying). It's like the number 2 rule for green. And you're not allowed to force opponents to sacrifice a targeted creature.
NFB- What's annoying about this is that it requires exactly five targets, some of which may have to be your own lands. Even still it's far too powerful and swingy.
PPN- Why doesn't this fight?
MC- Did you not get the memo that intimidate is out?
Winner- ArchSinccubus
Next- Un-cards
ugh. judge veto of challenge: black (B) protagonists
Creature - Beast (R)
Flash
Whenever another creature enters the battlefield, you may have Pit-Bred Baloth fight that creature.
3/2
IIW: green non-artifact/-enchantment removal
Instant (R)
Search your library for up to four legendary creature cards with different names and reveal them. An opponent chooses two of those cards. Put the chosen cards into your graveyard and the rest into your hand. Then shuffle your library.
IIW: tutors (proceed with caution)
Alternative entry
Reddit
Legendary Land (C)
When Reddit enters the battlefield, sacrifice it if it's your turn.
t: Add one mana of any color to your mana pool.
Creature - Elf Scout (U)
When Llanowar Ranger enters the battlefield, untap up to two target Forests.
2/2
IIW: i don't know make whatever you want
Planeswalker - Ashiok (M)
+1: Put a loyalty counter on Ashiok, Architect of Dread for each creature card in target opponent's graveyard.
-X: Target opponent reveals cards from the top of his or her library until X land cards are revealed. That player puts all cards revealed this way into his or her graveyard.
-13: Put a 9/9 black Horror creature token onto the battlefield. It has trample and "When this creature leaves the battlefield, put two tokens that are copies of it onto the battlefield at the beginning of the next end step."
(4)
IIW: discard
Instant (C)
Scorch deals 2 damage to target creature. Add RRR to your mana pool.
IIW: rituals
avatarz- costs aren't allowed to target.
KK- no you're suspended.
what am i doing