Also, someone please help me with meta here. Trying to eval people without a baseline for their skill level and tendencies is like flailing with a baseball bat in a darkened room.
Hm.
Gone over me already.
Umami's a novice, but she's capable of great analysis as either alignment. I don't think she's ever had an true-Mafia game as scum yet (she's played IRL and she was scum in a Avalon game here), so I would be looking for differences in that.
For example, the fact she hasn't posted yet whereas she's usually the first off the bad. But that could easily be OOG.
Ter loves playing scum and her earlier tells was that if she was obviously not enjoying herself as much, she was town, but she's gotten better at that, good for her.
For me, it'll come down to further observance for her. Like I said, I noticed something but I don't want to fell into a tunnel just yet.
He's solidly seeming Town so far yes. If he's not, it'll become clear - the whimsy is very relaxed and Town from him though, compared to the tension before.
Who are all the rest of these people and what should I know about their metas so I don't screw up my reads on them? Toss a coin to your witcher?
@Sloth- No, not his partner. I don't swing that way. I was hoping you could teach me. Like, why are you already so scummy and why I should ignore it and mislynch someone else. Kthxbye.
I'm sloth and my meta is that if you think I'm scum based on my play, you are wrong.
I think 9 people out of 10 would say that my towngame is largely indistinguishable than my scumgame, with the one being people like tom and fonti who say "something-something" as the differential...to be honest not sure if they're on to something or just think they are, but I'd advise you do do you own thing as well. Me? I think the difference is more in the end result than my overt actions.
Btw, the bolded above takes you squarely out of "RVS" range and makes your vote on me serious, therefore you have a reason - which you are not providing.
This is the second time I'm asking. Explain your surprisingly strong scumread on me, please
He's solidly seeming Town so far yes. If he's not, it'll become clear - the whimsy is very relaxed and Town from him though, compared to the tension before.
Also there's #30.
Osie, you place a lot of weight on exact wording? I think I recall that from DLP. What else do you look for?
Hey Tubba, I see you rolled Town this time. Good for you.
What are your thoughts on the exchanges on #7, #8, #10 and #12? Do the reactions read natural and townie?
I don’t get where #7 (i.e, the scumtell) comes from, #8 seems a little stilted and miffed sounding. Could be frustration at being caught?Dont really have a barometer for Ter’s normality though. #10 could be you building a box around Ter, honestly not sure I’m a big fan if that. I guess if you’re right you can look back on this and lord it over me. #12 is again weird and maybe that’s just because I don’t get the joke. It seems like a weak attempt to get you to back off so it might just be farts in the wind.
Hm. Good.
Throw in the conditional that I saw no "scumtell" and that #7 was me messing with her. What does that make #10 for you?
I like that you're arriving at some of the same conclusions on Ter's posts that I am without me having to spell it out. But more on that later.
When a humble bard
Graced a ride along
with Geralt of Rivia
Along came this song...
vote Sloth
So are you Ter's partner or what is this about?
Hi, I'm sloth. Who's Geralt of Rivia? Teach me, Az?
P.S. I'm writing a book series with Ter that has a character that goes by your handle. He is not likable.
Hey Tubba, I see you rolled Town this time. Good for you.
What are your thoughts on the exchanges on #7, #8, #10 and #12? Do the reactions read natural and townie?
Ah. I see, you're distracting me and trying to get me to change my mind by joking with me. Neat.
Hm. I came into this game planning to leave you be and let others figure you out after the fiasco in prison, but damn, I can feel the conf!bias encroaching.
I need other people around so I can focus on other things. Where is everyone?
With their friends and families? Hah! What is this, 2019?
Call me dr. sloth
Gone over me already.
Umami's a novice, but she's capable of great analysis as either alignment. I don't think she's ever had an true-Mafia game as scum yet (she's played IRL and she was scum in a Avalon game here), so I would be looking for differences in that.
For example, the fact she hasn't posted yet whereas she's usually the first off the bad. But that could easily be OOG.
Ter loves playing scum and her earlier tells was that if she was obviously not enjoying herself as much, she was town, but she's gotten better at that, good for her.
For me, it'll come down to further observance for her. Like I said, I noticed something but I don't want to fell into a tunnel just yet.
Who else don't you know?
I think 9 people out of 10 would say that my towngame is largely indistinguishable than my scumgame, with the one being people like tom and fonti who say "something-something" as the differential...to be honest not sure if they're on to something or just think they are, but I'd advise you do do you own thing as well. Me? I think the difference is more in the end result than my overt actions.
Btw, the bolded above takes you squarely out of "RVS" range and makes your vote on me serious, therefore you have a reason - which you are not providing.
This is the second time I'm asking. Explain your surprisingly strong scumread on me, please
Also there's #30.
Osie, you place a lot of weight on exact wording? I think I recall that from DLP. What else do you look for?
Hm. Good.
Throw in the conditional that I saw no "scumtell" and that #7 was me messing with her. What does that make #10 for you?
I like that you're arriving at some of the same conclusions on Ter's posts that I am without me having to spell it out. But more on that later.
Hi, I'm sloth. Who's Geralt of Rivia? Teach me, Az?
P.S. I'm writing a book series with Ter that has a character that goes by your handle. He is not likable.
What are your thoughts on the exchanges on #7, #8, #10 and #12? Do the reactions read natural and townie?
Hm. I came into this game planning to leave you be and let others figure you out after the fiasco in prison, but damn, I can feel the conf!bias encroaching.
I need other people around so I can focus on other things. Where is everyone?
With their friends and families? Hah! What is this, 2019?
...
Wow, holy crap, are you actually scum this game?
Well, that was easy.
VOTE TERRAINE
How long are Day/Nights? I just realized it's not in the intro post.