1) I fundamentally disagree with these premises making me scum:
"His catchup in the midgame feels strongly reminiscent of my scum self"
-This isn't something that makes someone scum
"he does a lot of note taking and observing, but he doesn't really ask questions or interrogate players in his catchup."
-To me, that's what I do in a catchup post. Then through out the game I ask questions when I have them. Personally, I actually find people asking a lot directed questions a bit suspect. It seems like an attempt to look interested in scum hunting, while not really doing any real work in case-building or taking stances. I don't think asking questions is the only way to find scum.
"I would expect town Terry to ask some critical questions in his catchup"
-I'm afraid that's not really my meta, if I could say so myself. I view myself a bit more proactive/reactive. Inquisitive isn't really how I think you view me.
Okay so the mods got back to me, and said that CropCircles would get a message if he was roleblocked, which makes me think that think that CropCircles is scum who tried to wriggle his way out of the lunch D1 by claiming Friendly Neighbor and is now trying to set up something with Silver?
The only other situation that is coming to mind right now where both Silver and CC could be both town is that the possibility that Silver was ascetizied or was targeted by a scum "Rolestopper" (target a player, all actions that would affect that player fail). I'll check with the mods to see what would happen if this were the case.
However, those are very uncommon roles, and that's so unlikely to happen I'm happy with going with Occam's Razor and assume CropCircles is just lying.
Plus - his primary focus for most of Day 1 was the dkings slot and ZDS, and both have flipped town. Thiiiiiiink this is fairly clear-cut?
Vote CropCircles
Oh hi Proph, welcome back. Want to real time anything while you're here? I was just missing you from this disucssion.
If CC is lying and he just tried to throw something at Silver that stuck, wouldn't he throw it at someone that had a better chance of getting lynched? That's why I can't get W/W out of my head. Help me out here.
Also, is friendly neighbor too powerful for a 12P game?
1) I just got a discord note saying that a roleblocked player would be notified. That means either CC or Silver are lying or there is a role like commuter or something that just causes targets to miss. We could be in trouble if we go straight into this incorrectly being a thunderdome.
2) CC's target of Silver kind of tracks, he town read Silver Day 1.
Oh I have words about this, but I want JT and CC to post if they were roleblocked.
Why is this the first post of the day? Why did roleblocking become the focus of our attention since the very first post of the day?
Plug this into your calculator...
Concerted effort between CC, Vaimes and Silver to bus CC and gain town points?
im locking this in. It all lines up with pushes yesterday too
Please explain what our pushes yesterDay have to do with this story you're spinning for us, and why if I'm trying to bus CC I'm not just hellmurdering him for the red flip + town cred
I look into the details. I hell-murdered scum as 3P last game and hellmurdered too hard and it got me lynched, so there's that possibility.
Why is this the first post of the day? Why did roleblocking become the focus of our attention since the very first post of the day?
Plug this into your calculator...
Concerted effort between CC, Vaimes and Silver to bus CC and gain town points?
Walk me through this plan then. Because I think there might be some sort of game afoot but this particular iteration makes no sense to me. Anyway haven't I been the person most focused on the RB issue?
Ill try to make time tonight. I’m mobile RN and I tried but it’s too hard so i aborted
You can ask the same hypothetical question yourself if you like Terry. The mods are great at answering rules interactions questions if you give them a specific example.
You could have just said "I messaged with them on Discord". However, at this point it probably needs to be publicly posted by a mod.
"His catchup in the midgame feels strongly reminiscent of my scum self"
-This isn't something that makes someone scum
"he does a lot of note taking and observing, but he doesn't really ask questions or interrogate players in his catchup."
-To me, that's what I do in a catchup post. Then through out the game I ask questions when I have them. Personally, I actually find people asking a lot directed questions a bit suspect. It seems like an attempt to look interested in scum hunting, while not really doing any real work in case-building or taking stances. I don't think asking questions is the only way to find scum.
"I would expect town Terry to ask some critical questions in his catchup"
-I'm afraid that's not really my meta, if I could say so myself. I view myself a bit more proactive/reactive. Inquisitive isn't really how I think you view me.
If CC is lying and he just tried to throw something at Silver that stuck, wouldn't he throw it at someone that had a better chance of getting lynched? That's why I can't get W/W out of my head. Help me out here.
Also, is friendly neighbor too powerful for a 12P game?
1) I just got a discord note saying that a roleblocked player would be notified. That means either CC or Silver are lying or there is a role like commuter or something that just causes targets to miss. We could be in trouble if we go straight into this incorrectly being a thunderdome.
2) CC's target of Silver kind of tracks, he town read Silver Day 1.
More to come.
Plug this into your calculator...
Concerted effort between CC, Vaimes and Silver to bus CC and gain town points?