mirrodin71
This is some nameless mana rock I'd like to play. Never underestimate the power of Lupine Prototype (saying it as a player who likes to run Ghalta, Primal Hunger EDH). I am not sure it very well balanced but it doesn't require tapping because does the same but only for one phase which is fair. Not bad.
netn10
Create is an advanced Manamorphose which is okay in my book. Also completes the color cycle with Create. Filters mana but doesn't do much, even with the first half. Not sure how to use it for real value.
Subject16
I guess you can't use the second mode to pay for the first and third, so actually it costs 5 or 7 but at least you get 4 mana back filtered.
Gerrard's Mom
Very pleasant pseudo-Chinese menu (all abilities are green, you nailed it!) and surprisingly fair card when you need filtered mana or something. A good workhorse no less.
Jimmy Groove
Yest another interesting tech for Abzan reanimate strategies. This card is deeper than it seems which is good. Me likey.
rkohn1357
Very specific - great for instants (mostly counterspells and combat tricks I guess). Maybe a bit to much even with restrictions.
Raptorchan: Nice mana rock. I feel it like a mix between the castle sengir cyclw and Pyramid of the Pantheon. It's quite wordy, maybe youcould fit it all inside an only abylity "add w is tjere are no brick, gw if there is one, gwb ifthere are two" and so. Also, it makes more sense building it around the mutual enemy color.
Netn10: I really like the idea here but as a storm-enthusiast myself I feel this will break storm in half and hit players two tablwa away with the pieces The Looting effect is simply too powerful here. Toned down to scry, maybe juat for would be still very good but leave you the hoop of drawing the card, but still, having this effwcts together in ne card is quite too much
Gerrardsmom: Nice for limited, with great versatility and fixing functionality. The body is a bit too small to aurvive lots of comabts, though.
Subject16: A bit too dangerous in my book. Once you hit five mana, you can do any of the other two effects for very little. Land destruction and wiping are very powerful together.
Rkohn1357: Nice and simple and in a similar vein with my own submission. The limitatiin of how spending it is bif, but it doesn@t detract from the raw power this has. I would use a frailer body to keep it safe.
JimmyGrrovw: All around a cool design and in touch with the graveyard shenanigans abzan has avcess too. Even withou the creaturw dyinf this is very powerful. The ability is asking to be broken in half
Seems like a weird direction for Freyalise but maybe I'm missing something. I don't think a walker this narrow would be very popular - would have much rather seen a creature working in the stealing ability space.
Cool, very on point for Jeskai and even kind of a throwback to the free blue spells from Urza's block.
Something like "Statue of the Godsire" for a name? I think you want an intervening if clause for the wording, and it's reasonable for the deck you want it in, but kind of boring.
There is a nice Melvinity about the way the costs line up but it feels awfully weird as a card. I guess having a flashbackable one net mana ritual is probably good for something.
The land destruction is maybe a bit too cheap (nonbasics only?) but the overall package is pretty cool.
Is it supposed to trigger when you sac the enchantment? Not really sure how the parts fit together here, and the first trigger is fun but seems like it might be tough from a rules standpoint.
This is some nameless mana rock I'd like to play. Never underestimate the power of Lupine Prototype (saying it as a player who likes to run Ghalta, Primal Hunger EDH). I am not sure it very well balanced but it doesn't require tapping because does the same but only for one phase which is fair. Not bad.
netn10
Create is an advanced Manamorphose which is okay in my book. Also completes the color cycle with Create. Filters mana but doesn't do much, even with the first half. Not sure how to use it for real value.
Subject16
I guess you can't use the second mode to pay for the first and third, so actually it costs 5 or 7 but at least you get 4 mana back filtered.
Gerrard's Mom
Very pleasant pseudo-Chinese menu (all abilities are green, you nailed it!) and surprisingly fair card when you need filtered mana or something. A good workhorse no less.
Jimmy Groove
Yest another interesting tech for Abzan reanimate strategies. This card is deeper than it seems which is good. Me likey.
rkohn1357
Very specific - great for instants (mostly counterspells and combat tricks I guess). Maybe a bit to much even with restrictions.
2) mirrodin71
3) Gerrard's Mom
Raptorchan: Nice mana rock. I feel it like a mix between the castle sengir cyclw and Pyramid of the Pantheon. It's quite wordy, maybe youcould fit it all inside an only abylity "add w is tjere are no brick, gw if there is one, gwb ifthere are two" and so. Also, it makes more sense building it around the mutual enemy color.
Netn10: I really like the idea here but as a storm-enthusiast myself I feel this will break storm in half and hit players two tablwa away with the pieces
Gerrardsmom: Nice for limited, with great versatility and fixing functionality. The body is a bit too small to aurvive lots of comabts, though.
Subject16: A bit too dangerous in my book. Once you hit five mana, you can do any of the other two effects for very little. Land destruction and wiping are very powerful together.
Rkohn1357: Nice and simple and in a similar vein with my own submission. The limitatiin of how spending it is bif, but it doesn@t detract from the raw power this has. I would use a frailer body to keep it safe.
JimmyGrrovw: All around a cool design and in touch with the graveyard shenanigans abzan has avcess too. Even withou the creaturw dyinf this is very powerful. The ability is asking to be broken in half
Top three
1. Rkohn
2. Jimmy Groove
3. Gerrard's Mom
mirrodin71
netn10
Subject16
Jimmy Groove