the graveyard busybody makes all gravyards yours and also still the original owners as well but if i have a card that says shuffle your graveyard into your library would i also shuffle those graveyards into my library because they are also technically my graveyard
Using card tags is mandatory in the Magic Rulings forum. Please check your private messages to learn how to use them. I've added them for this post.
-MadMage
First, just so you know, un-cards operate outside normal Magic, so the Comprehensive Rules don't really cover them.
Nevertheless, the CR do regulate this: Cards you don't own cannot go to a player specific zone of yours, if that player isn't you. So only cards you own can go to your library, hand, graveyard. If a card you don't own would go there, it goes to its owner's respective zone instead.
Note, that it may be, that you could put cards you own into other players' graveyards with the Busybody. But such a thing is not covered by the CR. So you either have to get an agreement from the other players at the table on how to handle it. Or you could ask the Un-Rules manager Mark Rosewater himself for a ruling on this.
Modern un-sets have Oracle rulings listed in Gatherer straight from Maro's mouth.
Here are hers:
Rulings
1/19/2018 Only you can use abilities of cards in graveyards. For example, if a spell requires that you exile cards from your graveyard, you can exile cards from any graveyard. Any card that looks at cards in graveyards looks at any or all your graveyards.
1/19/2018 Cards owned by your opponents still go to the appropriate graveyard.
1/19/2018 If an effect asks how many cards are in your graveyard, use the total number of cards in all your graveyards. However, they are still separate graveyards. If an effect affects a single graveyard, such as shuffling it into its owner’s library, only that one graveyard is shuffled in.
1/19/2018 Speaking of that, cards in graveyards are shuffled into their owners’ libraries. You won’t put any cards from graveyards you stole, er . . . borrowed into your library.
1/19/2018 If more than one player controls a Graveyard Busybody, the one that entered the battlefield most recently “wins.” The controller of that Graveyard Busybody has all the graveyards, and any other player’s Graveyard Busybody is a 0/0 that is put into the graveyard that player used to have as a state-based action.
Rulings #3 & 4 answer your questions.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
Using card tags is mandatory in the Magic Rulings forum. Please check your private messages to learn how to use them. I've added them for this post.
-MadMage
First, just so you know, un-cards operate outside normal Magic, so the Comprehensive Rules don't really cover them.
Nevertheless, the CR do regulate this: Cards you don't own cannot go to a player specific zone of yours, if that player isn't you. So only cards you own can go to your library, hand, graveyard. If a card you don't own would go there, it goes to its owner's respective zone instead.
Note, that it may be, that you could put cards you own into other players' graveyards with the Busybody. But such a thing is not covered by the CR. So you either have to get an agreement from the other players at the table on how to handle it. Or you could ask the Un-Rules manager Mark Rosewater himself for a ruling on this.
Former Rules Advisor
"Everything's better with pirates." - Lodge
(The Gamers: Dorkness Rising)
"Any sufficiently analyzed magic is indistinguishable from science."
(Girl Genius - Fairy Tale Theater Break - Cinderella, end of volume 8)
Here are hers:
Rulings #3 & 4 answer your questions.