Quote from Yandere Sliver »I can see why people think that might be too consistent for Modern and Legacy, but what would be the issue with Commander?
Quote from A_E_I_Own_U »I hate all these changes. Part of the game was the randomness. Mindless creatures bouncing off one another and now you can basically set your hand.
Quote from Crazy Pierre »Seems like a positive change, but I do not want this in Commander, people will just mull nonstop till they get their combo pieces.
Quote from Leaf »Wouldn't that just be a bigger tell to the rest of the table to be prepared for combotown?
Quote from Leaf »Quote from Crazy Pierre »Seems like a positive change, but I do not want this in Commander, people will just mull nonstop till they get their combo pieces. Wouldn't that just be a bigger tell to the rest of the table to be prepared for combotown?
Quote from Incanur »Imagine playing Vintage Dredge with this rule!
Would you even need Serum Powder anymore?
Quote from AtlasNova »Good point. Edit: That's a new aspect combo players would themselves consider more.
Quote from JaceBluesMaster »But then it means people will have to mainboard more anti-combo hate pieces - and - be forced to mulligan so they can get one or two hate cards early to counter the combo decks' now far more consistent early game.
Experiement with and with-out it, see what ends up being more efficient.
You do remember they have to ditch a few cards to the bottom right
Quote from ryuplaneswalker »Very likely not, Vintage Dredge only needs one card to really have a keep hand, it is in the very least going to increase Dredge's game 1 performances, this very possibly has a positive effect on shops too since you can get Mishra's Workshop and Lock Piece in opening hand a little easier. This could end up with Bazar and Shop getting restricted.
Quote from Anonymous >>The opposite of a sleeper:
Ugin is going to get really bad once all the fatties are colourless. I sold all mine. Sell sell sell!
He's going to be absolutely rotten. Hangarback walker has already nerfed him quite significantly. I reckon he'll be $3 junk within 2 months of rotation
Quote from sirplayalot11 »If it tests well why not just make this mulligan standard and draft exclusive and use the current one for other eternal formats? Pretty sure all of us are used to using different mulligan rules for stuff like commander, this would be no different.
Quote from Dunharrow »Time to buyout Cellar Door