When ~ enters the battlefield, exile all artefacts your opponents control until ~ leaves the battlefield.
"Our workshops are silent. Our creations have been seized. They've killed our desire to live." - Pia Nalaar
Note that the translation appears to be a bit wonky. Literal wording translates as 'exile all artefacts your opponent controls'. I'd think it would be either 'exile all artefacts target opponent controls' or 'exile all artefacts your opponents control', given that effects like these are generally worded with multiplayer formats in mind.
Interesting, I thought the revealed 5 cards days ago are going to be the only Story Highlights for this set (and would be the norm from here on)... seems there's gonna be more.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Serra Stan - Angel Enthusiast - Garruk and Tyvar thirsty follower - Flavor and Art Enthusiast
This is terrible, like its just a terrible card. Merciless Eviction is just one mana more and better. I'd hate to get this as a rare considering it really isn't that amazing. Maybe in limmited with all the artifacts but in constructed its garbage.
Yeah I don't think it's a card aimed for constructed play. I imagine that it's quite good in limited though. Five mana, sure, but Kaladesh already has some powerful artifacts and I imagine Aether Revolt will be similar, so this card will often be quite useful. Well, so long as you yourself aren't running too many artifacts.
When ~ enters the battlefield, exile all artefacts your opponents control until ~ leaves the battlefield.
"Our workshops are silent. Our creations have been seized. They've killed our desire to live." - Pia Nalaar
Note that the translation appears to be a bit wonky. Literal wording translates as 'exile all artefacts your opponent controls'. I'd think it would be either 'exile all artefacts target opponent controls' or 'exile all artefacts your opponents control', given that effects like these are generally worded with multiplayer formats in mind.
This is the correct translation of this card ability.
When Repression of the Consulate enters the battlefield, exile all artifacts your opponents control until Repression of the Consulate leaves the battlefield.
This is terrible, like its just a terrible card. Merciless Eviction is just one mana more and better. I'd hate to get this as a rare considering it really isn't that amazing. Maybe in limmited with all the artifacts but in constructed its garbage.
I have to agree plenty. This could easily have cost 2WW and it still wouldn't be as strong as Creeping Corrosion ever was during the years SoM block was in standard or Shatterstorm was at any time. For being a board artifact wiping Oblivion Ring isn't worth the 5 CMC.
This is terrible, like its just a terrible card. Merciless Eviction is just one mana more and better. I'd hate to get this as a rare considering it really isn't that amazing. Maybe in limmited with all the artifacts but in constructed its garbage.
I have to agree plenty. This could easily have cost 2WW and it still wouldn't be as strong as Creeping Corrosion ever was during the years SoM block was in standard or Shatterstorm was at any time. For being a board artifact wiping Oblivion Ring isn't worth the 5 CMC.
While I wouldn't say that the card is particularly strong it is still an interesting one in my opinion and you both forget that it only wipes your opponents artifacts. One sided board wipes have to be more costly than symmetrical ones. With all the crazy artifacts in EDH I think this card may find a place there as well. I also don't think that it will see Constructed play, but not everything has to.
It has its uses in certain commander metas too. Daretti, Scrap Savant would hate to see this card since its ability to effectively deal with enchantments are extremely limited (Chaos Warp, Spine of Ish Sah, Scour From Existence). The fact that it's an enchantment makes it relevant for decks running certain types of tutors or decks where enchantments matter, such as enchantress decks or the aforementioned Daxos the Returned. It's a very niche card, especially for decks that have access to other colours, but it's not entirely a write off.
Interesting, I thought the revealed 5 cards days ago are going to be the only Story Highlights for this set (and would be the norm from here on)... seems there's gonna be more.
1/5 was missing from the leaked cards. Yahenni's Expertise, leaked along the other four, was not a Story Spotlight.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
100% Vorthos Spike and Storyline Expert
Former Fact Prospector of the Greek Alliance.
Let this great clan rest in peace (2001-2011)
Given that it's #11, I'm going with Consulate Repression, as that fits better in the number crunch. Unless there are a whole lot of cards starting with S-Z (which I doubt) I think it's the better assumption.
This is terrible, like its just a terrible card. Merciless Eviction is just one mana more and better. I'd hate to get this as a rare considering it really isn't that amazing. Maybe in limmited with all the artifacts but in constructed its garbage.
What are you talking about? It's one mana less than Merciless Eviction and is a one-sided board-wipe for artifacts. Meaning you get to keep your own artifacts. You can even combo with Mycosynth Lattice to take all your opponents' permanents, including lands, and have basically free reign of the board for as long as it takes someone to draw enough land to rebuild or find enchantment removal.
Interesting, I thought the revealed 5 cards days ago are going to be the only Story Highlights for this set (and would be the norm from here on)... seems there's gonna be more.
Only four were revealed though and numbering started at 2/5
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Currently Playing:
Standard - Some kind of control
Modern - UB Mill (casual)
EDH - Meren's Grave Shenanigans
There's a difference between "votre adversaire" and "l'adversaire cible". The first means "opponents" and the second means "target opponent". This targets everyone. Also, it's actually not the worst card for the Panharmonicon mirrors lol.
Yeah the people calling this terrible obviously don't realize it is one sided. This is going to see standard play.
I highly doubt that. Maybe if it exiled continuously as a state based effect. Unless Mycosynth Lattice or something similar gets printed in this set (and people are GREEDY), this is a bulk rare.
Hate to rely on that old chestnut "card is good for EDH", but this card WILL see lots of play in mono-W EDH. White's weaknesses in EDH, card draw and mana ramp, are achieved through artifacts such as Staff of Nin, Gauntlet of Power and Caged Sun. To be able to keep these components on the board while temporarily hosing all your opponents will be huge.
I'm not calling this card an all-star by any means and it will be under $1 but it will almost surely see SB play. We'll just have to see what artifacts come out of this set but it seems likely we will be getting some good ones. Being able to permanently get rid of clues, thopters, and servos while also being able to slow down the decks already built around artifacts (panharmonicon, aetherworks marvel, dynavolt tower, aetherflux reservoir) means it already has corner case uses. It's only going to be better once we get the full spoiler.
It is good in commander for momo white builds leaning on artifacts to reduce whites built in weaknesses, like white's lack of ramp and card draw. And while white has access to other artifact mass removal that are more flexible destroying all there own artifacts can put a white mage quite a bit back as white (at least in control builds like my Avacyn nukes deck) needs its card drawing artifacts or risk losing the resource war in a big way to the blue, green, and black mages on the table. A opponents only artifact board wipe even if temporary is very welcomed. I will find a copy for my Avacyn nukes deck.
As for other formats, it will likely be a high draft pick in an artifact based block. It may see some sideboard action in standard if there is one or more dominant artifact/artifact token based deck(s) (likely) and W/X or W/X/X control decks are a thing, but is too slow for older formats outside of commander. My prediction is this will be a $0.50 to a $1 rare but it will see play in commander and in standard white control sideboards if white based control is a thing. I have a feeling artifact/artifact token based decks will be a thing in standard till it rotates out.
I think this is a rare only because of how artifact heavy limited will be. Would have made too many waves as an uncommon in that format, even though that is probably the more appropriate rarity for its power level.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
Mod Edit: Source
-Jay13x
Mod edit 2: the english version has been posted on the mothership title has been changed
Marquisd
Serra Stan - Angel Enthusiast - Garruk and Tyvar thirsty follower - Flavor and Art Enthusiast
Yeah I don't think it's a card aimed for constructed play. I imagine that it's quite good in limited though. Five mana, sure, but Kaladesh already has some powerful artifacts and I imagine Aether Revolt will be similar, so this card will often be quite useful. Well, so long as you yourself aren't running too many artifacts.
This is the correct translation of this card ability.
When Repression of the Consulate enters the battlefield, exile all artifacts your opponents control until Repression of the Consulate leaves the battlefield.
No, it says "Votre adversaire" which is singular "your opponent" - otherwise it would be "Vos adversaires" - your opponents.
EDIT: so it's another mistake in the translation then?
I have to agree plenty. This could easily have cost 2WW and it still wouldn't be as strong as Creeping Corrosion ever was during the years SoM block was in standard or Shatterstorm was at any time. For being a board artifact wiping Oblivion Ring isn't worth the 5 CMC.
While I wouldn't say that the card is particularly strong it is still an interesting one in my opinion and you both forget that it only wipes your opponents artifacts. One sided board wipes have to be more costly than symmetrical ones. With all the crazy artifacts in EDH I think this card may find a place there as well. I also don't think that it will see Constructed play, but not everything has to.
1/5 was missing from the leaked cards. Yahenni's Expertise, leaked along the other four, was not a Story Spotlight.
Let this great clan rest in peace (2001-2011)
Note that it says "opponents", meaning it hits them all.
EDIT: Elfrago ninja'd me on that, lol.
TerribleBad at Magic since 1998.A Vorthos Guide to Magic Story | Twitter | Tumblr
[Primer] Krenko | Azor | Kess | Zacama | Kumena | Sram | The Ur-Dragon | Edgar Markov | Daretti | Marath
Only four were revealed though and numbering started at 2/5
Standard - Some kind of control
Modern - UB Mill (casual)
EDH - Meren's Grave Shenanigans
I highly doubt that. Maybe if it exiled continuously as a state based effect. Unless Mycosynth Lattice or something similar gets printed in this set (and people are GREEDY), this is a bulk rare.
As for other formats, it will likely be a high draft pick in an artifact based block. It may see some sideboard action in standard if there is one or more dominant artifact/artifact token based deck(s) (likely) and W/X or W/X/X control decks are a thing, but is too slow for older formats outside of commander. My prediction is this will be a $0.50 to a $1 rare but it will see play in commander and in standard white control sideboards if white based control is a thing. I have a feeling artifact/artifact token based decks will be a thing in standard till it rotates out.