I have an Underrealm Lich in play. During my draw step, I want to dredge a Stinkweed Imp. Do I get to choose which replacement effect is applied to my draw, since I control both permanents?
Also. Gatherer ruling states:
Underrealm Lich’s first ability applies even if you have fewer than three cards in your library. If you have no cards in your library, you can’t lose the game for trying to draw a card from an empty library.
Yes, you can choose which replacement effect to apply between the Lich and Dredge provided you actually have enough cards to Dredge. Without enough cards, you have to apply the Lich's effect.
With regards to the Maniac, that too is a replacement effect that applies if you have no cards in your library. You are free to apply that replacement over that of the Lich in order to win the game.
I have an Underrealm Lich in play. During my draw step, I want to dredge a Stinkweed Imp. Do I get to choose which replacement effect is applied to my draw, since I control both permanents?
The reason you get to choose is because you are the player trying to draw, not because you control those permanents.
Let's say you have Underrealm Lich and an opponent has Notion Thief, and you try to draw outside of your draw step. You still get to choose which effect applies, you have no say on that.
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
Also. Gatherer ruling states:
.
So is the Lich anti-synergistic with Labotratory Maniac?
Yes, you can choose which replacement effect to apply between the Lich and Dredge provided you actually have enough cards to Dredge. Without enough cards, you have to apply the Lich's effect.
With regards to the Maniac, that too is a replacement effect that applies if you have no cards in your library. You are free to apply that replacement over that of the Lich in order to win the game.
My Sidisi commander welcome your wisdom (and my opponents will curse you ;-) )
The reason you get to choose is because you are the player trying to draw, not because you control those permanents.
Let's say you have Underrealm Lich and an opponent has Notion Thief, and you try to draw outside of your draw step. You still get to choose which effect applies, you have no say on that.