Among other things, I controlled a Panharmonicon, and a Phyrexian Vault. I paid to have a Petravark enter the battlefield.
Are these rulings correct?
a) Petravark + Panharmonicon lets me exile two lands on ETB?
b) but as Petravark has only one LTB trigger I only have to give one land back?
c) and as the abilities are separate, I can sacrifice Petravark to Phyrexian Vault, stacking the abilities so I give back the exiled land before either of the lands are actually exiled, then drawing a card and exiling two lands?
Thanks!
Private Mod Note
():
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
“Tell me who you walk with, and I'll tell you who you are.” Esmeralda Santiago Art is life itself.
a. Panharmonicon's effect applies here because Petravark is a creature and Petravark's first ability is an enters-the-battlefield ability (C.R. 603.6a).
b. Not exactly. The "exiled card" on Petravark's second ability refers to all cards in exile that were put there due to its first ability (C.R. 108.1, 607.3, 607.2a).
c. Just as in the case where Panharmonicon isn't involved, if Petravark's second ability resolves before its enters-the-battlefield ability (or abilities) would resolve, the "exiled card" on the leaves-the-battlefield ability won't refer to any cards (C.R. 607.2a), so nothing will return to the battlefield.
Among other things, I controlled a Panharmonicon, and a Phyrexian Vault. I paid to have a Petravark enter the battlefield.
Are these rulings correct?
a) Petravark + Panharmonicon lets me exile two lands on ETB?
b) but as Petravark has only one LTB trigger I only have to give one land back?
c) and as the abilities are separate, I can sacrifice Petravark to Phyrexian Vault, stacking the abilities so I give back the exiled land before either of the lands are actually exiled, then drawing a card and exiling two lands?
Thanks!
Art is life itself.
b. Not exactly. The "exiled card" on Petravark's second ability refers to all cards in exile that were put there due to its first ability (C.R. 108.1, 607.3, 607.2a).
c. Just as in the case where Panharmonicon isn't involved, if Petravark's second ability resolves before its enters-the-battlefield ability (or abilities) would resolve, the "exiled card" on the leaves-the-battlefield ability won't refer to any cards (C.R. 607.2a), so nothing will return to the battlefield.
EDIT (Feb. 19, 2018; Feb. 23, 2018): Clarification.
EDIT (Oct. 15, 2019): Add rule citation.