so at my turn, I used the Homeward path to get it back so then I used Quicksilver elemental to target the player's creatures to steal again but it wasn't giving them to me
if it's right why? is it because it's the same deal with Treachery when you get it back still attached or something?
Thassa flickered an Agent of Treachery you mean? I was reading this as Thassa flickering Mirage Mirror. Use of pronouns and indexicals is not advised for setting up situations.
so at my turn, I used the Homeward path to get it back so then I used Quicksilver elemental to target the player's creatures to steal again but it wasn't giving them to me
You're saying you activated QS Elemental on an opponent's creature, and you controlled Willbreaker at that time?
Change of control effects are never tricky to apply, they don't depend on things. Each one just supersedes the previously existing ones so none of that sequence should have had any relevance to this inference: Willbreaker was on your side, so when you activated the QS ability that targeted an opponent's creature, it should trigger Willbreaker and cause you to gain control of that creature with duration [for as long as you control Willbreaker].
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Epic banner by Erasmus of æтђєг.
Awesome avatar provided by Krashbot @ [Epic Graphics].
Thassa flickered an Agent of Treachery you mean? I was reading this as Thassa flickering Mirage Mirror. Use of pronouns and indexicals is not advised for setting up situations.
so at my turn, I used the Homeward path to get it back so then I used Quicksilver elemental to target the player's creatures to steal again but it wasn't giving them to me
You're saying you activated QS Elemental on an opponent's creature, and you controlled Willbreaker at that time?
Change of control effects are never tricky to apply, they don't depend on things. Each one just supersedes the previously existing ones so none of that sequence should have had any relevance to this inference: Willbreaker was on your side, so when you activated the QS ability that targeted an opponent's creature, it should trigger Willbreaker and cause you to gain control of that creature with duration [for as long as you control Willbreaker].
that’s what I thought
looks like I got to tell the creators a glitch of the rulings on the program
thanks man
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
I had a homeward path, willbreaker, Quicksilver Elemental and mirage mirror in play
What happens is I stole some creatures with willbreaker but someone used an Agent of Treachery to take my mirage mirror, so that player can turn it into a Homeward path to get the creatures back, then flickered it with Thassa, Deep-Dwelling and took my Willbreaker
so at my turn, I used the Homeward path to get it back so then I used Quicksilver elemental to target the player's creatures to steal again but it wasn't giving them to me
if it's right why? is it because it's the same deal with Treachery when you get it back still attached or something?
Thassa flickered an Agent of Treachery you mean? I was reading this as Thassa flickering Mirage Mirror. Use of pronouns and indexicals is not advised for setting up situations.
You're saying you activated QS Elemental on an opponent's creature, and you controlled Willbreaker at that time?
Change of control effects are never tricky to apply, they don't depend on things. Each one just supersedes the previously existing ones so none of that sequence should have had any relevance to this inference: Willbreaker was on your side, so when you activated the QS ability that targeted an opponent's creature, it should trigger Willbreaker and cause you to gain control of that creature with duration [for as long as you control Willbreaker].
Awesome avatar provided by Krashbot @ [Epic Graphics].
that’s what I thought
looks like I got to tell the creators a glitch of the rulings on the program
thanks man