As requested, this thread is for the discussion of anything unusual.
Small update: All inquiries about foreign cards and other strange cards may now go in here. It is no longer limited to just Miscuts and misprints. - Sparki
Just a reminder about the MS Cafe Rules: No Solicitation
Users should not post offers or requests for trades, sales, or other exchanges on cards. Please leave such offers to PM or posts in a user's trade or sales thread. Posting offers or requests for a sale or trade will result in an infraction.
I'd value the Vraska around the same as AlwaysDrawing, although I don't think it's out of reach for it to be $5 more if you can find the right buyer. A lot of players probably wouldn't touch it and it's just not that extreme of a misprint for the collectors to want to jump on it.
I would personally trade for it at $5 over retail, and that's about where I'd put it.
Cheers
Your comment and all the rest of the comments about the Vraska are garbage. He's not asking what YOU value it at. In every single misprint thread people chime in with spam like this. Obviously misprints/miscuts etc.. have a niche market, everyone knows that already.
@jerbo A misprint like that should fetch considerably more than a regular one's market value if it's legal for tournament play.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
The path of the righteous man is beset on all sides by the tyranny of magical cards.
Your comment and all the rest of the comments about the Vraska are garbage. He's not asking what YOU value it at. In every single misprint thread people chime in with spam like this. Obviously misprints/miscuts etc.. have a niche market, everyone knows that already.
@jerbo A misprint like that should fetch considerably more than a regular one's market value if it's legal for tournament play.
I concur that its worth more then what people are suggesting, the only problem is that its an opinion-based market. So when they say they'd trade for it at +$5, its a valid statement, but doesn't necessarily set a gold standard. Someone that collects miscuts such as Gunslinga may pay +$20, yet you may never find that person.
Moral: All people can really do is say what they'd think would be fair, but as with any collector's market the right buyer will make all the difference in the world.
I would say make it known that you have it and sit on offers. Its a miscut planeswalker from a large set with some cool things going for it, I'd take my chances on waiting for the right offer.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from Beefhouse3D »
I like to protect frightened things perhaps. I assembled them in the fortress of beefitude for safety.
I collect misprints and unique cards as well. Square cut just isn't important to most people, that's why it's not worth as much. I'm certain there's someone out there that would trade more for it, but from all the miscut/misprint people I know, square cut new cards just aren't in demand.
I collect misprints and unique cards as well. Square cut just isn't important to most people, that's why it's not worth as much. I'm certain there's someone out there that would trade more for it, but from all the miscut/misprint people I know, square cut new cards just aren't in demand.
Cheers
Well...I'm concerned about your knowledge then. A square cut planeswalker that's potentially playable, in a set that is structured to meet the higher standards for quality than the cards were 5-10 years ago is going to fetch a good deal more than +$5 in the misprint market. I have to agree with the later posters...put the misprint out there and wait on the right buyer.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
"Talkin outta turn....That's a paddlin'. Starin' at my sandals....That's a paddlin'. Paddlin' the school canoe....You better believe that's a paddlin'!" --Jasper
What are random alpha-cut 4th edition cards worth? I can't find any on ebay either listed or completed auctions. I have a couple uncommons, and from what I found out, those are the most common. For reference, I have Tunnel, Gloom, and Green Ward.
What are random alpha-cut 4th edition cards worth? I can't find any on ebay either listed or completed auctions. I have a couple uncommons, and from what I found out, those are the most common. For reference, I have Tunnel, Gloom, and Green Ward.
From what I've seen, you'll most likely get about $2-3 for each one. They aren't really playable, so that doesn't help, and alpha-cut 4th isn't really popular. I know that CCGHouse has a few up for sale at ~$15 or so each, but I've never seen them move any.
Duel deck doesn't really matter for miscuts/misprints. I'd say maybe $10~ more then normal, as it's a popular EDH general. Playability really effects pricing; that's the main reason I put Vraska low, as she's not really playable in anything.
The 1mm border would most likely increase the value, but the amount I cannot say. If its not showing another card, its not a full value miscut though, but Sylvan Library is obviously highly playable.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from Beefhouse3D »
I like to protect frightened things perhaps. I assembled them in the fortress of beefitude for safety.
I asked about this awhile back and totally forgot about it:
Two cheap rares from INN, split halfway. By split i mean top left to bot left, to the middle, split from the magic back and face of the card. Ive never seen or heard of this.
Also, whats the 5th ed. shivan dragon misprint going for? prices seem to fluctuate a lot.
Wondering if anyone out there as a true idea what mis-stamped Guru lands like this one are worth today. I'm 100% sure of it's authenticity, that's not what I'm asking, just wondering what the market looks like for them these days. I know an Island like this sold for $525 on E-bay BIN years ago, but that was before the Guru price boom, and I'm told there are several Islands out there, but no mountains have surfaced. Any help is appreciated :).
I value cards like this at less than a normally-cut card. I know quite a few others here feel the same way because this has come up before. It's all about the buyer, though. Some people may value it higher than a normally-cut example.
Hey guys, bought a few rtr packs today and pulled a foil architect with a vertical miscut. Knowing that jace is hot right now how do you think this will effect it's price?
Hey guys, bought a few rtr packs today and pulled a foil architect with a vertical miscut. Knowing that jace is hot right now how do you think this will effect it's price?
Looks more like it was stuck to the card next to it and left a part of itself behind. If that is the case, then it would be a damaged card and subject an appropriate devaluation. Are you certain that it is indeed a misprint and not damage?
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
Small update: All inquiries about foreign cards and other strange cards may now go in here. It is no longer limited to just Miscuts and misprints. - Sparki
Just a reminder about the MS Cafe Rules:
No Solicitation
Users should not post offers or requests for trades, sales, or other exchanges on cards. Please leave such offers to PM or posts in a user's trade or sales thread. Posting offers or requests for a sale or trade will result in an infraction.
I would probably hold onto it until I could get $5 over retail, and hope to do it soon before the price crashes even further.
Special thanks to Bornnover for the Sig
Cheers
Your comment and all the rest of the comments about the Vraska are garbage. He's not asking what YOU value it at. In every single misprint thread people chime in with spam like this. Obviously misprints/miscuts etc.. have a niche market, everyone knows that already.
@jerbo A misprint like that should fetch considerably more than a regular one's market value if it's legal for tournament play.
lets trade:
http://forums.mtgsalvation.com/showthread.php?t=509405
I concur that its worth more then what people are suggesting, the only problem is that its an opinion-based market. So when they say they'd trade for it at +$5, its a valid statement, but doesn't necessarily set a gold standard. Someone that collects miscuts such as Gunslinga may pay +$20, yet you may never find that person.
Moral: All people can really do is say what they'd think would be fair, but as with any collector's market the right buyer will make all the difference in the world.
I would say make it known that you have it and sit on offers. Its a miscut planeswalker from a large set with some cool things going for it, I'd take my chances on waiting for the right offer.
Cheers
Well...I'm concerned about your knowledge then. A square cut planeswalker that's potentially playable, in a set that is structured to meet the higher standards for quality than the cards were 5-10 years ago is going to fetch a good deal more than +$5 in the misprint market. I have to agree with the later posters...put the misprint out there and wait on the right buyer.
From what I've seen, you'll most likely get about $2-3 for each one. They aren't really playable, so that doesn't help, and alpha-cut 4th isn't really popular. I know that CCGHouse has a few up for sale at ~$15 or so each, but I've never seen them move any.
Does it being from the Dual Decks matter?
Cheers
They're all like that. Neat to have, but there's no extra value associated with it.EDIT: Good to know. I've never seen the corrected version.
This is not true. The card has a corrected version. I don't know which is rarer, but these are out there too.
Click on the small icon for a larger picture.
Hope this helps.
Set to default
Does the mis-cut decrease or increase the value?
https://fieldmarshalshandbook.wordpress.com/
RUGLegacy Lands.dec
RUGBLegacy Lands.dec
RGLegacy Lands.dec
WUBRG EDH Lands.dec
UBR EDH Artificer Prodigy
B EDH Relentless Rats
https://fieldmarshalshandbook.wordpress.com/
RUGLegacy Lands.dec
RUGBLegacy Lands.dec
RGLegacy Lands.dec
WUBRG EDH Lands.dec
UBR EDH Artificer Prodigy
B EDH Relentless Rats
Two cheap rares from INN, split halfway. By split i mean top left to bot left, to the middle, split from the magic back and face of the card. Ive never seen or heard of this.
Also, whats the 5th ed. shivan dragon misprint going for? prices seem to fluctuate a lot.
I value cards like this at less than a normally-cut card. I know quite a few others here feel the same way because this has come up before. It's all about the buyer, though. Some people may value it higher than a normally-cut example.
WUBSharuumBUW
GGGOmnathGGG
RRRKiki-JikiRRR
WUBZur the "I wanna play the longest game ever" EnchanterBUW
A picture would help.
WGURBLands!WGURB
WGUInfectWGU
Legacy Lands Primer
Top 8 SCG Oakland 2014
Helpdesk
My Cube on CubeTutor
http://dl.dropbox.com/u/1322619/Photo%2031.10.12%2019%2004%2004.jpg
Looks more like it was stuck to the card next to it and left a part of itself behind. If that is the case, then it would be a damaged card and subject an appropriate devaluation. Are you certain that it is indeed a misprint and not damage?